CHANGES: Rd 15 vs Brisbane

[Billy 2,461]

8 hours ago, Sydee said:

I'm warming to the idea of playing Trac as a permanent forward against the Lions and replacing him in the guts with Gus. We have become very predictable and teams are feeding off that 

Gus is in form and Trac has been struggling to impact on the ball

We desperately need some strong bodies in the F50 and that won't be coming from BB or Weid assuming he is gifted another opportunity

Gus whilst playing great footy at HBF can be covered if we have May, Petty, Lever, Salem. Pig and any of (Bowey, Rivers, Hunt)  

I like it, good post, would love to see them change it up a bit

Gus would get the same amount of possessions as Trac at the moment , maybe more & we need a forward to help Fritta with another 3 or so goals

The big forwards we have aren’t & won’t get it done on a cold winters night at the G

[loges 6,767]

Would bring Weid straight into the ruck for 60% of the game Dogga 40,%. No good playing Weid mainly forward he's too easy to defend. More chance to get a couple of goals from LJ

[chook fowler 19,248]

Pity we didn’t pick up Bell from Casey in the midseason draft

[Jjrogan 1,391]

39 minutes ago, loges said:

Would bring Weid straight into the ruck for 60% of the game Dogga 40,%. No good playing Weid mainly forward he's too easy to defend. More chance to get a couple of goals from LJ

I like this idea.  Andrews and Adams have his measure.  Giving Weed the ruck game could really force him to be physical and crash some packs. I'm sure he would be able to take an intercept mark or two and he would have a significant mobility edge on Oscar. 

[Redleg 40,065]

8 minutes ago, chook fowler said:

Pity we didn’t pick up Bell from Casey in the midseason draft

Played a nice game last week.

[monoccular 17,314]

1 hour ago, chook fowler said:

Pity we didn’t pick up Bell from Casey in the midseason draft

Our injury list blossomed just a week or so too late.  Looking with the benefit of hindsight, should / could we have put Howes on the long term injury list and allowed him the full 2022 season to recover?  It will be frustrating if he doesn't get at lest a handful of Casey games later in the year.

[Demon Dynasty 17,091]

13 hours ago, Sydee said:

I'm warming to the idea of playing Trac as a permanent forward against the Lions and replacing him in the guts with Gus. We have become very predictable and teams are feeding off that 

Gus is in form and Trac has been struggling to impact on the ball

We desperately need some strong bodies in the F50 and that won't be coming from BB or Weid assuming he is gifted another opportunity

Gus whilst playing great footy at HBF can be covered if we have May, Petty, Lever, Salem. Pig and any of (Bowey, Rivers, Hunt)  

Yeh im also a big fan here.  Nice one Syd

[Demon Dynasty 17,091]

12 hours ago, DeeZone said:

I have been searching through injury reports and cannot find any useful info on Majak Daw apart from a number of posters asserting that he is injured. If this is the case what is the injury and how long is he unavailable?? Given that he is our backup ruckman that should provide coverage for Max / LJ I am a bit annoyed that the club have not provided some explanation for his unavailability. The info provided on DL is confusing at best and suggestions that Majak is not up to playing AFL makes me wonder where the truth lies.

KC can you provide any info to support or refute Majak’s fitness and wellbeing as we could really use his Presence over the next 4-6 weeks.

He's been in & out of the McGoos over the last three to four weeks or so.  I figured it might have been the flu/covid.

So, after playing pretty much every match bar the last few weeks and being a chance of getting a call up at a time of need, he's now possibly out for the next four weeks or so!??  Couldn't make this stuff up 🥴

[COOLX 184]

Not too sure that Majak is actually injured.Perhaps he is on some sort of training mission. Why wouldn't he be listed as injured on the Demon website.......... the sit is next to useless.  Why have not trained players in the reserves to become "swingman" like Tom Mac. Tomlinson , Daw and J.Smith ( not so much defence due to too many injuries)  should be constantly tried. Winning a flag is that important as to cover for T.Mac is very important . Perhaps Daw will get a call up.

[one_demon 826]

16 hours ago, loges said:

Would bring Weid straight into the ruck for 60% of the game Dogga 40,%

No way.  Weideman is not a ruckman.  

[sue 9,004]

12 minutes ago, COOLX said:

Not too sure that Majak is actually injured.Perhaps he is on some sort of training mission. Why wouldn't he be listed as injured on the Demon website.......... the sit is next to useless.  Why have not trained players in the reserves to become "swingman" like Tom Mac. Tomlinson , Daw and J.Smith ( not so much defence due to too many injuries)  should be constantly tried. Winning a flag is that important as to cover for T.Mac is very important . Perhaps Daw will get a call up.

