Phantom Drafts 2023

[DeeSpencer 26,091]

3 minutes ago, Garbo said:

Mistake if we don’t take Curtain at 6 assuming he is still there, Leake should still be there 11 so no need to rush and take him early if we also want him. We are set for mids and they are easier to draft or trade for if we want another next year.

I significantly doubt Leake will be available at 11. I feel Geelong would love him, as would GWS.

And what if you count Curtin as a midfielder? I prefer him as a mid than down back 

[58er 6,681]

49 minutes ago, DeeSpencer said:

I significantly doubt Leake will be available at 11. I feel Geelong would love him, as would GWS.

And what if you count Curtin as a midfielder? I prefer him as a mid than down back 

Well the Club has the say so let’s get behind their choice and after all Windsor could be great at pick11. 

I want Curtin also at 6 but I’m a key position down the track. 

[Pennant St Dee 13,324]

I really would be shocked if we even contemplated taking Collard with one of our first two picks

[manny100 1,613]

According to BF today concerning how many live picks clubs have. I Have not checked it.

Melbourne
Starting list size: 36
Out: 5 (Hibberd, Dunstan retired, Grundy, Jordon, Harms trade/FA)
In: 3 (Billings, Fullarton, McAdam trade) - plus D.Turner possibly promoted
Current senior list: 34 players
Current rookies: 4 Cat A (McVee, Sestan, Turner, Verrall) + 2 Cat B (Moniz-Wakefield, Farris-White)
Live picks: 4 (6, 11, 42, 93)
 

[Demon 16 214]

6 hours ago, manny100 said:

According to BF today concerning how many live picks clubs have. I Have not checked it.

Melbourne
Starting list size: 36
Out: 5 (Hibberd, Dunstan retired, Grundy, Jordon, Harms trade/FA)
In: 3 (Billings, Fullarton, McAdam trade) - plus D.Turner possibly promoted
Current senior list: 34 players
Current rookies: 4 Cat A (McVee, Sestan, Turner, Verrall) + 2 Cat B (Moniz-Wakefield, Farris-White)
Live picks: 4 (6, 11, 42, 93)
 

Sounds like we’ve also delisted Milkshake this afternoon, with a view to adding him back onto the rookie list.

[Demonstone 23,115]

I have complete faith in our recruitment team and whomever is selected by Jason Taylor and his colleagues, it will guarantee no Moore, Harmes, Dunn.  

[old55 23,801]

Some small variation on the theme from the ABC

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-11-06/afl-draft-rankings-top-30-harley-reid-jed-walter-zane-duursma/103039892

[binman 44,201]

1 hour ago, old55 said:

Some small variation on the theme from the ABC

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-11-06/afl-draft-rankings-top-30-harley-reid-jed-walter-zane-duursma/103039892

I rate the author, Dean bilton. 

[Ted Lasso 19,549]

The Dwight phantom draft for 2023 - assuming no live trading, which there will be. 

1. Harley Reid (WCE)
2. Jed Walter (GCS)
3. Colby McKercher (NM)
4. Zane Duursma (NM)
5. Daniel Curtin (Haw)
6. Nick Watson (WB)
7. Ethan Read (GCS)
8. James Leake (MFC)
9. Nate Caddy (GWS)
10. Riley Sanders (GEE)
11. Caleb Windsor (ESS)
12. Darcy Wilson (AFC)
13. Conner O'Sullivan (MFC)

• I think Essendons greatest list need now is a classy, quick, pure wingman so they'll target Windsor with pick 11
• Adelaide apparently really like Darcy Wilson and i expect their next pick they'll target Ollie Murphy and get another key back 
• I have Conner O'Sullivan sliding due to Wilson, Leake and WIndsor all flying up the ranks 
• I fully expect West Coast to trade pick 1 and us to attempt to move up the draft order in some capacity.  

[adonski 12,613]

9 minutes ago, Dwight Schrute said:

The Dwight phantom draft for 2023 - assuming no live trading, which there will be. 

