Just now, Redleg said:

I think many on here would feel more comfortable, if a trade of Frost was linked in some way, either direct, or by use of picks, even shuffling of the pick, to getting another player.

Of course one way or another we will get another player, as unless it is a very low unusable pick, we will use it to draft someone.

Imagine live trading Frost pick (maybe 31ish) plus a future 2nd rounder for pick around 20-23 and selecting Weightman or similar sliding draftee.

3 minutes ago, Redleg said:

I think many on here would feel more comfortable, if a trade of Frost was linked in some way, either direct, or by use of picks, even shuffling of the pick, to getting another player.

Of course one way or another we will get another player, as unless it is a very low unusable pick, we will use it to draft someone.

So you're after Freddie Clutterbuck Mr Leg!

Just now, Moonshadow said:

Imagine live trading Frost pick (maybe 31ish) plus a future 2nd rounder for pick around 20-23 and selecting Weightman or similar sliding draftee.

Yes there are various ways and means to obtain a result.

5 hours ago, Demons11 said:

Successful clubs don’t do this??? Every team has depth players. 

Ryan Schoenmakers is a perfect example at Hawthorn.  

Ryan Schoenmakers is a PREMIERSHIP PLAYER Hardly Depth I wouldnt have thought!??

Edited October 8, 20195 yr by picket fence

2 minutes ago, picket fence said:

Ryan Schoenmakers is a PREMIERSHIP PLAYER Hardly Depth I wouldnt have thought!??

So is Jacob Townsend.

2 minutes ago, Baghdad Bob said:

So is Jacob Townsend.

Could you ever see Stretch, Oscar, JKH, Spargo ANB playing in an AFL  Premiership side??? 

I can't

16 minutes ago, picket fence said:

Ryan Schoenmakers is a PREMIERSHIP PLAYER Hardly Depth I wouldnt have thought!??

if he is not a depth player why doesn’t he play every week?

Just now, picket fence said:

Ryan Schoenmakers is a PREMIERSHIP PLAYER Hardly Depth I wouldnt have thought!??

You don't think he is depth?

Lewis, O'Brien, Gunston and Nash as tall forwards all get games before him. Even without Roughie who is no longer there. Ceglar and Big Boy also go forward.

Schoenmakers is clearly depth.

Missing the piont he has a Premiership Medallion.Was in best 22 in 2015.

How many of the players I mentioned would have got a game in a GF in Hawks team???

5 hours ago, Demons11 said:

Successful clubs don’t do this??? Every team has depth players. 

Ryan Schoenmakers is a perfect example at Hawthorn.  

Kaiden Brand?

1 minute ago, Redleg said:

You don't think he is depth?

Lewis, O'Brien, Gunston and Nash as tall forwards all get games before him. Even without Roughie who is no longer there. Ceglar and Big Boy also go forward.

Schoenmakers is clearly depth.

Would he get a game with us Now?? If Fit?? YES

Just now, picket fence said:

Missing the piont he has a Premiership Medallion.Was in best 22 in 2015.

How many of the players I mentioned would have got a game in a GF in Hawks team???

Premiership players are not all superstars. Premiership teams all have their quota of what Jack Dyer called 'good ordinary footballers;.

Just now, picket fence said:

Missing the piont he has a Premiership Medallion.Was in best 22 in 2015.

How many of the players I mentioned would have got a game in a GF in Hawks team???

Well if you are on a list of a club that makes the GF and you are the last fit player left of a certain type, you could get a game.

Plenty of ordinary players have played in GF's.

Just now, picket fence said:

Would he get a game with us Now?? If Fit?? YES

Can he play the Garlett role, because we need one of those desperately?

If he is that good and not getting a game, they will be lining up for him. Can't see any line.

21 minutes ago, Baghdad Bob said:

So is Jacob Townsend.

Steven Armstrong won a flag.

So did Jonathan Simpkin.

 

2 minutes ago, Axis of Bob said:

Steven Armstrong won a flag

I was there that day. His job was to run with the likes of Cousins and Kerr take the handball and dish it back to them as they streamed down the field. He did his job perfectly

Sad irony that the player we brought in to replace James Frawley after Hawthorn took him, will now be taken by Hawthorn, looking for a replacement for Frawley

2 hours ago, TeamPlayedFine39 said:

Sad irony that the player we brought in to replace James Frawley after Hawthorn took him, will now be taken by Hawthorn, looking for a replacement for Frawley

 

2 hours ago, TeamPlayedFine39 said:

Sad irony that the player we brought in to replace James Frawley after Hawthorn took him, will now be taken by Hawthorn, looking for a replacement for Frawley

gotta laugh, just hope he doesnt get a premiership medal.

7 hours ago, picket fence said:

Ryan Schoenmakers is a PREMIERSHIP PLAYER Hardly Depth I wouldnt have thought!??

 

7 hours ago, Baghdad Bob said:

So is Jacob Townsend.

 

7 hours ago, demoniac said:

Premiership players are not all superstars. Premiership teams all have their quota of what Jack Dyer called 'good ordinary footballers;.

Steve Armstrong

7 hours ago, Diamond_Jim said:

I was there that day. His job was to run with the likes of Cousins and Kerr take the handball and dish it back to them as they streamed down the field. He did his job perfectly

He may have just been there to run after those two, topping them up ??

I noticed today the sky hadn't fallen yet... So no actual Frost news yet?

Edited October 8, 20195 yr by Unleash Hell

And we're still talking about Frosty. Wow.

What a slow trade period it is (as always).

 

1 hour ago, Unleash Hell said:

I noticed today the sky hadn't fallen yet... So no actual Frost news yet?

The Frost trade’s probably being held up by Hawthorn’s offer of a future 6th round draft pick.

9 hours ago, picket fence said:

Would he get a game with us Now?? If Fit?? YES

Was carried along in the equivalent of a footy tidal surge for a few years PF amd got lucky.

Played a few decent games but also gifted as many chances in a very good team that could cope with and cover a few NQRs.

All clubs have them and they generally look better when surrounded by a few champs and some very solid team mates who are on a roll.  Problem is many teams don't carry such luxury on their list and some never will.

Only when the tide goes out do you see who's been swimming naked and we saw that after 2015 with Shoey.

9 hours ago, Axis of Bob said:

Steven Armstrong won a flag.

So did Jonathan Simpkin.

 

As did Mark Blake

46 minutes ago, Bring-Back-Powell said:

The Frost trade’s probably being held up by Hawthorn’s offer of a future 6th round draft pick.

I think the trade'd be done if we'd been offered a draft pick of any kind.