Langdon would certainly compliment our side. But the player we need is Brad Hill. If the club thinks this list can get a flag then Hill is our man. Quick with elite skills. Also elite endurance. Wouldn’t give up pick 3 for Hill alone but we need to chase him. 

Im not convinced Collingwood will get Langdon. They apparently have their own cap issues. If we go for Langdon I wouldn’t be trading him for Brayshaw. At best it’s be an even deal. At worst he plays at 2018 levels at freo and we lose out big time. 

Would pic 3 for hill and Langdon be overs?

does hill play in the f50?

23 hours ago, Wiseblood said:

I'll be interested to see how we negotiate with Freo as well after the rubbish from last year.  I can't see them attempting to do us any favours, although finishing on the bottom means we possibly hold all the cards in terms of him going into something like the pre-season draft.

Could you tell me the last time a wanted, quality player stiffed his former club and went into the preseason draft to go to a near bottom team?

Edited July 20, 20196 yr by Moonshadow

1 minute ago, Moonshadow said:

Could you tell me the last time a wanted, quality player stiffed his former club and went into the preseason draft to go to a near bottom team?

That wasn't really the point, Moonie. It's more around how they try to stuff us last year with Jesse, but this time we have more power. I'm sure a trade will happen if he wants to come here, but we have more leverage this time. 

10 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

That wasn't really the point, Moonie. It's more around how they try to stuff us last year with Jesse, but this time we have more power. I'm sure a trade will happen if he wants to come here, but we have more leverage this time. 

What is this "more power" or "leverage"? Is it that he is OOC and can 'potentially' come to us in the preseason draft? If so, then it is on point. 

But I'll move on

Edited July 20, 20196 yr by Moonshadow

5 minutes ago, Moonshadow said:

What is this "more power" or "leverage"? Is it that he is OOC and can 'potentially' come to us in the preseason draft? If so, then it is on point. 

But I'll move on

Very ordinary player tonight. The knock on his disposal is correct. On tonight’s performance, a Pick around 30 is about right. 

On tonight’s game Zak Jones is a better player, he’d be worth about a Pick 25. 

13 hours ago, Hunt29 said:

Langdon would certainly compliment our side. But the player we need is Brad Hill. If the club thinks this list can get a flag then Hill is our man. Quick with elite skills. Also elite endurance. Wouldn’t give up pick 3 for Hill alone but we need to chase him. 

Im not convinced Collingwood will get Langdon. They apparently have their own cap issues. If we go for Langdon I wouldn’t be trading him for Brayshaw. At best it’s be an even deal. At worst he plays at 2018 levels at freo and we lose out big time. 

Langdon wouldn’t get a game at the Pies. Phillips & Sidebottom are both much better Wingers. 

I don't really see the attraction

18 hours ago, FireInTheBelly said:

I don't really see the attraction

To be honest I think Freo will play hardball but he won’t attract anything more than our second rounder. 

On 7/20/2019 at 9:54 AM, DemonOX said:

Would pic 3 for hill and Langdon be overs?

does hill play in the f50?

For Mahoney it won’t be. That’s one thing you can bet on.

On 7/20/2019 at 9:54 AM, DemonOX said:

Would pic 3 for hill and Langdon be overs?

does hill play in the f50?

We can’t trade our first round pick this year. The only option is if we trade pick 3 for 2 picks, one within the first round, then on trade the other pick. 

We must use a first round selection this year, unless the rules have changed? 

If we pay more than a 2nd rounder then it’s daylight robbery. His kicking is very ordinary. 

7 minutes ago, Nelo said:

If we pay more than a 2nd rounder then it’s daylight robbery. His kicking is very ordinary. 

An outside mid who can’t kick? So what exactly are we getting here?

20 minutes ago, olisik said:

An outside mid who can’t kick? So what exactly are we getting here?

Speed and that’s it. 

based on what we've seen this year, i'd rather get brandon ellis as a free agent and keep our second round pick and use it at the draft

On 7/20/2019 at 9:54 AM, DemonOX said:

Would pic 3 for hill and Langdon be overs?

does hill play in the f50?

This was my thought also pick 3 for hill and Langdon with maybe a second rounder coming back

15 minutes ago, whatwhatsaywhat said:

based on what we've seen this year, i'd rather get brandon ellis as a free agent and keep our second round pick and use it at the draft

As much as I dislike said player, this makes a lot of sense.

is Baker our langdon already in the system?

2nd round picks will range from #19 to #36 (excluding academy etc players)  A very wide range!   

Our 2nd round pick will be around ~20-22.  Hope people aren't saying we use that as 'the second rounder' for Langdon!!  

Would much rather use it for someone who is a proven goal kicker of any shape or size.

Edited July 22, 20196 yr by Lucifer's Hero

4 minutes ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

2nd round picks will range from #19 to #36 (excluding academy etc players)  A very wide range!   

Our 2nd round pick will be around ~20-22.  Hope people aren't saying we use that as 'the second rounder' for Langdon!!  

Would much rather use it for someone who is a proven goal kicker of any shape or size.

Kysaiah Pickett

17 minutes ago, Engorged Onion said:

is Baker our langdon already in the system?

Maybe and I am getting excited about Jordon, who is continuing to develop very well. Also Sparrow to come back and Nietsche ( sorry about spelling,) who was spoken about by players in pre season as being very talented.

IMO unless we are targeting a champion, we should try and find a FA or two and use our draft picks for top end talent.

Can’t recall any FA’s we have picked up.I think you have more chance with a disgruntled player possibly not getting a run, than one merely going for money. 

Edited July 22, 20196 yr by Redleg

I personally don't like Langdon as a player and i wouldn't be giving up anything significant for him. he runs all day sure, but he's not a very good kick at all, makes average decisions and while he'd probably fit in, i don't see him being a regular in the best 22 or contributing in any meaningful way to improving this side to the point it can challenge for a flag. 

Brad Hill on the other hand... Speed, class, skills

On 7/20/2019 at 9:54 AM, DemonOX said:

Would pic 3 for hill and Langdon be overs?

does hill play in the f50?

NO! That would be a super deal for us!!?

Probably said this 3 or 4x's already, but this guy is not going to help us improve to the levels we're all hoping for in the future. 

Besides his tank & a bit of pace, i don't see anything else to suggest he's a talented footballer. I really hope we look elsewhere.