PREGAME: Rd 18 vs Essendon

[At the break of Gawn 4,512]

2 minutes ago, Bring-Back-Powell said:

Given Essendon were kind enough not to select Goldstein we could win as many as 5 centre clearances on Saturday night.

Don’t think they could possibly get any taller. Already got 11 players above 190cm listed. They’re surely the tallest team in the AFL

Wright

Langford

Ridley

Mckay

Jones

Caddy

Stringer

Cox

Jones

Draper

Martin

I’m praying for a wet night 

[Stu 1,073]

38 minutes ago, Roost it far said:

Anyone remember the 2006?? final against freo when we played a big lump of a lad called 426 for his first game in 3 years when Mark Jamar was injured. He got completely toweled up and we literally played a man down in a cut throat final. I think Fullerton is the new Nick Smith. For me it's a wise move. We're already missing enough talent.

Fixed it for you 😂

[poita 3,944]

1 minute ago, DistrACTION Jackson said:

I imagine if it doesn’t work well they will likely change next season week.

You mean when we're out of finals contention? Fullarton should have played against West Coast, after Petty was ruled out. 

[binman 44,824]

5 minutes ago, Lexinator said:

Love how Goody got abused for being too safe. Another example of being creative - keeps playing the kids, positional changes and done so all season long through experimentation and necessity. Look forward to seeing how we go without Max, may be an early insight in a few years time.

Indeed.

And even his critics surely acknowledge he's got runs on the board this season with his left field selections.

Tmac in two weeks after ankle surgery. And selected as a defender at that.

Bbb of a limited preseason was a factor in a couple of early wins. 

Howes was excellent for rge first 8 weeks or so.

Turner as a forward and doing ok

Melk straight into the ones after 12 months out and being one of our best players.

The kolt not really left field I guess, but still it was yet another young player in the side.

[praha 11,267]

I am honestly just happy we haven't omitted anyone. Glad our mouse pack is still playing. Time to shine on the big stage.

[Demonsterative 3,021]

26 minutes ago, BAMF said:

I think Goody could have named Chandler in the ruck and you would have found a way to 100% see the logic. 😛

And given a stat for ground ball gets as a ruckman to back up the logic 😜

[whatwhat say what 23,855]

10 minutes ago, picket fence said:

The first Nail in Goodys Coffin some might say!!

Now I know you hate it I am all for it 😛

[picket fence 18,184]

3 minutes ago, poita said:

You mean when we're out of finals contention? Fullarton should have played against West Coast, after Petty was ruled out. 

No Not Fullarton...... JEFFERSON and in spite of being in the best several weeks now, Goody saying he's close and Mc Qualter same, still cant even get on the Emergency list! 

[beelzebub 23,392]

1 minute ago, poita said:

As others have said, the issue is not that we have overlooked two poor options in Fullarton and Verrell.

The issue is that we're destroying our forward structure, and potentially the players themselves, by asking Van Rooyen and Petty to play as permanent rucks, particularly against an aggressive ruckman like Draper. 

It is exceedingly poor selection and coaching, which will look even worse if we cop another injury to a key position player. 

This, this.....and........THIS..  most likely

Robbing Peter to pay Paul.

Fascinating or Foolish as others observe.

A wet night and park...   

But perhaps there's a part to this that only becomes apparent on the night. Im going with that....   or it's good night Irene 

 

 

[Oxdee 537]

14 minutes ago, poita said:

As others have said, the issue is not that we have overlooked two poor options in Fullarton and Verrell.

The issue is that we're destroying our forward structure, and potentially the players themselves, by asking Van Rooyen and Petty to play as permanent rucks, particularly against an aggressive ruckman like Draper. 

It is exceedingly poor selection and coaching, which will look even worse if we cop another injury to a key position player. 

Playing turner, petty and jvr at the same time makes us too heavy up forward. I don’t mind rotating petty and jvr 

[Tracca 862]

6 minutes ago, picket fence said:

No Not Fullarton...... JEFFERSON and in spite of being in the best several weeks now, Goody saying he's close and Mc Qualter same, still cant even get on the Emergency list! 

because hes no better than any of our forwards. keep him at casey to develop.

[seventyfour 1,248]

Who is the sub though? Woewodin again I guess - but I feel sorry for the kid. He's got talent and I genuinely wouldn't be surprised if he wanted out, maybe even back to WA.

[DistrACTION Jackson 10,728]

12 minutes ago, poita said:

You mean when we're out of finals contention? Fullarton should have played against West Coast, after Petty was ruled out. 

Well we won that comfortably so not sure how you can claim that? Unless you have a super dominant ruckman it can be a bit of a wasted position 

[48 Year Now 108]

Does anyone read into this that Petty is staying. I doubt he would happily agree to ruck if he was Adelaide bound. I think it’s ok for him to ruck, he is big enough, but of course we all worry about injury with him.

[picket fence 18,184]

5 minutes ago, Tracca said:

because hes no better than any of our forwards. keep him at casey to develop.

