POSTMATCH: Rd 19 vs St. Kilda

[Sorry kids 635]

Perfect time for the Club to fire a shot across the bow.

Drop Viney or Brayshaw, maybe both.

It is so unfair to be dropping the usual battlers who do not have much talent to begin with all the time. We need to drop back a few players with top line talent who are not performing their role to the required standard. What is fair for one is fair for all. 

[Redleg 40,907]

9 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

I think they will keep Billy on for one more year. Apparently one of the most professional players on our list and coaches love him. Unfortunately the last 2 years he hasn't had a good ran at it due to injuries.

Honestly rather Stretch getting games on a wing then the Wagner's. 

Agree.

Honestly, I am at the stage now, where if they keep picking our mate, I don’t want to go or watch. I don’t like picking on a kid who is doing his best, but this is a ruthless business and I don’t understand why we play one short every week, unless we want pick 2, which we seem to have secured.

Edited July 27, 2019 by Redleg

[Mazer Rackham 14,971]

Problem with Stretch is he exactly the same as ANB. Great trainers, professional attitude, tireless workers on the field, and not very good at football.

[GCDee 3,199]

God I hope we are tanking, and not just this bad. 

[praha 11,240]

9 hours ago, Dr. Gonzo said:

When the turnovers come down to skill errors and poor execution (eg Salem's floater to Brayshaw) I think that comes down more to execution than gameplan.

Goodwin has things he needs to work on too and if he doesn't he'll have a short coaching career but it's hard to blame him for the constant turnovers and skill errors.

Sure, but at the same time, you're talking about a pretty significant change to the way the game is structured with 6-6-6, and a team that has seen both collective drop off across the boards, of perhaps among the greatest drop offs season-on-season after finals of all time. 

All year, we have looked more like a poorly coached team, than a poor team. Gold Coast are a poor team. Earlier in the season I remember someone here posting that they couldn't tell if we were playing bad or we were just trying really hard for no reward. Or if we were simply just a bad team. It is extremely difficult to put your finger on.

Goodwin's press conferences the past two weeks have been his most honest of his coaching career, but also his most damning: three years into his coaching career, his team's skill are getting progressively worse, they are being utterly smoked in final quarters, and there is zero -- ZERO -- mention of gameplan. Why? Because the actual fundamentals have gone missing.

How does a team lose grasp of the fundamentals to such a degree that it allows almost 100 points from turnovers, can barely score, can't transition, can't rebound, can't defend, can't tackle, and on and on? Skill errors are one thing. But I don't think skills are a catalyst here. They are very clearly a symptom of a complete systematic breakdown. That is down to the coach.

Edited July 27, 2019 by praha

[Mazer Rackham 14,971]

1 minute ago, GCDee said:

God I hope we are tanking, and not just this bad. 

God here. Sorry to disappoint but you are this bad. I'm normally a compassionate God but when it comes to the Dees ... I just go back to my Old Testament cruel and vindictive ways.

Oh, and I've got some more bad news for you, GCD,  but not for another 35 years. (It's not too late to repent.)

[Diamond_Jim 12,578]

2 minutes ago, Mazer Rackham said:

Problem with Stretch is he exactly the same as ANB. Great trainers, professional attitude, tireless workers on the field, and not very good at football.

Keeping Stretch also raises the issue of the 4 injured amigos... AVB, 2 Smiths and Stretch... can we afford as a list to have four NQR players who are injury prone. Add in KK and that's 5. Put's immediate strain on the list.

[goodwindees 2,488]

9 hours ago, jnrmac said:

Apologist number 2 rears his head. 

You clearly didn't watch.  We were putrid. Gifted them 14 goals. We were 3 goals up after 3m and were hammered in nearly every stat. 

They’ve hit the post 3 times and missed several other easy ones.  If the Petty gift goal had happened to us, Demonland would be in meltdown. I also thought scoreboard flattered us to the tune of about 4 goals. They’re crap, in fact they asked for a Priority Pick 2 weeks ago and they were 7 goals better than us. 

