Question- is Carl Ditterich the only player to return to the Dees after leaving

[spirit of norm smith 16,450]

There is occasionally (rare) the romantic footy story of a player returning to their original club. Paul Salmon is the best example that I recall. 
 

For the Dees, I can only recall Carl Ditterich as an example although he will be remembered as a Saints man. Ironically he was a “return” at the Saints and the Dees. He played with Melbourne from 1973-75 and then as player/coach 1979&80.  

I am still thinking that one day perhaps Jesse Hogan could return but history shows it is a 0.01% chance of happening for any club or player.  

[Whispering_Jack 30,054]

Chris Aitken played for the club in 1967 and 1969, then left and came back again for a few games in 1977. He’s Wilbur Wilde’s brother.

 

[bush demon 2,039]

Gary Hardeman went to play in South Australia in the 70's then came back to play under Barassi in 1980.

[bush demon 2,039]

Norm Smith left Melbourne in 1948 and played for the Royboys as coach in 1949?  He came back to Melbourne 1950s as coach. 

[Swooper1987 3,322]

Peter Patrick Pius Paul Crackers Keenan - 1970-1975 101 games; 1981-82 - 30 games

[bush demon 2,039]

Don Williams left Melbourne late 50s or early 60s went back to play for Sale then came back to star in Melbourne's '64 premiership team.

[TeamPlayedFine39 8,503]

Todd Viney ‘retired’ to train Mark Philippoussis, only to later return to the Dees when that inevitably went aas over elbow.

[dieter 3,325]

Neil Crompton. Left in 1961 to play for Glenelg. He was a rover in those days, kicked 7 against North in a match in 1959. He returned in 1962 and became the tightest back pocket in the competition. 

Crompton also played 45 first class cricket matches for Victoria. he averaged 32 and was known as a superb fielder.

[Tough Kent 2,137]

This doesn't apply, but Chris Heffernan grew up supporting Melbourne, got drafted to Essendon, was traded to Melbourne and then got traded back to Essendon!

[spirit of norm smith 16,450]

Ok so really it’s just Carl Ditterich and Crackers Keenan who played with the Dees, went to another (VFL/AFL) club and returned. No one else in the past 40 years. Still will hope that the Dees reach out to Jesse Hogan to see if there is any interest in a return one day. 

[Bobby McKenzie 2,385]

2 hours ago, bush demon said:

Don Williams left Melbourne late 50s or early 60s went back to play for Sale then came back to star in Melbourne's '64 premiership team.

And what a champion player he was. Dasher Williams! 

[Jumping Jack Clennett 1,780]

Like yourself, I'm told, Bobby.

Don Williams used to take hangers( front  cover of footy record for ages), dash out of defence bouncing it, then kick long drop kicks!

He was spectacular....and tough.

[picket fence 17,151]

Des Campbell??

[dee-eee 231]

7 hours ago, bush demon said:

Don Williams left Melbourne late 50s or early 60s went back to play for Sale then came back to star in Melbourne's '64 premiership team.

Yes , Don had two stints with us '53-59 & '64-68   with West Perth '60-62 and Sale '63 .

[spirit of norm smith 16,450]

2 hours ago, picket fence said:

Des Campbell??

Another who played a year then went back to the bush.  The VFL era was where players came and went to VFL, SANFL, the bush of the VFA.  It depended on job opportunities, family and money available.  Totally different to today’s professional footballers. 

[Demonstone 22,506]

1 minute ago, spirit of norm smith said:

It depended on job opportunities, family and money available.  Totally different to today’s professional footballers. 

Absolutely correct, Norm.  Here's a stunning example:

The game in 1947 in which Fred Fanning kicked a league record 18 goals (still a record) against St Kilda was the last game for the season and Fred's last appearance for Melbourne.  His final kick was the sole behind in his day's tally of 18.1.  He had kicked 16 until three-quarter time before being quietened somewhat in the last.

The following season, he was lured to coach at Hamilton because of the extra money on offer, which worked out to be six times what Melbourne could pay.  That situation would be totally inconceivable these days.

[MyFavouriteMartian 572]

9 hours ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Ok so really it’s just Carl Ditterich and Crackers Keenan who played with the Dees, went to another (VFL/AFL) club and returned. No one else in the past 40 years. Still will hope that the Dees reach out to Jesse Hogan to see if there is any interest in a return one day. 

Jim Stynes... was with Melbourne, went to Prahran,  then back to the Dees, when his footy took off.

[John Dee 445]

Jim was essentially loaned to Prahran as Melbourne did not have a VFL affiliate in those days. He was still tied to Melbourne.

[MyFavouriteMartian 572]

36 minutes ago, John Dee said:

Jim was essentially loaned to Prahran as Melbourne did not have a VFL affiliate in those days. He was still tied to Melbourne.

Yes,  but there wasn't necessarily a return ticket.  He made good.

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,754]

23 hours ago, spirit of norm smith said:

There is occasionally (rare) the romantic footy story of a player returning to their original club. Paul Salmon is the best example that I recall. 
 

For the Dees, I can only recall Carl Ditterich as an example although he will be remembered as a Saints man. Ironically he was a “return” at the Saints and the Dees. He played with Melbourne from 1973-75 and then as player/coach 1979&80.  

I am still thinking that one day perhaps Jesse Hogan could return but history shows it is a 0.01% chance of happening for any club or player.  

Interesting thread. I like that Paul Salmon is your "best example" which suggests you've either forgotten about Gary Ablett Jr and Eddie Betts or you don't think of them as "good examples". Trent Croad is another "good example" because he played in a Premiership on his return to Hawthorn. 

[Its Time for Another 4,209]

Jack Mueller retired and was recalled to come back and play for the team just for the finals in 1948 and was instrumental in the Premiership win. He kicked 8 goals in the Prelim and 6 each in the first Grand Final against Essendon which was a draw and in the win the next week. The other key forward was Norm Smith in his last game for MFC before he finished his career playing for Fitzroy for two years. Something I didn't remember until I just read it. 

Edited April 20, 2020 by It's Time

[durango 2,007]

Mattew Febey left after injuries returned to tasmania then came back later.

[spirit of norm smith 16,450]

A few other Dees are at other clubs aside from Hogan.  Watts, Dunn, Howe, Kent, Tyson, Frost, Frawley.  Would any one return for a final farewell year in their careers?

[Pates 9,660]

11 hours ago, spirit of norm smith said:

A few other Dees are at other clubs aside from Hogan.  Watts, Dunn, Howe, Kent, Tyson, Frost, Frawley.  Would any one return for a final farewell year in their careers?

Interesting looking at that list because people on here often bemoan the fact we give away players for peanuts. If he got his foot (and probably more importantly his head) right Hogan is the only one I’d really happily have back. Howe as well maybe but he’s not something we desperately need. 

Watts maybe as well for a chuckle! ?

[Wrecker45 3,378]

On 4/19/2020 at 9:56 AM, bush demon said:

Norm Smith left Melbourne in 1948 and played for the Royboys as coach in 1949?  He came back to Melbourne 1950s as coach. 

I wish he could come back now and end this curse.