I am not going into specifics but he knows how to party and I wouldn’t want him around my club.

on top of that he’s an undersized power forward who doesn’t cover enough ground defensively. We already have a power forward who does that.

12 hours ago, Watts Jurrah Dunn? said:

Based on the fact he's had 5 seasons at AFL level where he's kicked over 30 goals in a season - numbers that Harmes and Bugg could only dream of. Put him in a training singlet and you'll be drooling over him in no time. 

That was 2 years ago which is a long time in footy, just think the game has passed him by

Don't drool, just support who is in hte squad, unlike others.

Still have an opinion on where players need to improve, and surprisingly can talk to them about it

If FD see emough in Crameri to sign him, will ask why when I get the opportunity, and will give him 100% support

 

 

 

 

Thread needs a poll.

48 minutes ago, JJJ said:

I am not going into specifics but he knows how to party and I wouldn’t want him around my club.

on top of that he’s an undersized power forward who doesn’t cover enough ground defensively. We already have a power forward who does that.

The beginning of the Mosquito fleet?

Edited October 28, 20177 yr by Wadda We Sing

1 hour ago, JJJ said:

I am not going into specifics but he knows how to party and I wouldn’t want him around my club.

on top of that he’s an undersized power forward who doesn’t cover enough ground defensively. We already have a power forward who does that.

Do you think that Dustin Martin and Swanny go to the US to see the sights? Martin is such a bad influence on the Tiges.

1 hour ago, Demon Disciple said:

Paging @Bitter but optimistic

I'll let it go.

18 hours ago, mo64 said:

Do you think that Dustin Martin and Swanny go to the US to see the sights? Martin is such a bad influence on the Tiges.

I still wouldn’t have him but if you’re going to make that argument at least attempt to make it relevant. Clubs always weigh up risk vs reward when dealing with players and you’ve compared 2 Brownlow medalists to a washed up, undersized power forward with no other skills required in today’s game.

On top of that, both the Tigers and Collingwood sacked players who were close to both of those blokes in an effort to make them fly straight. 

No. Offers very little. I'd rather a rookie punt.

'Old Melbourne' would draft this guy.  That's because we had a rubbish list and would take anyone who smiled nicely at us. 

We've moved past guys like this. 

We'll play a high brand of pressure again next year and with talls in Hogan/McDonald and excellent marking mid-talls in Petracca, Hannan, Balic and vandenBerg we don't need this guy.  Harmes marks pretty well too. 

Two talls and high pressure smalls and mid-talls is the go. 

Let North take him. 

Edited October 29, 20177 yr by ProDee

4 minutes ago, ProDee said:

'Old Melbourne' would draft this guy.  That's because we had a rubbish list and would take anyone who smiled nicely at us. 

We've moved past guys like this. 

We'll play a high brand of pressure again next year and with talls in Hogan/McDonald and excellent marking mid-talls in Petracca, Hannan, Balic and vandenBerg we don't need this guy.  Harmes marks pretty well too. 

Two talls and high pressure smalls and mid-talls is the go. 

I think I would add one caveat to that. 

Old Melbourne would add guys like Crameri but would expect them to be 50 plus goal forwards or rack up 25 posies a game. See most of our recruiting for 2012.

I think it will work should we rookie him and use him for depth. If people are expecting a first option forward then they will be sorely disappointed.

 

Not  in our Demographic.

3 hours ago, Barney Rubble said:

Not  in our Demographic.

Agree; the only players we should look at in this age group now, if at all are real leaders like Cross and Lewis and he's very much not that.

1 hour ago, rjay said:

Agree; the only players we should look at in this age group now, if at all are real leaders like Cross and Lewis and he's very much not that.

Please not another player just for leadership. Lewis won't be in the best 22 if or when this team is challenging for a flag unless (touch wood) we pull out something special this year. He should still have value on and off field but the best players need to become the best leaders.

I think it's getting closer to the time where you bring in a risk-reward player like a Stewie Dew or Brian Lake, who could do nothing but also could fill a specific need in September.

I'm not sure Crameri could be that kind of player but he has some things that work in favour. He can kick a goal, at his best he was a superb athlete with a rare combination of endurance, speed and size and might be able to play different positions. 

Travis Cloke is also available.

23 minutes ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

Travis Cloke is also available.

Perfect fit for Nought Melb

8 hours ago, DeeSpencer said:

Please not another player just for leadership. Lewis won't be in the best 22 if or when this team is challenging for a flag unless (touch wood) we pull out something special this year. He should still have value on and off field but the best players need to become the best leaders.

I think it's getting closer to the time where you bring in a risk-reward player like a Stewie Dew or Brian Lake, who could do nothing but also could fill a specific need in September.

I'm not sure Crameri could be that kind of player but he has some things that work in favour. He can kick a goal, at his best he was a superb athlete with a rare combination of endurance, speed and size and might be able to play different positions. 

Comprehension problem there 'Dee'????

Edited October 29, 20177 yr by rjay

29 - injury prone and has missed a lot of footy, for the 1-2 years he may have left as a fringe player i hardly see him as worth the investment. 

Hogan and Mcdonald together up forward will give us enough tall targets, i personally think you need four ground level pressure forwards minimum this year to play deep in September

I suspect McDonald will rotate through the ruck and Petracca or Hannan will play taller rather than playing another tall player as a supporting ruckman. 

On ‎27‎/‎10‎/‎2017 at 8:15 AM, buck_nekkid said:

Can’t we pick up DFAs for nothing now, in the appropriate time window?  Won’t even cost us 47.  It is more a case if we have a spot we are prepared to use on the main list.  Otherwise we will have to wait for the rookie draft.  I think the FD will pass for the main list, and if history serves, will pull a Smokey from a state league before a DFA for either list.

it's the opportunity cost I am talking about. we don't use pick 47 as there is no spot on the list for that pick if we take a Delisted free agent

On 29/10/2017 at 6:57 AM, JJJ said:

I still wouldn’t have him but if you’re going to make that argument at least attempt to make it relevant. Clubs always weigh up risk vs reward when dealing with players and you’ve compared 2 Brownlow medalists to a washed up, undersized power forward with no other skills required in today’s game.

On top of that, both the Tigers and Collingwood sacked players who were close to both of those blokes in an effort to make them fly straight. 

I haven't got an issue with the highlighted point, but your initial post simply cast aspersions on Crameri's character, without any substance.

No movement?

Not surprised 

On 31/10/2017 at 9:38 AM, mo64 said:

I haven't got an issue with the highlighted point, but your initial post simply cast aspersions on Crameri's character, without any substance.

I’ve associated with some of his now ex teammates and he’s been around. I think he makes bad choices outside of footy. Don’t want our players to do the same.

Apparently a terrific fellow though.

I reckon all these speculative threads can be wiped

We're going to the draft.

1 hour ago, JJJ said:

I’ve associated with some of his now ex teammates and he’s been around. I think he makes bad choices outside of footy. Don’t want our players to do the same.

Apparently a terrific fellow though.

Do you make bad choices, mate?

17 minutes ago, A F said:

Do you make bad choices, mate?

I barrack for the dees, AF. Does that count??

2 minutes ago, small but forward said:

I barrack for the dees, AF. Does that count??

I read this forum too much.