1 hour ago, Brownie said:

collingwood big footy saying our players were inciting their fans.

hysterical

Melbourne players inciting the crowd | BigFooty
https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/melbourne-players-inciting-the-crowd.1168293/

There's some absolute spun gold over at Big Footy right now...

...this isn't bad for a laugh

https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/collingwood-need-to-end-their-association-with-melbourne-on-qb.1168243/ 

*chortle chortle*

 

I know there was a bye and I'm not sure if anyone actually mentioned it....but isn't that um..2 in a row!

2 hours ago, Sir Why You Little said:

Will be very interesting to see where Hogan fits into the forward line when he comes back. 

What is his optimum role..?

I have a theory that Hogan is vital up forward when we don't have momentum and we can only bomb it in under enormous pressure, but when we have the momentum, Hogan in the middle is better as a linking target who can take a grab. Goodwin is starting to use him in the middle and I think we play better that way, especially if we have a recognised ruckman in so Pederson and watts can play as forwards.

5 minutes ago, the rolling fog said:

There's some absolute spun gold over at Big Footy right now...

...this isn't bad for a laugh

https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/collingwood-need-to-end-their-association-with-melbourne-on-qb.1168243/ 

*chortle chortle*

 

I agree with it, [censored] them off and give it to Essendon. If the Daniher/MND legacy continues it means more to us and Essendon. 

The fact that we get the gate every year doesn't sit well with me anymore either. I know we need it, but it should alternate. 

32 minutes ago, titan_uranus said:

IIRC, only two: Carlton and Essendon.

I'll double check but I am confident in each of the other 9, we've been down by 20+.

It was rhetorical, but Richmond. They got the last five. Carlton we let them peg back the four-to-five goals, and Essendon I've stricken from my memory.

From the Magpie Bigfooty forum.....

"Why do they get the home game each QB? That's BS time to get back to being ruthless Pies and give knowone nothing...." (sic)

 

I can just imagine the neanderthal typing that through his gritted tooth.

 

 

21 minutes ago, Bay Riffin said:

were you saying that in the first month of footy ?

No. i am saying it now. The Midfield is too quick for him now. 

 

3 minutes ago, ding said:

From the Magpie Bigfooty forum.....

"Why do they get the home game each QB? That's BS time to get back to being ruthless Pies and give knowone nothing...." (sic)

 

I can just imagine the neanderthal typing that through his gritted tooth.

 

 

Did anyone else read this in Donald trumps voice?? 

2 minutes ago, ding said:

From the Magpie Bigfooty forum.....

"Why do they get the home game each QB? That's BS time to get back to being ruthless Pies and give knowone nothing...." (sic)

 

I can just imagine the neanderthal typing that through his gritted tooth.

 

 

" They had the bulk of the crowd which gave the umpires anunitotion."

anunitotion

anunitotion

anunitotion

I was surprised to read that we won the centre clearances so convincingly and came out even in clearances overall. Not a bad effort by the 'worst' midfield in the competition against the 'best' midfield.

Upon watching the replay. Despite winning the tackle count, I thought we missed a lot of tackles today. There were plenty of tackles that got broken and a few where we had them corralled but just didn't put the tackle on and gave them an 'out'. At the very least we should be able to put a smother on. I think Maynard put on two smothers on Salem and melksham and its something we should be doing more.

Not trying to be negative but if we can fine tune these things to our game, we'll make it easier for ourselves.

1 hour ago, Crompton's the man said:

Not being mean but ....

 

Sean Smith ?

i saw this mark IRL, sitting on the fence on the wing at the Gabba, eating a pie, looked up and saw Smith Snr launch over the playing field, nearly missed it!

To quote the Collingwood fan sitting in M7, Row 3, 3rd seat in from the aisle on the quarter time siren after Dunn gave away a free to T.Mac. " The bloody AFL has been giving this club handouts for the last 20 years. I can't believe that these people come to the games and follow this team."

Well fella, it's moments like today why we come to the football. We are as passionate as the bloke next door, it's an escape from the real world and we live in the moment. Yes, you have seen your team win a grand final, most of us have not but we will continue to scream, cheer and hug the stranger sitting next to us and maybe our day will come.

The noise in the last quarter was simply incredible, it's been a long time since I heard that much noise from us. Take a bow Melbourne fans, you willed your team over the line today. I'm still out of breath and my heart hasn't slowed one bit since leaving the ground. 

Well done Dees!!!!

What a win. I'd say that's our second best win of the year (behind the obvious Adelaide result): big crowd, played poorly for large parts of the game, minus Gawn and Hogan, the winner jumps into 6th, the loser has a very tough road ahead. But we held it all together and managed to hold on. I haven't felt as elated after a win in a long time. It's winning those close ones.

Thought it was a terrific effort from Goodwin and co to turn things in the second half and for such a young team to respond as they did is very exciting.

Oliver's third quarter was insane. The kid is a genius. Oscar started off slowly but by the end of the game was in our top 2 or 3 players. He was a rock. Clever little kick from him into the path of Harmes for Watts' sealer too. Petracca got the accolades and as I said to my old man during his ordinary first quarter and a bit, he is going to be that mercurial player that bobs up with a moment or two to turn the game. Sure enough, he did in that second quarter to keep us in touch.

Had a couple of scum supporters in front of me from Brighton, given the botox in the faces of the ladies and their husbands wanted to punch my block off, but couldn't reach due to the 6'6ness of me. Loved giving it to them in the end. Some will say it's bad sport, others will say stick it right up 'em.

Go the bloody redlegs.