[chook fowler 19,458]

7 hours ago, Graeme Yeats' Mullet said:

Can we at least start the required surgeries now?!

Brain and heart transplants?

[goodwindees 2,488]

9 hours ago, binman said:

Sorry, did you make a typo. I assume you mean Twiggy Lever. His turn overs directly cost us 4 goals. Pathetic. What was the losing margin?

Our highest paid player can't hit a target 25 metres away. Gets a free pass. 

You can’t have it both ways. Surely you would argue that Lever’s got an excuse because he’s missed a pre season. 

[pitmaster 3,549]

16 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

And this describes everything  quite succinctly  as to why we're  crud.

Its not injuries  per se....its about being an athlete and not a footballer 

You can teach football to an athlete. You can't teach athleticism to a footballer. Athleticism is innate. 

[Demonstone 22,508]

I thoroughly enjoyed last night.  Started with a nice dinner, followed up with a long soak in the bath and went to bed with a really good book.  Did I miss anything?

[Deesprate 1,324]

56 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

ANB, Oscar McDonald are two players the club needs to be trade off or delist (ANB OOC this year). Grab some late picks and go to the draft and get some fresh talent as its quite obvious now we are miles off being a top 8.

The likes of the Wagner's, Smith, Keilty, JKH will all be delisted.

Don’t assume this club has the common sense to ditch some of these players they just resigned ANB the ball butcher.

[Mazer Rackham 14,971]

1 minute ago, demonstone said:

I thoroughly enjoyed last night.  Started with a nice dinner, followed up with a long soak in the bath and went to bed with a really good book.  Did I miss anything?

dinner ... check

book ... check

oh ... WINE!

glass of red wine.

[pitmaster 3,549]

9 minutes ago, praha said:

 

All year, we have looked more like a poorly coached team, than a poor team.

Don't just say it, show us the difference. 

FWIW I think our lack of skills is part of the cascading effect which stems from being underdone at season's start, unexpected losses undermining confidence compounded by some players poor form and others' seasons interrupted by injury, resulting in more losses, less confidence and diminishing skills. But I could be wrong.

Anyway, I am interested in you elaborating on the above comment.

[Sorry kids 635]

1 minute ago, pitmaster said:

Don't just say it, show us the difference. 

FWIW I think our lack of skills is part of the cascading effect which stems from being underdone at season's start, unexpected losses undermining confidence compounded by some players poor form and others' seasons interrupted by injury, resulting in more losses, less confidence and diminishing skills. But I could be wrong.

Anyway, I am interested in you elaborating on the above comment.

Sorry, but AFL level skills are not lost in some having a shortened pre season. We are talking basic skills of hitting a player 30 metres away or up until this week kicking set shot at goals. The only genuine excuse is the recruiters chose players with some AGFL attributes and not others.

[Gorgoroth 12,950]

11 hours ago, Luther said:

Bad news for you - I live in London and am still unable to separate from them. You'll merely carry the burden with you.

Nah I think I’ll be too occupied with other things including $2 pints and cheap cigars. [censored] football!

10 hours ago, Jaded said:

Lucky bastard. I have 2 more games then I’m off overseas. Opposite time zone means no footy! 

 

 

Just focus on the trip. Enjoy the rest of the “season” once you leave ?

[Moonshadow 17,676]

10 hours ago, jnrmac said:

That's hilarious. You're one funny guy. 

We dont have enough members to lose  them through total ineptitude fin the club. There are plenty who won't renew or follow the club and that'll make you happy? Totally stupid. 

Where did I say that would make me happy? Stop your usual ranting and take a breath before posting [censored]

[jnrmac 20,060]

1 hour ago, Redleg said:

Agree on all except Oscar, who was terrible last night. 

Went back and looked at some of the games last year and he was ok. Is he just having a poor season or is he not up to it, I am unsure. 

I would like to see him tried up forward, to see if he can do anything there. I still think he needs another 5-8 kgs of muscle and that would be a priority if I was in charge. I think extra muscle would boost his confidence and give him every chance to make it.If that didn’t help and last night became his norm,  well then he would be gone.

