SYNDROME # 47 AND HOW TO DEAL WITH IT

[MadAsHell 4,089]

Two words;

DARCY CAMERON

[Chelly 754]

 

Surely we can't get a Cedric, can we?

Why not? They named today's feature race at Moonee Valley after him. 

[Whispering_Jack 28,097]

Chris25 posted his latest phantom draft shortly after the article in the opening post was put up. At present, you can see the effect there of academy bids up to the end of the second round - 2016 Young Talent Time. He will probably load more shortly but based on his PD, I can't see #47 coming in earlier than around Picks 48 - 50.

[DeeSpencer 23,569]

 

Surely we can't get a Cedric, can we?

Cyril and Neville are 2 of the best Indigenous players in the comp. No reason why Cedric couldn't join that pair.

[old55 21,777]

 

As all Demonlanders would be aware by now, my judgement (let's not count Lucas Cook) is impeccable, dare I say second to none, when it comes to the draft.

Quinton Narkle, son of Phil and nephew of Pharc is the player I like. Get on board.

 

Prefer Pharc but I heard he's moved to Colombia.

[picket fence 15,698]

I can just see the headlines and Dees news gushing 

" We are ecstactic with player .............. We had him going early second round, what a bonus we are surprised and pleased with player X" and at pick 47 what a bonus for MFC!

 

Edited October 23, 2016 by picket fence

[ManDee 7,093]

 

As all Demonlanders would be aware by now, my judgement (let's not count Lucas Cook) is impeccable, dare I say second to none, when it comes to the draft.

Quinton Narkle, son of Phil and nephew of Pharc is the player I like. Get on board.

 

RTG, you deserved more with this gem. Phil was good but who could forget the hours of pleasure watching Pharc. 

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,534]

 

Is this the guy?

The answer to everything is 47

Had a look at this.  If he thinks 47 is the answer to everything, I don't think he understood all the questions.

[Bendigo Demon 115]

I'm sure Pharc Narkle spent quite a bit of his career playing for the Demons.

[Demanding Success 298]

 

Chris25 posted his latest phantom draft shortly after the article in the opening post was put up. At present, you can see the effect there of academy bids up to the end of the second round - 2016 Young Talent Time. He will probably load more shortly but based on his PD, I can't see #47 coming in earlier than around Picks 48 - 50.

I just had a look at the GWS list and how many picks they have which have a points value. They currently have 7 list spots available and 11picks which have a points value. All of them before our pick 69 and 6 of them between our first 2 picks. I think there are about 5 academy kids that they will want (I could be wrong on this) but it's what I heard. They could all go on the 1st 30 odd. Plus if they pick McGrath at 2. They may even go into points deficit for next year depending on bidding.  Under the rules they can only use the first 7 picks for points anyway. Our picks will move up. Especially pick 69. They also have 3 or 4 more kids for next year. They may chose not to match a bid on one of the academy kids this year, and still go into deficit.

[Big Kev 340]

 

I've therefore taken a phantom draft at random off the authoritative bigfooty website and listed picks 41 to 50:-

Chris 25

41 Dylan Clarke - 187cm, 85kg midfielder from Eastern Ranges

42 Jake Pitman - 177cm, 77kg midfielder from Norwood

43 Jake Waterman - 191cm, 82kg forward from Claremont (West Coast*)

44 Kym LeBois - 175cm, 66kg forward/midfielder from North Adelaide

45 Callum Brown - 177cm, 69kg midfielder from Eastern Ranges (Collingwood*)

46 Jack Maibaum - 193cm, 90kg defender from Eastern Ranges

47 Cedric Cox - 184cm, 70kg defender from North Ballarat Rebels

48 Jordan Gallucci - 183cm, 75kg midfielder from Eastern Ranges

49 Ryan Garthwaite - 192cm, 84kg defender from Murray Bushrangers (GWS**)

50 Willem Drew - 188cm, 78kg midfielder from North Ballarat Rebels

 

Looked very good in the U18s Grand Final.

[DeeSpencer 23,569]

10 hours ago, Demanding Success said:

I just had a look at the GWS list and how many picks they have which have a points value. They currently have 7 list spots available and 11picks which have a points value. All of them before our pick 69 and 6 of them between our first 2 picks. I think there are about 5 academy kids that they will want (I could be wrong on this) but it's what I heard. They could all go on the 1st 30 odd. Plus if they pick McGrath at 2. They may even go into points deficit for next year depending on bidding.  Under the rules they can only use the first 7 picks for points anyway. Our picks will move up. Especially pick 69. They also have 3 or 4 more kids for next year. They may chose not to match a bid on one of the academy kids this year, and still go into deficit.

I thought I heard something about them being able to use any of the picks they had from last year for points, but not allowed to use the ones they've got in this year unless they had list spaces. So they cleared more list spaces and can now use a lot if not all of their picks for points. 

They always use whatever rules available to them to the absolute max.

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,534]

8 hours ago, DeeSpencer said:

I thought I heard something about them being able to use any of the picks they had from last year for points, but not allowed to use the ones they've got in this year unless they had list spaces. So they cleared more list spaces and can now use a lot if not all of their picks for points. 

They always use whatever rules available to them to the absolute max.

Nothing wrong with that. I'd like to think we are doing the same.

[DeeSpencer 23,569]

49 minutes ago, La Dee-vina Comedia said:

Nothing wrong with that. I'd like to think we are doing the same.

I agree. 

But the AFL implement new rules to get them to stop stockpiling picks, then the AFL adds exemptions to those rules and GWS exploit the exemptions. Makes me wonder if the AFL are repeatedly stupid or if they set up new rules to restrict the other sides instead of GWS. 

Anyway, we've seen the effect of finally reigning in the Giants list spaces and salary cap. Hopefully the next step is the Academy and they can get back somewhere near level terms with the rest of the league.

[Deespicable 2,574]

I can only see three options for pick No.47 (which may end up being about pick 43) and given Tubby Taylor's recent track record I am sure he'll be on the money.

1) Tall forward/mobile ruck option - It wouldn't surprise me if we nabbed an out of contract player like Zac Clarke if available but he will more than likely be taken even later - possibly as a rookie. Alternatively we may go another project tall. Once again we may wait until the rookie list for this.

2) Pacey small forward/midfielder - with our defence now shored up (Hibberd, McKenna and Smith), this posy is now a priority. We will want to be picking up someone who can apply pressure to Jeffy, who is facing a huge year after a fairly average second year at the Dees. Given we picked up another slowish midfielder (Lewis), it will be a player with major pace - hence someone like Galluci if he slipped through. But most of the quick kids will be taken higher than expected because all clubs now realise that pace is critical to the current transition game.

3) Someone who sneaked through who Taylor rated highly - Unless there is a gun awaiting us in the above two categories us, then the most likely option is that we will go for someone who we think has been underrated by other clubs. What position that is, is pretty much irrelevant as apart from two above areas, we are now pretty much covered.