3 hours ago, Demonland said:

 

How about you give your coaches at least one day off a week Justin?  surely some things are more important than footy.  Regardless, anyones output reduces when they work non stop, you will get better ideas from rested minds

IN Sparrow Woewodin

OUT Clarry Hunter

Wow, Woey Jnr getting a go is really pleasing if that's the case.

He's definitely skilled enough to make it, he's a lovely kick and for those who remember his dad, he seems to have a similar work ethic although I worry about his pure speed. But his dad managed to work his way from a back pocket rookie longshot in 97 into our most important midfielder by 2000, so who really knows.

Even more pleasing is that for the first time since round 3, our selectors are thinking outside the box again.

As with Sydney, Fremantle has done well against us in recent times with last year's win at the 'G the start of our decline and if you recall it was Michael Frederick who carved up Rivers as they overran us after halftime.

Rivers has been our most improved players this year so I doubt Frederick will be much of an influence, but they are in form with their tail up and Walters and Seargent Schultz will be everywhere I reckon, not to mention Fyfe, Brayshaw and Serong.

Hopefully McVee gets Walters, Bowey gets Schultz and our Brayshaw takes Fyfe out of it, whether in the middle or up forward. They play three talls - Amiss, Jacko and Treacy and Banfield ain't short either, so I suspect we will need either Turner. Turner has to play - he learnt a bit from his three quarters on the Gold Coast as was shown by his huge game at Casey against NM last week.

And while we are talking changes, with Hunter out, now is the time to start Salem on the left wing which will surprise Freo. I'd have him rotating with Hibbo, who ensures we have a hard tackling outside mid who is good in the air - that is one of Freo's big strengths when they are on.

Either way our selectors must be way more tactical than they have been of late and must pull some changes to break up our monotonous ways which have crept back in - you are allowed to attack down the right hand wing and if Ed is over there we need to use his pace.

And a hard tag on Serong would also help - Viney is the obvious man, with whoever plays out of Harmes or Jordon given a tagging job on Andrew Brayshaw when they are on the field. 

Chandler's confidence has dried up the past two weeks - and as clever as he was early, it's time to give him a rest - I know that's a hard call given his plethora of goals and assists in early games.

One last comment that I know most won't agree with - but JVR must be dropped for this game - we all know he's a developing talent but there has to be consequences for his lack of discipline that cost us big time against Port. A week in the twos should be compulsory.

And like many of you, I reckon we can get by without T.Mac this week, he's just not quite quick enough these days and probably needs another hard block of match-free training to get his mobility back.

Out: Oliver, Hunter, JVR, T-Mac, Chandler

In: Woey, BB, D.Turner, Sparrow, Harmes or Jordon

 

B: Bowey (Schultz), May (Amiss - lets make it hard for the youngster) McVee (Walters)

HB: Rivers (Frederick) Lever (Jackson) Hibberd (Banfield) - seventh Turner (Treacy)

C: Langdon Angus Brayshaw (Fyfe) Salem

HF: Sparrow Gawn ANB

F: Pickett Fritsch Ben Brown

Ru: Grundy Petracca Viney (Serong)

Int: Woey, Harmes or Jordon, Turner, Spargo

Emerg: Melky, J.Smith (the sub if fit), Lawrie, Harmes or Jordon

3 hours ago, Wells 11 said:

At a glance he doesn't seem to overly quick

Draft camp he was top 5 speed over 20 metres, IIRC. I also remember that surprising the draft watchers. A bit like Tom Sparrow. Most assume he isn’t quick by the ‘look’ of his running. He’s top 5 at the club. 

19 minutes ago, Deespicable said:

Wow, Woey Jnr getting a go is really pleasing if that's the case.

He's definitely skilled enough to make it, he's a lovely kick and for those who remember his dad, he seems to have a similar work ethic although I worry about his pure speed. But his dad managed to work his way from a back pocket rookie longshot in 97 into our most important midfielder by 2000, so who really knows.

