42 minutes ago, Bombay Airconditioning said:

I hate Collingwood as much as the next person but they are so much more than Nick Daicos.

I agree BA. They would be in the top four without ND. Vs the bottom five we find ourselves in.

On 24/06/2025 at 16:56, nextskipclaz said:

Absolutely. Chandler has to go - he is the kind of player that kids you into thinking he's valuable (and many dees supporters fall for that), but Collingwood would never pick up someone like Kade Chandler - he "tries" but doesn't "do" or "create" or "stay in the game"
Please god get rid of Chandler - the role he plays running is so important and was done incredibly well by Neal-Bullen, and we've just replaced him with Chandler ad-hoc, but we can do so much better - it's such a critical position to connect with fowards and stay in the game. Sparrow has done it much more effectively this year.

Hashtag - the Chandler delusion has to end. Sorry Chin fans, please ask yourself what you really value about him. Don't be fooled by his "trying" and "battling". Neal Bullen was a "battler" but he was a far more balanced, potent and contributing player. Please for the love of God Chin fans, have a hard look at yourselves before you murder this post with your fraternal Chin wagging

We have a ton of problems. A ton of them, and some of them start at the very top of the football department chain.

However, the Kade Chandlers of the world, who probably commands $250K a year and provides good value for money in terms of his output, shouldn't be the "poster boy" as to why we've been a dismal football side since round 10 last year, as you've espoused above.

2 hours ago, Bombay Airconditioning said:

I hate Collingwood as much as the next person but they are so much more than Nick Daicos.

Yes they are, but he is a game changer, ability is one thing to have but his work rate coupled with that makes him a very special player in the Ablett jnr mould.

He would change any team overnight

He has lost the players. During our premiership contention years, we would get outplayed or outcoached but we always showed up to play. Not today. This is Bailey and Neeld era stuff.

I think today might be a real sign that Goody is on the fringe and might not make this season out.

Yep. Real "we want the coach out" type effort going on here

1 minute ago, biggestred said:

Yep. Real "we want the coach out" type effort going on here

So accurate. They look worse than Carlton.

It’s time for Goodwin to go . He and a number of other Senior players seem satisfied with their 2021 Premiership win ( and Club “legend” status ) and quite frankly lack any real hunger for more premierships. He is too close to too many players and at the same time has lost the team. The two propositions may seem at first contradictory but they are not. We need someone fresh , with new ideas, hungry for a Premiership, and who can reset the relationship between players and Coach.

Edited June 28Jun 28 by FabDemon

1 hour ago, SadDee said:

So accurate. They look worse than Carlton.

We dont have a clubroom to spraypaint.

Monday morning, pack your bags and leave Simon.

Yeah, I’ve been a Goody defender time and again.

But I think I’m done.

That first quarter broke me.

5 minutes ago, ElDiablo14 said:

Monday morning, pack your bags and leave Simon.

Yes for Caaaarysst sake

Goodwin is done, he is stale, the list is stale and all the younger players look like they hate the place. The club needs to cut their loses with Goodwin before we end up in the wilderness for the next decade.

Question really needs to be is it the coach or the players. I think with the group as it is it wouldn’t matter who was coaching we wouldn’t be a contender, having said that I think Goodwin has consistently underperformed throughout his coaching career (outside of 2021) we might not be a contender atm but we certainly should be more consistent than we have been this season which seems to be a running thing under Goodwin since day 1, you just don’t know which version of Dee’s will turn up week to week.

I think the dominance of max, petracca et al has hidden our lack of a system in general play. Now that they are becoming a little battle weary, our lack of a system is being highlighted. Max wins plenty of the ball but we should be taking it away much more.

As with every new President and CEO coming into a football club they want their own man.

I think the equally most important question is here what are the lengths of contract of our assistances?

We couldn't possibly payout Simon and 4 or 5 assistants.

Chocco, Chaplin, Bassett, Jones etc.

While your at it take that fraud Selwyn Griffiths with you and his contract.

48-49 W/L 48-39* since the flag. 9-18 since Round 11 last year. With several 50+ point defeats. Still people will defend the coaches.

Edited June 28Jun 28 by MurDoc516

11 minutes ago, Garbo said:

Question really needs to be is it the coach or the players. I think with the group as it is it wouldn’t matter who was coaching we wouldn’t be a contender, having said that I think Goodwin has consistently underperformed throughout his coaching career (outside of 2021) we might not be a contender atm but we certainly should be more consistent than we have been this season which seems to be a running thing under Goodwin since day 1, you just don’t know which version of Dee’s will turn up week to week.

Never underestimate the effect a coach has ON players.

There is undeniable talent on the list ( though arguably not as great a list as some suppose ) but the current folk in charge only manage what we witness, which is quite frankly rubbish football.

They need a fresh voice and some new ideas. Someone who lights a fire underneath them and promotes a fighting never-say-die culture rather than a mate who’s a coach. We need to develop some C.

1 minute ago, Heart Beats True said:

They need a fresh voice and some new ideas. Someone who lights a fire underneath them and promotes a fighting never-say-die culture rather than a mate who’s a coach. We need to develop some C.

Is that a 4 letter word ending in t?

Asking for a friend.

😂😂😂😂

Edited June 28Jun 28 by YesitwasaWin4theAges

This Team beat last Year’s Premier and were 1 Point off the Filth.

They can play, but they choose when to play.

That is definitely on the Coach and to a lesser degree the Captain

The internal standards are not high enough

Goodwin should do the honourable thing and step down tonight

We need new leadership in the Football Department NOW….

Back your bag Goody, we need change. Start the search now and have the coach ready before preseason starts

There'll definitely be a lot of learnings to take out of this one. Namely not allowing the opposition a 37 point head start on the back of zero structure and effort.

With this club, it is either losing after conceding a massive deficit in the first quarter then putting in a valiant effort in the final 3 qtrs in a 3-4 goal loss or inaccuracy. There are no other methods of losing.

The Carlton game last season still pisses me off going scoreless and losing by less than a kick in the end. St Kilda average like 70 pts a game in 2025 and we allowed them to kick 6 in the first quarter.

It is a continuous pattern since the flag. Season on the line and we dish out that first quarter tripe. What a complete and utter joke!

Edited June 28Jun 28 by VNightCityLegend

4 minutes ago, VNightCityLegend said:

With this club, it is either losing after conceding a massive deficit in the first quarter then putting in a valiant effort in the final 3 qtrs in a 3-4 goal loss or inaccuracy. There are no other methods of losing.

The Carlton game last season still pisses me off going scoreless and losing by less than a kick in the end. St Kilda average like 70 pts a game in 2025 and we allowed them to kick 6 in the first quarter.

It is a continuous pattern since the flag. Season on the line and we dish out that first quarter tripe. What a complete and utter joke!

Not Mentally switched on

Too much love, but not enough respect for The Club

The Jobs are just not being done…