1. Harley Reid (WCE)
2. Jed Walter (GCS)
3. Colby McKercher (NM)
4. Zane Duursma (NM)
5. Daniel Curtin (Haw)
6. Nick Watson (WB)
7. Ethan Read (GCS)
8. James Leake (MFC)
9. Nate Caddy (GWS)
10. Riley Sanders (GEE)
11. Caleb Windsor (ESS)
12. Darcy Wilson (AFC)
13. Conner O'Sullivan (MFC)

• I think Essendons greatest list need now is a classy, quick, pure wingman so they'll target Windsor with pick 11
• Adelaide apparently really like Darcy Wilson and i expect their next pick they'll target Ollie Murphy and get another key back 
• I have Conner O'Sullivan sliding due to Wilson, Leake and WIndsor all flying up the ranks 
• I fully expect West Coast to trade pick 1 and us to attempt to move up the draft order in some capacity.  

Essendon have Nic Martin, Duursma perhaps even Tsatas for their wings, Windsor would be a really odd choice for them

[Ted Lasso 19,549]

1 hour ago, adonski said:

Essendon have Nic Martin, Duursma perhaps even Tsatas for their wings, Windsor would be a really odd choice for them

I take your point, i think 13 and 11 could easily go either way, and i don't think many at the MFC would be dissapointed with Windsor or O'Sullivan 

[dee-tox 4,835]

Makes you wonder if Norf even need picks 3 and 4 given their needs.

Their midfield is stacked with likes of LDU, Simpkin, Wardlaw, Sheezel, Tarryn Thomas and Will Phillips... All high draft picks

They don't need McKercher, etc. They need key defenders, classy flankers and goal sneaks which they can pick up later. 

[bluey 1,118]

We basically take the leftovers in a shallow draft, take what’s left on the table with 8 & 13, unless West Coast accept all of our picks, plus next years, throw all our chips in  for number one.

 

[Left Foot Snap 2,501]

  .

Edited November 6, 2023 by Left Foot Snap
Accidental post

[SthSea22 655]

Disappointing to hear Orlando Turner had refused to attend the combine

No commitment by the looks of it

[Redleg 41,758]

3 hours ago, SthSea22 said:

Disappointing to hear Orlando Turner had refused to attend the combine

No commitment by the looks of it

Maybe a club told him to refuse.

[Greg Schneider 987]

2 hours ago, Redleg said:

Maybe a club told him to refuse.

Keen to rookie him are we?

[dazzledavey36 55,458]

2 hours ago, Redleg said:

Maybe a club told him to refuse.

That's not how it works..

He didn't attend because he missed his flight.

[58er 6,681]

On 06/11/2023 at 21:52, bluey said:

We basically take the leftovers in a shallow draft, take what’s left on the table with 8 & 13, unless West Coast accept all of our picks, plus next years, throw all our chips in  for number one.

 

No that’s not the case Either Windsor or O’Sullivan are good for us. But if we can go some spots higher our first pick is a better option but would rule it a second high draft pick no doubt. 

[Redleg 41,758]

9 hours ago, dazzledavey36 said:

That's not how it works..

He didn't attend because he missed his flight.

No other flights?

[SthSea22 655]

14 hours ago, Redleg said:

Maybe a club told him to refuse.

No

He stayed in Alice because he wasn't confident of testing well

[SthSea22 655]

11 hours ago, dazzledavey36 said:

That's not how it works..

He didn't attend because he missed his flight.

He didn't accidently miss his flight

[FrothiesLiam 63]

Cal twomey and Kevin Sheehan did a mock draft on gettable with Melbourne picking o Sullivan at 6 ahead of sanders and Darcy wilson with our next pick 

[2021 301]

5 minutes ago, FrothiesLiam said:

Cal twomey and Kevin Sheehan did a mock draft on gettable with Melbourne picking o Sullivan at 6 ahead of sanders and Darcy wilson with our next pick 

I never count on Sheehan to be realistic in terms of who goes where. Plus it wasn’t a Phantom Draft, just a mock draft based on needs, not on who actually goes where.

After the mock draft finished, Cal linked us to both Curtin & Caddy, which is interesting.

[Greg Schneider 987]

6 minutes ago, 2021 said:

I never count on Sheehan to be realistic in terms of who goes where. Plus it wasn’t a Phantom Draft, just a mock draft based on needs, not on who actually goes where.

After the mock draft finished, Cal linked us to both Curtin & Caddy, which is interesting.

Think we'll take Caddy with the first pick, hopefully Windsor with the second if he's there