Even more pleasing is that for the first time since round 3, our selectors are thinking outside the box again.

As with Sydney, Fremantle has done well against us in recent times with last year's win at the 'G the start of our decline and if you recall it was Michael Frederick who carved up Rivers as they overran us after halftime.

Rivers has been our most improved players this year so I doubt Frederick will be much of an influence, but they are in form with their tail up and Walters and Seargent Schultz will be everywhere I reckon, not to mention Fyfe, Brayshaw and Serong.

Hopefully McVee gets Walters, Bowey gets Schultz and our Brayshaw takes Fyfe out of it, whether in the middle or up forward. They play three talls - Amiss, Jacko and Treacy and Banfield ain't short either, so I suspect we will need either Turner. Turner has to play - he learnt a bit from his three quarters on the Gold Coast as was shown by his huge game at Casey against NM last week.

And while we are talking changes, with Hunter out, now is the time to start Salem on the left wing which will surprise Freo. I'd have him rotating with Hibbo, who ensures we have a hard tackling outside mid who is good in the air - that is one of Freo's big strengths when they are on.

Either way our selectors must be way more tactical than they have been of late and must pull some changes to break up our monotonous ways which have crept back in - you are allowed to attack down the right hand wing and if Ed is over there we need to use his pace.

And a hard tag on Serong would also help - Viney is the obvious man, with whoever plays out of Harmes or Jordon given a tagging job on Andrew Brayshaw when they are on the field. 

Chandler's confidence has dried up the past two weeks - and as clever as he was early, it's time to give him a rest - I know that's a hard call given his plethora of goals and assists in early games.

One last comment that I know most won't agree with - but JVR must be dropped for this game - we all know he's a developing talent but there has to be consequences for his lack of discipline that cost us big time against Port. A week in the twos should be compulsory.

And like many of you, I reckon we can get by without T.Mac this week, he's just not quite quick enough these days and probably needs another hard block of match-free training to get his mobility back.

Out: Oliver, Hunter, JVR, T-Mac, Chandler

In: Woey, BB, D.Turner, Sparrow, Harmes or Jordon

 

B: Bowey (Schultz), May (Amiss - lets make it hard for the youngster) McVee (Walters)

HB: Rivers (Frederick) Lever (Jackson) Hibberd (Banfield) - seventh Turner (Treacy)

C: Langdon Angus Brayshaw (Fyfe) Salem

HF: Sparrow Gawn ANB

F: Pickett Fritsch Ben Brown

Ru: Grundy Petracca Viney (Serong)

Int: Woey, Harmes or Jordon, Turner, Spargo

Emerg: Melky, J.Smith (the sub if fit), Lawrie, Harmes or Jordon

We're not making 5 changes, anymore than 2 would be a major surprise.

7 minutes ago, Webber said:

Draft camp he was top 5 speed over 20 metres, IIRC. I also remember that surprising the draft watchers. A bit like Tom Sparrow. Most assume he isn’t quick by the ‘look’ of his running. He’s top 5 at the club. 

A bit like Tom Sparrow? Very interesting take. Hard at the footy yes, but don’t think they’re very similar. Sparrow is crash and bash, Taj more breaks lines in and out of traffic.

4 minutes ago, 12345_54321 said:

A bit like Tom Sparrow? Very interesting take. Hard at the footy yes, but don’t think they’re very similar. Sparrow is crash and bash, Taj more breaks lines in and out of traffic.

Maybe read again what he said.. was talking more of how his pace is deceiving. No mention on the type of player. 

4 hours ago, Wells 11 said:

At a glance he doesn't seem to overly quick...

He was second at his Draft Combine over 20 metres.

His time was 2.898.  Under 3 seconds is quick, under 2.9 seconds is express.

I think its time to change the balance a bit.  JVR is only young and Tmac is struggling a bit.  This puts a lot of pressure on Fritta.   

