Tom McDonald

[leave it to deever 17,511]

Bbb can't do it all.

At present he really is are only tall.

Melk has been good but isn't a big man . Neither is Fritta.

WWXcan't play Weid but if we have Jackson in the ruck...Max is nit a reliable link to leave up fwd.

It's a huge gamble playing Tmac ...I'm not sure Goody will risk it.

Can Tomlinson play fwd or is he injured?

 

[old55 23,546]

15 hours ago, Nasher said:

No way TMac plays before at least another Casey game IMO. If I were him I’d be mentally preparing for a tilt at a Casey flag and treat anything else as a bonus.

Agree, if we win through to the GF there is no way the FD will change the team unless there's an injury.

[Macca 16,961]

The chances are an injury could well appear and T-Mac could be near the top of emergencies or close to next in line (because of his versatility)

Not forgetting that we have had a number of players who have missed out on selection because of a late injury (not publicised) or for Covid reasons

And in an ideal world the MC might like him in the team (above the depth players)

If we can make it to the GF Tom could find himself in the team by default

[Diamond_Jim 12,568]

let's say we win on Friday and Melksham has a poor to middling game.

T Mac plays VFL the following week and plays a decent but not spectacular game

Who gets picked for the PF

And just to make it more interesting Smith kicks three and has four goal assists in the VFL game

Edited August 30, 2022 by Diamond_Jim

[M_9 2,082]

3 minutes ago, Diamond_Jim said:

let's say we win on Friday and Melksham has a poor to middling game.

T Mac plays VFL the following week and plays a decent but not spectacular game

Who gets picked for the PF

And just to make it more interesting Smith kicks three and has four goal assists in the VFL game

I would not be playing Mitch Brown regardless of his VFL form.

Three games this year. Averaged 8 disposals. Goal-less in two games. Two goals v Crows in a 6 goal win.

[Gawndy the Great 9,011]

3 hours ago, old55 said:

Agree, if we win through to the GF there is no way the FD will change the team unless there's an injury.

Yep there’s no point risking next year. He said the injury is a 6 month One and he’s back playing in 3 months. I know it’s all about flags and premiership medallions but we will be there abouts next year as well so better to have a fit and firing KPF as we are low in stocks and the ones we do have are not in the best health. 

[DubDee 25,835]

18 minutes ago, Diamond_Jim said:

let's say we win on Friday and Melksham has a poor to middling game.

T Mac plays VFL the following week and plays a decent but not spectacular game

Who gets picked for the PF

And just to make it more interesting Smith kicks three and has four goal assists in the VFL game

Depends how poor Melksham was and how T Mac feels but on face value I would play T Mac in the prelim.  very harsh on melksham but a second talls adds a lot to our structure around the ground, not just up fwd

Smith - Casey

[Macca 16,961]

43 minutes ago, Diamond_Jim said:

let's say we win on Friday and Melksham has a poor to middling game.

T Mac plays VFL the following week and plays a decent but not spectacular game

Who gets picked for the PF

And just to make it more interesting Smith kicks three and has four goal assists in the VFL game

Just last year Hibberd was out after r22 (dropped? Injured?) then missed r23 and the QF

Recalled for the PF when Smith was injured

[layzie 33,793]

Can Werridee make a team of guys that have played with plates in their foot?

[leave it to deever 17,511]

Im 100 % sure Tmac won't be selected unless via injury.

 

Too late for such a risk and too much at stake.

 Sad.

[D4Life 2,469]

If TMac fully fit and played 3-4 games he would obviously be in the team.

Watching him last weekend he looked slow and lacking in mobility - totally understandable after his injury!

He would need to improve nearly 50% in his next vfl game on what he showed last weekend to be considered for selection in the finals series.

[SFebes 4,884]

The trouble with TMAC is after an injury, it takes him a good 5-6wks to get into form and is usually woeful in that time. I wish he was fit and firing though.

[jnrmac 20,058]

43 minutes ago, SFebes said:

The trouble with TMAC is after an injury, it takes him a good 5-6wks to get into form and is usually woeful in that time. I wish he was fit and firing though.

That is simply not true. I have posted stats on this before, You are perpetuating an urban myth.

[SFebes 4,884]

1 hour ago, jnrmac said:

That is simply not true. I have posted stats on this before, You are perpetuating an urban myth.

Post them again? To my eyes, more times than not hes out of touch and thats OK.

[58er 6,422]

3 hours ago, D4Life said:

If TMac fully fit and played 3-4 games he would obviously be in the team.

Watching him last weekend he looked slow and lacking in mobility - totally understandable after his injury!

He would need to improve nearly 50% in his next vfl game on what he showed last weekend to be considered for selection in the finals series.

That's your opinion.

Not everyone else's some more positive others are very positive.

Still has next weeks PF for match play with Casey Dees or Our Semi if considered ok if we don't win. 

[58er 6,422]

On 8/30/2022 at 1:02 PM, M_9 said:

I would not be playing Mitch Brown regardless of his VFL form.

Three games this year. Averaged 8 disposals. Goal-less in two games. Two goals v Crows in a 6 goal win.

This post was about Tmac not Mitch Brown !!! 
Tommy or no Tommy ? 

[Mr Steve 3,820]

[jnrmac 20,058]

3 hours ago, SFebes said:

Post them again? To my eyes, more times than not hes out of touch and thats OK.

I'm not your intern try searching

[Macca 16,961]

1 hour ago, Mr Steve said:

Might have been an old school case of the team being posted on a notice board!

If your names not there you're kicking the dew off the grass in the ressies

[jumbo returns 6,741]

Best line of all time:

'Google it, mate!'

[daisycutter 29,613]

1 minute ago, jumbo returns said:

Best line of all time:

'Google it, mate!'

or just gim

[SFebes 4,884]

1 hour ago, jnrmac said:

I'm not your intern try searching

I'll believe my own eyes then, stats mean bugger all really.

[Demon4Life 603]

The deeper we get into the finals series the better he's going to get and I find it a reassuring thought to know we have him sitting in our back pocket

[Demonland 72,154]

8 hours ago, Mr Steve said:

There’s more to the exchange. 

[layzie 33,793]

Intel, Age. Intel.