It's not impossible that Daw has personal issues which may explain why he neither plays nor is listed as injured.  Hopefully not.

[fr_ap 2,430]

1 hour ago, one_demon said:

No way.  Weideman is not a ruckman.  

He's actually a better ruckman than he is a forward. That's saying something....

Edited June 18, 2022 by fr_ap

[Redleg 40,065]

While I remain confident we can turn it around, a look at our current key forwards and rucks, when compared to our main opposition, is frightening.

A relatively short, young ruckman and an out of form FF, are basically on their own.

Yes we lost Max and Tom, but we seem to have left ourselves with no depth in these two areas. 

[whatwhat say what 22,091]

41 minutes ago, Redleg said:

While I remain confident we can turn it around, a look at our current key forwards and rucks, when compared to our main opposition, is frightening.

A relatively short, young ruckman and an out of form FF, are basically on their own.

Yes we lost Max and Tom, but we seem to have left ourselves with no depth in these two areas. 

take the equivalent of max and plugger mac out of any side and the would look noticeably short on personnel 

[one_demon 826]

1 hour ago, fr_ap said:

He's actually a better ruckman than he is a forward. That's saying something....

That doesn't mean he's a good ruckman 

[DeeSpencer 24,690]

53 minutes ago, Redleg said:

While I remain confident we can turn it around, a look at our current key forwards and rucks, when compared to our main opposition, is frightening.

A relatively short, young ruckman and an out of form FF, are basically on their own.

Yes we lost Max and Tom, but we seem to have left ourselves with no depth in these two areas. 

I can understand why we stuck with Weid, if he was willing to stay it would’ve been hard for the club and coaches to move him on.

Sticking with Daw and Mitch Brown both deep in to the twilight of their careers looks like hubris after the flag to me. Neither of them have the bodies for consistent AFL footy and it’s been years since they played proper stints.

At a minimum it would’ve been nice to have a couple of guys train with the club over summer to push their cases. 

[Diamond_Jim 12,351]

If Daw is fit he has to come in just to do the simple bounce grunt. On ground time will be say 70%.

The M Brown experiment has not worked. Hunt was a good forward in 2019 (?) so that's a possibility. Otherwise it's Weideman.

Cannot see enough fire power in Chandler or Bedford

Replacing Sparrow with Dunstan is a possibility but it doesn't excite me.

Down back I'll leave the Rivers/Bowey discussion to the selectors

[loges 6,767]

3 hours ago, one_demon said:

No way.  Weideman is not a ruckman.  

What is he then ?

[Redleg 40,065]

1 hour ago, whatwhat say what said:

take the equivalent of max and plugger mac out of any side and the would look noticeably short on personnel 

Look at the other sides in the 8 and take out a Tom Mac type and all have more options than us. All have more ruck options too.

I think no injuries last year and then the flag, misled us as to our depth in a couple of positions and we might pay for it this year.

[old dee 23,486]

4 hours ago, sue said:

It's not impossible that Daw has personal issues which may explain why he neither plays nor is listed as injured.  Hopefully not.

I think you have won the prize sue. I think the problem is above the shoulders.

[old dee 23,486]

34 minutes ago, Redleg said:

Look at the other sides in the 8 and take out a Tom Mac type and all have more options than us. All have more ruck options too.

I think no injuries last year and then the flag, misled us as to our depth in a couple of positions and we might pay for it this year.

The part that amuse me the most was how at the end 2020 Tmac was not required and without him in the first part of 2021we may not have even made the GF. Now he is injured in 2022 and our forward line looks very ordinary without him. 

[old dee 23,486]

3 hours ago, Redleg said:

While I remain confident we can turn it around, a look at our current key forwards and rucks, when compared to our main opposition, is frightening.

A relatively short, young ruckman and an out of form FF, are basically on their own.

Yes we lost Max and Tom, but we seem to have left ourselves with no depth in these two areas. 

If we had lost Tmac in 2020 when he was on the market then I doubt we would won the flag in 2021. He carried the forward line in the first 8-9games of 2021. 

[old dee 23,486]

1 hour ago, loges said:

What is he then ?

An extremely good question!

[Demon4Life 601]

51 minutes ago, old dee said:

The part that amuse me the most was how at the end 2020 Tmac was not required and without him in the first part of 2021we may not have even made the GF. Now he is injured in 2022 and our forward line looks very ordinary without him. 

That amuses you? It depresses me

[Deemania since 56 6,550]

4 hours ago, fr_ap said:

He's actually a better ruckman than he is a forward. That's saying something....

...and there is not a great deal that can be said..