At present we have 8 defenders in the side if you include Brayshaw.  

I think you can remove one of them and include another marking forward.   Smith seems to be performing that role at Casey.  If he was included if Bowey is injured, you would also have cover if a tall defender goes down (either he or Tmac  could then cover that and still have marking strength up forward).  Smith also has pace which creates room which has enabled Melks to kick goals at Casey.  Perhaps he could do the same for JVR/Fritta.

56 minutes ago, SPC said:

Maybe read again what he said.. was talking more of how his pace is deceiving. No mention on the type of player. 

Apologies.

4 hours ago, WalkingCivilWar said:

Thing is, it WILL be nasty from some.

”worthy of discussion “??? Yes. 
Worthy of straight up vitriolic insults? That’d be a huge bunch of nope, right there. 

Keep the mods busy 😂

Just now, Roost it far said:

Keep the mods busy 😂

I daresay they’re plenty busy as it is. 

5 hours ago, WalkingCivilWar said:

Some folk are champing at the bit to resurrect that horrid thread after only one loss. Or even before the final siren when a loss is inevitable. 
🙄

People need to realize that teams actually lose a handful of games a season, Port isn't a bad team, have one 6-7 on the run and we played in the wet away. Obviously not an amazing game from a dees perspective but its not as though we are back to the horror years.

3 hours ago, Deespicable said:

Wow, Woey Jnr getting a go is really pleasing if that's the case.

He's definitely skilled enough to make it, he's a lovely kick and for those who remember his dad, he seems to have a similar work ethic although I worry about his pure speed. But his dad managed to work his way from a back pocket rookie longshot in 97 into our most important midfielder by 2000, so who really knows.

Even more pleasing is that for the first time since round 3, our selectors are thinking outside the box again.

As with Sydney, Fremantle has done well against us in recent times with last year's win at the 'G the start of our decline and if you recall it was Michael Frederick who carved up Rivers as they overran us after halftime.

Rivers has been our most improved players this year so I doubt Frederick will be much of an influence, but they are in form with their tail up and Walters and Seargent Schultz will be everywhere I reckon, not to mention Fyfe, Brayshaw and Serong.

Hopefully McVee gets Walters, Bowey gets Schultz and our Brayshaw takes Fyfe out of it, whether in the middle or up forward. They play three talls - Amiss, Jacko and Treacy and Banfield ain't short either, so I suspect we will need either Turner. Turner has to play - he learnt a bit from his three quarters on the Gold Coast as was shown by his huge game at Casey against NM last week.

And while we are talking changes, with Hunter out, now is the time to start Salem on the left wing which will surprise Freo. I'd have him rotating with Hibbo, who ensures we have a hard tackling outside mid who is good in the air - that is one of Freo's big strengths when they are on.

Either way our selectors must be way more tactical than they have been of late and must pull some changes to break up our monotonous ways which have crept back in - you are allowed to attack down the right hand wing and if Ed is over there we need to use his pace.

And a hard tag on Serong would also help - Viney is the obvious man, with whoever plays out of Harmes or Jordon given a tagging job on Andrew Brayshaw when they are on the field. 

Chandler's confidence has dried up the past two weeks - and as clever as he was early, it's time to give him a rest - I know that's a hard call given his plethora of goals and assists in early games.

One last comment that I know most won't agree with - but JVR must be dropped for this game - we all know he's a developing talent but there has to be consequences for his lack of discipline that cost us big time against Port. A week in the twos should be compulsory.

And like many of you, I reckon we can get by without T.Mac this week, he's just not quite quick enough these days and probably needs another hard block of match-free training to get his mobility back.

