4 hours ago, Kent said:

Well I guess i'm both dieter but then you  obviously know much more than I do. I listened to Toms' interview and believed him. My mistake.  Even at his best T Mac wont kick enough goals. He is second string in my opinion and the club  needs to get another big forward. It is high risk not to . We can get small forward in the draft we cannot get a ready made big forward in this draft and we have no real prospect of developing one in the near future. But I guess if you have faith in the football department then all will be ok . I don't so lets see how it pans out.

YOU'D HARDLY EXPECT tmac TO ADMIT IN AN INTERVIEW HE'S PLAYING WITH A CROCKED TOE, WOULD YOU????

20 hours ago, picket fence said:

Clearly,....  we are happy with our "Overperforming" List which has yielded Sweeeeet F.A

 

Yes clearly, which is why we have been more active in trade week than any other club.

Give it a rest! 

1 hour ago, dieter said:

YOU'D HARDLY EXPECT tmac TO ADMIT IN AN INTERVIEW HE'S PLAYING WITH A CROCKED TOE, WOULD YOU????

Yes  I would he chose not to so reflecting on his poor performance wasn't looking for excuses like some. My view is that Tom got found out by good opposition and couldn't perform.you may have other views fine with me.

2 hours ago, Jaded said:

Yes clearly, which is why we have been more active in trade week than any other club.

Give it a rest! 

Active??? We have traded away our first pick next year ( Likely top 5 given my lack of faith in our direction)

We have traded away a quick, rebounding defender Sam Frost for pick 50

And we will probably [censored] up our no 3 and 8 draft selections picking  Jimmy Toumpas and Cale Morton CLONES

You give it a rest!!

Until I see Fruits and action I'll reserve my opinion 

Watch this space!!

meanwhile JKH, Spargo, ANB, Stretch and others are STILL on our list

DOUBLE GIVE IT A REST!

1 hour ago, picket fence said:

Active??? We have traded away our first pick next year ( Likely top 5 given my lack of faith in our direction)

We have traded away a quick, rebounding defender Sam Frost for pick 50

And we will probably [censored] up our no 3 and 8 draft selections picking  Jimmy Toumpas and Cale Morton CLONES

You give it a rest!!

Until I see Fruits and action I'll reserve my opinion 

Watch this space!!

meanwhile JKH, Spargo, ANB, Stretch and others are STILL on our list

DOUBLE GIVE IT A REST!

You’re so pleasant. Why do you barrack for us again?

1 hour ago, picket fence said:

DOUBLE GIVE IT A REST!

GIVE IT A TRIPLE REST!!!

38 minutes ago, Jaded said:

You’re so pleasant. Why do you barrack for us again?

Addiction is a hard habit to break!

Looking like Bruce deal is about to be done. So he is a domino off the table.

 

good deal for the dags

23 hours ago, picket fence said:

Active??? We have traded away our first pick next year ( Likely top 5 given my lack of faith in our direction)

.....

And we will probably [censored] up our no 3 and 8 draft selections picking  Jimmy Toumpas and Cale Morton CLONES

If you think we'll draft bad players then why are you upset that we traded next year's first round pick?

?

Dogs did very well out of this deal IMO.

43 minutes ago, Axis of Bob said:

If you think we'll draft bad players then why are you upset that we traded next year's first round pick?

?

Coz we will still be Shizen next year!! We have NOT addressed two of our biggest needs 

1  A Big Key Forward ( Josh Jenkins would have been handy

2 A quick clever Crumbing forward

I'll also say this.. Tomlinson is overated but I'm happy with Langdon

We still have some Spuds which are STILL on our list

Frosty is another Blunder

I'll say this.. Picks 3 and 8 had better give us some Class and Premierships!

I'll be asking some serious questions at the AGM just on these "Salient"Points!

 

13 hours ago, picket fence said:

Coz we will still be Shizen next year!! We have NOT addressed two of our biggest needs 

1  A Big Key Forward ( Josh Jenkins would have been handy

2 A quick clever Crumbing forward

I'll also say this.. Tomlinson is overated but I'm happy with Langdon

We still have some Spuds which are STILL on our list

Frosty is another Blunder

I'll say this.. Picks 3 and 8 had better give us some Class and Premierships!

I'll be asking some serious questions at the AGM just on these "Salient"Points!

 

Agree with most of this

13 hours ago, picket fence said:

I'll be asking some serious questions at the AGM just on these "Salient"Points!

Make sure you ask them in bold like your posts on this site.