1 minute ago, Demon77 said:

To quote the Collingwood fan sitting in M7, Row 3, 3rd seat in from the aisle on the quarter time siren after Dunn gave away a free to T.Mac. " The bloody AFL has been giving this club handouts for the last 20 years. I can't believe that these people come to the games and follow this team."

This seems to be an increasingly familiar refrain for may supporters of Melbourne based clubs of late, as least that I've encountered, even amongst friends who support other clubs. I mean, I can see where they're coming from and/or why they might think that. But to me it also smacks a bit of the chubby kid who got picked on a high school, and has come back from summer holidays looking sharp and some don't know how deal with it. Unfamiliarity can be scary to some. 

6 hours ago, Clint Bizkit said:

Umpires helped us a lot.

Oscar was VAFA in the first half but All Australian in the second.

Fitting that Watts kicked the sealer, an excellent goal at that.

Tyson does himself no favours.

Team selection still wrong despite the win.

On a personal note, Mini Bizkit was born a few days ago, bought her membership last night so today she was our good luck charm.

 

Congrats, mate. 

As for your post, I felt the umpiring was bad both ways. They got a great run of it in the second quarter. We had some key decisions go our way in the last.

5 minutes ago, A F said:

What a win. I'd say that's our second best win of the year (behind the obvious Adelaide result): big crowd, played poorly for large parts of the game, minus Gawn and Hogan, the winner jumps into 6th, the loser has a very tough road ahead. But we held it all together and managed to hold on. I haven't felt as elated after a win in a long time. It's winning those close ones.

Thought it was a terrific effort from Goodwin and co to turn things in the second half and for such a young team to respond as they did is very exciting.

Oliver's third quarter was insane. The kid is a genius. Oscar started off slowly but by the end of the game was in our top 2 or 3 players. He was a rock. Clever little kick from him into the path of Harmes for Watts' sealer too. Petracca got the accolades and as I said to my old man during his ordinary first quarter and a bit, he is going to be that mercurial player that bobs up with a moment or two to turn the game. Sure enough, he did in that second quarter to keep us in touch.

Had a couple of scum supporters in front of me from Brighton, given the botox in the faces of the ladies and their husbands wanted to punch my block off, but couldn't reach due to the 6'6ness of me. Loved giving it to them in the end. Some will say it's bad sport, others will say stick it right up 'em.

Go the bloody redlegs.

i say stick it right up em every chance you get.

Had a slab on the result with a pies mate. Got a text at half time... 'How is that free beer looking, mate?'

I replied 'don't count your beer until it's hatched'

Hehehehe

Got them to send $50 to MND. I can buy my own beer.

21 minutes ago, Uncle Fester said:

Had a slab on the result with a pies mate. Got a text at half time... 'How is that free beer looking, mate?'

I replied 'don't count your beer until it's hatched'

Hehehehe

Got them to send $50 to MND. I can buy my own beer.

lol thats bloody gold

Goodwin again changed things up at half time and got the result.

His move of Tommy Mac into the ruck helped shift the midfield battle back to us after we were annihilated in the first half.

We have a very proactive coach...not afraid to try something different.

We've got a good one in Goodwin.

Just watched the replay.

Collingwood fans would have to be kidding themselves blaming the umps. We got some lucky decisions in the last 2 minutes but other than that we were robbed of several holding the ball calls which were then rebounded and resulted in the Collingwood goals.

My first impressions were that Tyson was pretty good but he made some bad kicking errors in the last quarter.

Salem a good 2nd half.

Melksham really average, but a nice goal.

Watts dropped so many easy marks but kept at it and came up big when it mattered. 

Garlett was epic, some of his defensive running to shutdown the Collingwood mids was crucial.

Grundy is average, just hack kicks it out the ruck overtime he grabs it.

Was thinking to myself early, why have we chosen Omac over Dunn. Then Dunn gave us an arm chop and panicked next to the boundary for a deliberate. There were 3 instances where he crapped himself next to the boundary line, a deer in the headlights. Then Oscar lifted.

Howe was great and hard to pass at times.

Loved that Oliver was always looking forward this week.

Hunt was really poor, can't remember him hitting a target and was not clean with his hands, dropped marks and handballs several times. Can't fault his endeavour though and at least he runs 20m then kicks it 50.

Back to the hotel at midnight, up at balls o'clock to catch the first flight out. Hoarse, hung over and still bloody buzzing. Fantastic day.

6 hours ago, Deestroy All said:

" They had the bulk of the crowd which gave the umpires anunitotion."

anunitotion

anunitotion

anunitotion

An...un...it...otion?

4 hours ago, rjay said:

Goodwin again changed things up at half time and got the result.

His move of Tommy Mac into the ruck helped shift the midfield battle

Surely Goodwin now knows not to play McDonald forward.

Most of us here have known this for weeks, let's see if the coaches are learning.

4 hours ago, rjay said:

Goodwin again changed things up at half time and got the result.

His move of Tommy Mac into the ruck helped shift the midfield battle back to us after we were annihilated in the first half.

We have a very proactive coach...not afraid to try something different.

We've got a good one in Goodwin.

Biggest winner on the day, besides maybe Watts. I gave us exactly no chance.

Like having a 23rd player.

23 minutes ago, Clint Bizkit said:

Surely Goodwin now knows not to play McDonald forward.

Most of us here have known this for weeks, let's see if the coaches are learning.

Seriously? Goodwin, McCarthy, Rawlings and co., with years and years of full time footy at the highest level can't see what random fans on a footy forum can? Getting into Dunning-Kruger territory.