If he aint better than Petty as a forward ??! Please give me a break!!

[At the break of Gawn 4,512]

Thinking about this more, I think Petty was chosen because of his contested marking ability around the ground. That’s Gawn’s greatest contribution so he’s probably the best candidate. His tap work is overrated I think.

I do feel we missed a trick not selecting Tomlinson though. Essendon has a very tall forward line. 

[Oxdee 537]

6 minutes ago, seventyfour said:

Who is the sub though? Woewodin again I guess - but I feel sorry for the kid. He's got talent and I genuinely wouldn't be surprised if he wanted out, maybe even back to WA.

His decision making seems slightly slow. Hopefully this will develop with experience and age 

[forever demons 2,369]

1 hour ago, Satyriconhome said:

Wow, the sheriff of opinions comes barrelling into town, just a point you couldn't tie the shoelaces of @WalkingCivilWar as a Melbourne supporter.

I am a fan boy, I support my team no matter what,  as it is only footy, I get disappointed after a loss and enjoy the wins. It is not toxic, toxic is not allowing anybody else to have an opinion.

Back to the footy, looking forward to Roo rucking in the fwd 50, Tommy Mc in the back 50 and Petty and Turner around the ground. See what Draper thinks of that, with the occasional surprise of somebody like Clarry taking a ball up or 2

well said Saty,wish you would post more often

[Deelectable 1,043]

And Fullarton is on a two year deal.🙄

[beelzebub 23,392]

4 minutes ago, At the break of Gawn said:

Thinking about this more, I think Petty was chosen because of his contested marking ability around the ground. That’s Gawn’s greatest contribution so he’s probably the best candidate. His tap work is overrated I think.

I do feel we missed a trick not selecting Tomlinson though. Essendon has a very tall forward line. 

Or... Roo to play more in the Ruck...and Petty a supposed focus up forward.

We'll know come Sat night i guess

[beelzebub 23,392]

7 minutes ago, 48 Year Now said:

Does anyone read into this that Petty is staying. I doubt he would happily agree to ruck if he was Adelaide bound. I think it’s ok for him to ruck, he is big enough, but of course we all worry about injury with him.

Who says hes rucking ?

[Dee Zephyr 19,311]

59 minutes ago, MrFreeze said:

Don't mind it. If we had a pure ruck, we would struggle to find room for Melk, JVR, Petty and Disco. By including Petty we can rotate one of the big 3 in the ruck while keeping our forward structure similar to last week.

This ensures we include our most talented and competitive players. Fullarton and Verrel are project picks, neither are ready. 

Makes a lot of sense. 

[48 Year Now 108]

9 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

Who says hes rucking ?

You could be right. Who do you have as rucking? 

[daisycutter 30,021]

MelbourneVEssendon

FB

[25] Tom McDonald,[1] Steven May,[4] Judd McVee

[14] Jordan Ridley,[32] Ben McKay,[21] Dyson Heppell

 

HB

[24] Trent Rivers,[8] Jake Lever,[17] Jake Bowey

[37] Nic Martin,[27] Mason Redman,[1] Andrew McGrath

 

C

[15] Ed Langdon,[13] Clayton Oliver,[30] Alex Neal-Bullen

[28] Xavier Duursma,[22] Sam Durham,[16] Archie Perkin

 

HF

[36] Kysaiah Pickett,[2] Jacob van Rooyen,[32] Tom Sparrow

[35] Matt Guelfi,[23] Harrison Jones,[30] Nate Caddy

 

FF

[37] Kade Chandler,[31] Bayley Fritsch,[18] Jake Melksham

[25] Jake Stringer,[20] Peter Wright,[4] Kyle Langford

 

RUCK

[35] Harrison Petty,[7] Jack Viney,[3] Christian Salem

[2] Sam Draper,[6] Jye Caldwell,[7] Zach Merrett

 

IC

[6] Caleb Windsor,[39] Koltyn Tholstrup,[40] Taj Woewodin,[42] Daniel Turner,[45] Andy Moniz-Wakefield

 

[9] Dylan Shiel,[11] Jade Gresham,[13] Nik Cox,[19] Nick  Hind,29] Jake Kelly

 

EMG

[16] Bailey Laurie,[20] Adam Tomlinson,[33] Tom Fullarton

[12] Will Setterfield,[15] Jayden Laverde,[17] Todd Goldstein

 

Umpires

Nick Foot (2), Andrew Stephens (12), Nathan Williamson (22), Cameron Dore (28)

Edited July 11, 2024 by daisycutter

[Demon_spurs 1,984]

17 minutes ago, At the break of Gawn said:

Thinking about this more, I think Petty was chosen because of his contested marking ability around the ground. That’s Gawn’s greatest contribution so he’s probably the best candidate. His tap work is overrated I think.

I do feel we missed a trick not selecting Tomlinson though. Essendon has a very tall forward line. 

Good point, and I think it's going to be wet. Going small could be a stroke of genius