Out: Oliver, Hunter, JVR, T-Mac, Chandler

In: Woey, BB, D.Turner, Sparrow, Harmes or Jordon

 

B: Bowey (Schultz), May (Amiss - lets make it hard for the youngster) McVee (Walters)

HB: Rivers (Frederick) Lever (Jackson) Hibberd (Banfield) - seventh Turner (Treacy)

C: Langdon Angus Brayshaw (Fyfe) Salem

HF: Sparrow Gawn ANB

F: Pickett Fritsch Ben Brown

Ru: Grundy Petracca Viney (Serong)

Int: Woey, Harmes or Jordon, Turner, Spargo

Emerg: Melky, J.Smith (the sub if fit), Lawrie, Harmes or Jordon

JVR and Chandler are not getting dropped.

5 hours ago, drysdale demon said:

JVR and Chandler are not getting dropped.

JVR may get a rest though. The cupboard is pretty bare though, because I wouldn't be playing TMac ideally...

Derps, probably Schache for TMac and I wouldn't be against Smith replacing JVR for the one week. I doubt they'll want to replace both KPFs in the one week.

Edited May 24, 20232 yr by A F

9 hours ago, Jaded No More said:

The real question is; when did I get this old? 😭

Old is when your kid is approaching AFL retirement age... or you have actually worn a real woollen jumper.

8 hours ago, A F said:

JVR may get a rest though. The cupboard is pretty bare though, because I wouldn't be playing TMac ideally...

Derps, probably Schache for TMac and I wouldn't be against Smith replacing JVR for the one week. I doubt they'll want to replace both KPFs in the one week.

He will get a rest after the bye, bringing Smith as a key forward is too much of a gamble.

16 hours ago, DubDee said:

How about you give your coaches at least one day off a week Justin?  surely some things are more important than footy.  Regardless, anyones output reduces when they work non stop, you will get better ideas from rested minds

Don't need to take a class in burnout to know that this is how you get burnout. 

Looking forward to Woey's debut announcement video if the mail is correct.

No 'What they are saying at Cockburn' this week?

I've seen one poster on this thread state that Woewodin will debut with no attribution to anyone or anything official. I've then seen other posters say that he's playing but don't know whether they're basing that on the statement in that post or whether something has been announced. So, simple question: Has the club stated anywhere that Woewodin will be playing?

Edited May 24, 20232 yr by La Dee-vina Comedia
typo

13 minutes ago, La Dee-vina Comedia said:

I've seen one poster on this thread state that Woewodin will debut with no attribution to anyone or anything official. I've then seen other posters say that he's playing but don't know whether they're basing that on the statement in that post or whether something has been announced. So, simple question: Has the club stated anywhere that Woewodin will be playing?

Club hasn't announced anything about Woey debuting LDC, most are going by what the poster stated as they have a high success rate with 'inside' info. 

2 minutes ago, Dee Zephyr said:

Club hasn't announced anything about Woey debuting LDC, most are going by what the poster stated as they have a high success rate with 'inside' info. 

 

I reckon if Danny posted it you can take it to your grave. Never wrong.

I would say we will hear about it today prior to the team being announced. 

Intrigued by the Woey rumours.

There's 2 spots I'd consider him for.

1. Wing: in which case I can't see him overtaking JJ. But I guess JJ could play on ball. Gus back to half back. Bowey doesn't come up? Or McVee gets a rest?

2. half forward/3rd winger: ANB's done that at times but JJ probably needs more rest than Hunter, so a 3rd winger comes in. A half forward would have to make way. Chandler? Sprago? ANB himself? Drop a tall? Give Fritsch a potentially much needed week off (from a health perspective please don't start)?

Given how reluctant Goodwin has been in his career to play young guys on the wings my guess is it's the latter.

I think Woey was in line for the preseason game v Richmond and round 1 start that Laurie got so I'm not overly surprised if it happens.

 

20 hours ago, Deespicable said:

Wow, Woey Jnr getting a go is really pleasing if that's the case.

He's definitely skilled enough to make it, he's a lovely kick and for those who remember his dad, he seems to have a similar work ethic although I worry about his pure speed. But his dad managed to work his way from a back pocket rookie longshot in 97 into our most important midfielder by 2000, so who really knows.

