Adelaide gets GIBBS from Carlton ,Melbourne gets LEVER from Adelaide and Carlton gets a Melbourne player. To make the 3 way trade work include additional conditions which could be in the form of draft picks. i.e Aldelaide give us lever,they receive Tyson and our 2nd rd pick,they pass this off to Carlton plus their 3rd pick for Gibbs. the Dees gets Carlton's 5th rd pick.Aldelaide gets Carlton 4th rd pick.

Confused,life wasn;t meant to be easy.

Edited September 8, 20177 yr by Grapeviney

4 minutes ago, ENYAW said:

Adelaide gets GIBBS from Carlton ,Melbourne gets LEVER from Adelaide and Carlton gets a Melbourne player. To make the 3 way trade work include additional conditions which could be in the form of draft picks. i.e Aldelaide give us lever,they receive Tyson and our 2nd rd pick,they pass this off to Carlton plus their 3rd pick for Gibbs. the Dees gets Carlton's 5th rd pick.Aldelaide gets Carlton 4th rd pick.

Confused,life wasn;t meant to be easy.

I don't think the deal needs to involve a 5th round pick ENYAW... unnecessarily complicated.

I highly doubt we will be trading Tyson.

Watts 

Shouldn't this thread be on the trade board

Shouldn't this be in the Lever thread as it revolves around getting Lever?

Shouldn't this thread be on the whacko general board with other oddities of life?

30 minutes ago, Is Dom Is Good said:

I highly doubt we will be trading Tyson.

Carlton would want a lot more I suspect.

Edited September 8, 20177 yr by Wrecked Owl Dees Function

43 minutes ago, Is Dom Is Good said:

I highly doubt we will be trading Tyson.

Soon we'll need to rename Carlscum to Greater Western Blues. They do love the GWS boys.

Simples. 

Blues give up Gibbs and pick 37 to Crows

Crows give up Lever to Dees

Dees give up pick 10 to Blues

Blues use pick 2 and 10 for Josh Kelly and pick 13. 

Edited September 8, 20177 yr by spirit of norm smith
Simples

Adelaide are huge losers in that scenario. 

I wouldn't get involved with the blues unless we absolutely have to, they are known to be impossible to deal with 

I reckon the Blues are really in this deal. We trade Lewis and Hogan to the Blues. They therefore learn defensive Boxing under the Marquis Rules and become happy reading comics. We pick up all their Team after one months training as an equal Trade, and throw Murphy and Gibbs to Crows for Lever. Everyone moves on.

1 hour ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

Adelaide are huge losers in that scenario. 

Who cares!!

Gibbs and Dees 2nd Rounder to Crows

Lever and Blues 3rd Rounder to Dees 

Dees 1st & 2nd rounder to Blues

Blues use 2 first round picks on Kelly 

 

Crows don't need Gibbs anymore so you can eliminate Gibbs from any trade discussion.

5 hours ago, Abe said:

I wouldn't get involved with the blues unless we absolutely have to, they are known to be impossible to deal with 

Yeah lets stick with Pies they're pushovers !

9 hours ago, Pennant St Dee said:

Gibbs and Dees 2nd Rounder to Crows

Lever and Blues 3rd Rounder to Dees 

Dees 1st & 2nd rounder to Blues

Blues use 2 first round picks on Kelly 

 

Well done PSD. At least some creative ideas. Most posters just rubbish suggestions then give no alternative or ideas.

11 hours ago, Pennant St Dee said:

Gibbs and Dees 2nd Rounder to Crows

Lever and Blues 3rd Rounder to Dees 

Dees 1st & 2nd rounder to Blues

Blues use 2 first round picks on Kelly 

 

That's a win for Carlton, we have enough defenders would rather Kelly then lever, we need outside run that's what wins games, midfield depth is what all about, if Kelly is up for grabs go hard.

2 hours ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Well done PSD. At least some creative ideas. Most posters just rubbish suggestions then give no alternative or ideas.

Maybe because most of the suggested trades are rubbish that heavily favor Melbourne or ream another club

What about that Martin from Richmond, is he available !! Or Cotchin . Robbie Gray from Port.

Mitchell from West COast.

But the big one would be Kennady from Swans. He is a restricted FA.

Kelly will go to Geelong. It would be fair if he did. They need a bit of class in that team and the AFL would like to give the Cats a bit of a leg up. They're struggling.

On 08/09/2017 at 11:18 PM, Pennant St Dee said:

Gibbs and Dees 2nd Rounder to Crows

Lever and Blues 3rd Rounder to Dees 

Dees 1st & 2nd rounder to Blues

Blues use 2 first round picks on Kelly 

 

Now way the Crows do that, Gibbs is 29 next season.

I reckon our Lewis will be too busy for his Italian Island holiday. there is one around here he could see though...........

Adelaide - 5 

Freo - 10, 27, Kent

MFC - 40, Lever, Balic