So it looks like we are going into 2020 with TMac  and  Wiederman

We will pick up a small forward in the draft and maybe another Mid or half back

I for one really think we need another KPF 

There are no ready to go in the draft

I don't think we will take enough marks or win enough ball inside 50 to kick enough goals

We really needed a big forward in my opinion

So basically we go into 2020 with the same dysfunctional set up as last year

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

10 minutes ago, Kent said:

So it looks like we are going into 2020 with TMac  and  Wiederman

We will pick up a small forward in the draft and maybe another Mid or half back

I for one really think we need another KPF 

There are no ready to go in the draft

I don't think we will take enough marks or win enough ball inside 50 to kick enough goals

We really needed a big forward in my opinion

So basically we go into 2020 with the same dysfunctional set up as last year

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I think the footy department may see some upside in Petty - Smith as KPF or even swing May forward.

2 hours ago, ManDee said:

I think the footy department may see some upside in Petty - Smith as KPF or even swing May forward.

Not Good enough!! some upside in Petty and Smith??? Maybe but should have made a big play for Bruce or Jenkins but didn't Our footy Dept IMV is Blinded by the lights eminating from their own smug beliefs.Our Forward line was farcicle last year

Blinded by the Light

Manfred Mann's Earth Band

Blinded by the light
Revved up like a deuce
Another runner in the night

Blinded by the light
Revved up like a deuce
Another runner in the night

Blinded by the light
Revved up like a deuce

Madman drummers bummers
Indians in the summer
With a teenage diplomat
In the dumps with the mumps
As the adolescent pumps
His way into his hat
With a boulder on my shoulder
Feelin' kinda older
I tripped the merry-go-round

With this very unpleasin'
Sneezin' and wheezin
The calliope crashed to the ground
The calliope crashed to the ground

Well she was
Blinded by the light
Revved up like a deuce
Another runner in the night

Blinded by the light
Revved up like a deuce
Another runner in the night

Blinded by the light
Revved up like a deuce
Another runner in the night

Blinded by…

Edited October 16, 20195 yr by picket fence

2 hours ago, ManDee said:

I think the footy department may see some upside in Petty - Smith as KPF or even swing May forward.

This has been a growing mantra but let's remember he was played exclusively as a backman at VFL level and he was only tried forward for a few games at AFL level because both MacDonald and Weid were absent.

Might work but it's no guarantee by any measure.

So our forward line where we had all the problems still hasn't improved

 

1 minute ago, Diamond_Jim said:

This has been a growing mantra but let's remember he was played exclusively as a backman at VFL level and he was only tried forward for a few games at AFL level because both MacDonald and Weid were absent.

Might work but it's no guarantee by any measure.

There are no guarantees on any player, we live in hope.

He has a handy highlights reel, can take a decent mark, fairly quick, doesn't mind a bit of rough and tumble, can kick the odd bag of goals

Light on for these qualities at MFC not sure if we were keen but seems like we missed a chance here - I'm not convinced the Weed will ever amount to much - really hope he proves me wrong next year

21 hours ago, Sydee said:

He has a handy highlights reel, can take a decent mark, fairly quick, doesn't mind a bit of rough and tumble, can kick the odd bag of goals

Light on for these qualities at MFC not sure if we were keen but seems like we missed a chance here - I'm not convinced the Weed will ever amount to much - really hope he proves me wrong next year

Me too.!!!!

On 10/17/2019 at 8:32 AM, ManDee said:

I think the footy department may see some upside in Petty - Smith as KPF or even swing May forward.

Petty has some upside but won't be our saviour next season in terms of impacting/kicking enough to make a serious difference to ladder position imv MD.

Having said that i liked some of what i saw of him this year and i think he will probably end up fighting with the Weid for the 2nd tall forward position and might even rack up a tidy 20ish goals or so all going well.   Can't see the Weid making it as the 2nd KF.  3rd target or back up depth more than likely but he might well prove me wrong.

Petty's mobility and willingness to hit any contest hard (not just leading up) should see him slightly ahead of Weid for this spot by season's end with Smith possibly chomping at their heals as the smokey.

If we end up swinging May forward for any length of time, beyond an emergency change up move (plan C) in the rare game, i think you will find that it'll be because one or more of our KF options up forward have failed quite badly prior to that and we are struggling to put a winning score on the board (again).

If that is the case the season will probably be close to gone or over by that stage.  I much prefer that May rarely goes forward as that should mean the opposite and possibly even an outside chance at playing finals.

Edited October 18, 20195 yr by Rusty Nails