I am now worried about Baker and Billy, who I like, but has too many injuries and when playing doesn’t get the ball enough.

Anyway we have some interesting decisions to make soon. 

 

You're unsure of what is blindingly obvious??

hes no good and never has been.zero intensity or attack on the footy.but if you can't see it after this long there's not much help for you 

[Demon Dynasty 17,109]

10 hours ago, america de cali said:

If there is too much heat that he can’t pick up the ball then try to tap it out to advantage. No he has to eat like Jones’s used to when playing inside.

I cant believe we still don't get this part pretty much as a team with a few exceptions.  We watch other (quality) teams tap or kick the ball out towards their perceived or 'seen' fellow players weekly so the tapee or fellow player can run on to it or kick / tap it further again (it's called gaining yardage Goody)  yet, apart from Gawn and Jeffy (from memory), our blokes are hell bent on taking posession at every opportunity and getting immediately tackled for another bruising contested ball up / stoppage.  And guess what, we then look to do same again if we feel any heat, which we do as we don't maintain outliers around the stoppage, too many going for the ground ball always which encourages the opp to bring an extra to the ball to either sweat on this inisde mess or sit him on the outside for the recieve once we tire and they begin to get on top on the inside as well as the outside.

An almost fully fit available list might improve some connection skills, but certainly won't change aspects of the 'style/manner' in which we do or don't do the every day things needed to gain small advantages in a match.

The way we structure up (or don't) and maintain it (or don't), including other basics like getting smaller / medium crumbers front and square, not having 3 to 4 defenders up in a marking contest, ensuring your two key tall forwards make clear separation on running patterns instead of getting in each other's way, and the above possessin obsession style etc etc lies with Goody and his methods.

Won't win you many games of footy on the trot and very easy to counter and defeat as an opponent, but certainly a fabulous looking dog's breakfast.

Edited July 28, 2019 by Rusty Nails

[Gorgoroth 12,950]

For those talking about injuries, missing games etc.

Lets agree that yes, we have, especially in the back 6.

But, our best have played. Oliver, Gawn, Tmac for most of the year. And going by last year, Harmes, Brayshaw, Salem who were also good. They have played most of the year.

But let’s face facts, getting the ball, not much of a problem, skills, massive problem even from those who are our best users of the ball. Our problems have been this. We get it into f50 lots, we score very little, they get it into their f50 usually less and score much more. And they do so very very easily.

Goal kicking, not a new thing, we have been poor for years.

Desire to gut run defensively. We run in beautiful waves forward and jog backwards.

Game plan, last year Goodwin had a great plan with the extra players off the back of the square. This year, no idea.

 

[davo 209]

1 hour ago, Sorry kids said:

Perfect time for the Club to fire a shot across the bow.

Drop Viney or Brayshaw, maybe both.

It is so unfair to be dropping the usual battlers who do not have much talent to begin with all the time. We need to drop back a few players with top line talent who are not performing their role to the required standard. What is fair for one is fair for all. 

Wagners both need to be dropped and not played again, our problem is our bottom 6 players are trash, Wagners, OMac, ANB, Baker and Smith were absolute rubbish, it’s the difference between winning and losing! Baker is young and will be a good player, the other 5 are not worth persevering with! 

Edited July 28, 2019 by davo

[dl4e 5,851]

11 hours ago, KLV said:

Basically the same as the 70s

 

That is exactly right. In fact the side of 76 would have flogged those no hopers of last night

[Sorry kids 635]

20 minutes ago, davo said:

Wagners both need to be dropped and not played again, our problem is our bottom 6 players are trash, Wagners, OMac, ANB, Baker and Smith were absolute rubbish, it’s the difference between winning and losing! Baker is young and will be a good player, the other 5 are not worth persevering with! 

I agree with your assessment of those five however what I am saying is why are some of our stars not held to account for not playing to the best of their ability. At least the Wagners are probably playing to the best of their ability.

[Gunna’s 2,104]

Will I have to stay and watch next weeks game to win the jaguar f-pace?