Even more pleasing is that for the first time since round 3, our selectors are thinking outside the box again.

As with Sydney, Fremantle has done well against us in recent times with last year's win at the 'G the start of our decline and if you recall it was Michael Frederick who carved up Rivers as they overran us after halftime.

Rivers has been our most improved players this year so I doubt Frederick will be much of an influence, but they are in form with their tail up and Walters and Seargent Schultz will be everywhere I reckon, not to mention Fyfe, Brayshaw and Serong.

Hopefully McVee gets Walters, Bowey gets Schultz and our Brayshaw takes Fyfe out of it, whether in the middle or up forward. They play three talls - Amiss, Jacko and Treacy and Banfield ain't short either, so I suspect we will need either Turner. Turner has to play - he learnt a bit from his three quarters on the Gold Coast as was shown by his huge game at Casey against NM last week.

And while we are talking changes, with Hunter out, now is the time to start Salem on the left wing which will surprise Freo. I'd have him rotating with Hibbo, who ensures we have a hard tackling outside mid who is good in the air - that is one of Freo's big strengths when they are on.

Either way our selectors must be way more tactical than they have been of late and must pull some changes to break up our monotonous ways which have crept back in - you are allowed to attack down the right hand wing and if Ed is over there we need to use his pace.

And a hard tag on Serong would also help - Viney is the obvious man, with whoever plays out of Harmes or Jordon given a tagging job on Andrew Brayshaw when they are on the field. 

Chandler's confidence has dried up the past two weeks - and as clever as he was early, it's time to give him a rest - I know that's a hard call given his plethora of goals and assists in early games.

One last comment that I know most won't agree with - but JVR must be dropped for this game - we all know he's a developing talent but there has to be consequences for his lack of discipline that cost us big time against Port. A week in the twos should be compulsory.

And like many of you, I reckon we can get by without T.Mac this week, he's just not quite quick enough these days and probably needs another hard block of match-free training to get his mobility back.

Out: Oliver, Hunter, JVR, T-Mac, Chandler

In: Woey, BB, D.Turner, Sparrow, Harmes or Jordon

 

B: Bowey (Schultz), May (Amiss - lets make it hard for the youngster) McVee (Walters)

HB: Rivers (Frederick) Lever (Jackson) Hibberd (Banfield) - seventh Turner (Treacy)

C: Langdon Angus Brayshaw (Fyfe) Salem

HF: Sparrow Gawn ANB

F: Pickett Fritsch Ben Brown

Ru: Grundy Petracca Viney (Serong)

Int: Woey, Harmes or Jordon, Turner, Spargo

Emerg: Melky, J.Smith (the sub if fit), Lawrie, Harmes or Jordon

Why drop JVR and Chin?

1 hour ago, DeeSpencer said:

Intrigued by the Woey rumours.

There's 2 spots I'd consider him for.

1. Wing: in which case I can't see him overtaking JJ. But I guess JJ could play on ball. Gus back to half back. Bowey doesn't come up? Or McVee gets a rest?

2. half forward/3rd winger: ANB's done that at times but JJ probably needs more rest than Hunter, so a 3rd winger comes in. A half forward would have to make way. Chandler? Sprago? ANB himself? Drop a tall? Give Fritsch a potentially much needed week off (from a health perspective please don't start)?

Given how reluctant Goodwin has been in his career to play young guys on the wings my guess is it's the latter.

I think Woey was in line for the preseason game v Richmond and round 1 start that Laurie got so I'm not overly surprised if it happens.

 

I like the sound of Woey debuting if true. He’s looked good at VFL level. I think he’ll rotate the mid/wing Hunter role with Jordon. Woey’s been very good at VFL level since his return, good in and under, makes good space on the outside, uses the ball pretty well and takes a nice overhead mark and plays a little taller than he looks which would be a different look for us on a wing.

Edited May 25, 20232 yr by deejammin'