Last nights game.

Umpires. 3 votes.

The media bang on about the look of the game, rule changes ect.

Umpire like they did last night and we have no problem.

Let them go.

Put the good teams on in the prime time slots and the crap teams at 6pm on Sunday night and a lot of this would be fixed.

The AFL needs to take accountability for poor Friday night games by firstly gifting Carlton/St Kilda so many games and then, mystifyingly, defending the decision. It really is amateur.

Some commentators do have some merit in the opinions regarding congestion and over defensively set ups, but I can't agree more with the OP, leave the game alone and fix the umpiring interpretations.

Typical over reaction from the media.. Mind you most of the noise initially was from Slobbo & Ralph who are Essendon supporters when their team were 2-6 or something like that.

 

33 minutes ago, small but forward said:

Put the good teams on in the prime time slots and the crap teams at 6pm on Sunday night and a lot of this would be fixed.

The AFL needs to take accountability for poor Friday night games by firstly gifting Carlton/St Kilda so many games and then, mystifyingly, defending the decision. It really is amateur.

You can add the Bulldogs to the list. This is not 2016 or 2017 based on 2016 form. 

Game looks a lot better without navy blue and white on prime time

2 hours ago, gOLLy said:

Last nights game.

Umpires. 3 votes.

The media bang on about the look of the game, rule changes ect.

Umpire like they did last night and we have no problem.

Let them go.

Spot on. Remove the idiotic introduced rules of recent years and it's fair game. Couldn't agree more. Last night there was that ruck rule debacle where a Cats player did not nominate and only the Richmond ruckman could go up for it, beyond stupidity.

i will miss seeing carlton being mercilessly destroyed on friday nights

very therapeutic and schadenfreudic

15 minutes ago, MSFebey said:

Spot on. Remove the idiotic introduced rules of recent years and it's fair game. Couldn't agree more. Last night there was that ruck rule debacle where a Cats player did not nominate and only the Richmond ruckman could go up for it, beyond stupidity.

Even worse was when no-one nominated and the boundary umpire was told to throw it in again. 

I despise BT's commentary, but in this case he was absolutely right....throw the damn thing in and get on with the game.  No need to wait for rucks to walk over.  If no-one is allowed to ruck, then let the ball hit the ground.  Better still get rid of nominations, and only 2 people can contest. 

.....it ain't that hard! Except apparently for the AFL.

Just now, george_on_the_outer said:

Even worse was when no-one nominated and the boundary umpire was told to throw it in again. 

I despise BT's commentary, but in this case he was absolutely right....throw the damn thing in and get on with the game.  No need to wait for rucks to walk over.  If no-one is allowed to ruck, then let the ball hit the ground.  Better still get rid of nominations, and only 2 people can contest. 

.....it ain't that hard! Except apparently for the AFL.

Didn't see that one but jeez, what a shocker! Yep, ain't that hard, third man up gets a free against.

8 minutes ago, MSFebey said:

Didn't see that one but jeez, what a shocker! Yep, ain't that hard, third man up gets a free against.

Because the AFL and umpires would

if 4 men went up. /sarcasm

But yeah free against the 3rd man up solves it and stops wasting time and energy. 

 

2 hours ago, small but forward said:

Put the good teams on in the prime time slots and the crap teams at 6pm on Sunday night and a lot of this would be fixed.

The AFL needs to take accountability for poor Friday night games by firstly gifting Carlton/St Kilda so many games and then, mystifyingly, defending the decision. It really is amateur.

The continued refusal of the AFL to consider a flexible Friday night fixture is a mystery. It has a fantastic product but it risks killing interest in that product by its myopic Machiavellian approach.

The interesting thing is that a flexible fixture would be good for sponsors of the less powerful clubs such as ourselves in that sponsors would know that with success come exposure unlike now.

I hope Gill took a good hard look at today's game at the G. Be very careful with changing the rules Gill, there is nothing wrong with the game.

Just the teams you and your mates at Channel 7 allow to play in the marquee time slots.

2 minutes ago, Win4theAges said:

I hope Gill took a good hard look at today's game at the G. Be very careful with changing the rules Gill, there is nothing wrong with the game.

Just the teams you and your mates at Channel 7 allow to play in the marquee time slots.

And both umpired properly Haw Bris games 

I feel the umpires actually left too much alone last night by putting the whistle away. Rewarding undeserved players is not the answer either. Have to balance the middle ground and reward effort.

Edited August 4, 20187 yr by johndemonic

They put the whistle away in last quarters especially.

2 minutes ago, MSFebey said:

And both umpired properly Haw Bris games 

 

"Whistle away" So when we don't get HTB decisions go our way because the umpires want to even up our match with us 10 points up and looking to ice it, don't complain.

The worst look in the game is the AFL Commission.  They are a disgrace. 

whilst close games are good for spectators, it doesn't mean the game is good. still plenty of areas that need fixing or setting the clock back

That Crows Port game was one of the best I've seen for some time.

The game is continuing to make Gill and his clowns look like fools.

Yes the game has minor issues to clear up eg. Ruck nomination rule, running through the 5 meter protected area etc.

All this nonsense is all about the almighty dollar, not the state of the game.

8 minutes ago, Bitter but optimistic said:

That Crows Port game was one of the best I've seen for some time.

It was great result all round??

11 minutes ago, Bitter but optimistic said:

That Crows Port game was one of the best I've seen for some time.

What is the impact on the ' maid' when the dees are not involved in a game that exciting BBO ??

2 minutes ago, pineapple dee said:

What is the impact on the ' maid' when the dees are not involved in a game that exciting BBO ??

Unfortunately I am sans maid ATM and being severely hounded by Workcover.

5 minutes ago, Bitter but optimistic said:

Unfortunately I am sans maid ATM and being severely hounded by Workcover.

$2 an hour

Im beginning to think the state of the game has more to do with the state of Carlton, Doggies, GCS and to a lesser extent St Kilda and Freo than the rules.

To fix this, Carlton and Doggies to play each other at MARS stadium at night under dark eaxh week, GCS to play local league in Shanghai and St Kilda and Freo to merge and relocate to Tassie.