Darcy Parish

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

Not a big fan of what I see in his highlight reel.

I think he too small for the modern day midfielder.

He will get pushed off the ball too easily.

Same height and weight as scully who found it hard for the first 5 years to make his way through the middle.

We need 185cm 83+ kgs players.

Reminds me of no one in particular and looks too small and light! Just my opinion!

PASS!

Not a big fan of what I see in his highlight reel.

I think he too small for the modern day midfielder.

He will get pushed off the ball too easily.

Same height and weight as scully who found it hard for the first 5 years to make his way through the middle.

We need 185cm 83+ kgs players.

RORY SLOANE DRAFT STATS:

Date of birth: 17/3/90

Height: 182cm

Weight: 76kg

Club: Eastern Ranges

NAT FYFE DRAFT STATS:

Height: 186cm

Weight: 73kg

DOB: 18/09/91

Recruited from: Aquinas College/Claremont

DARCY PARISH DRAFT STATS:

Height: 181cm,

Weight: 73kg,

DOB: 25/07/1997

Recruited from: Geelong Falcons

SKINNY? SMALL? PLEASE. WE WANT FOOTBALLERS, HE IS ONE. DON'T JUDGE HIM BY WHAT HE LOOKS LIKE.

Edited October 28, 2015 by The Song Formerly Known As

[rpfc 28,383]

He is obviously a talent but if we don't think he can build that frame, then we can't pick him.

One thing going for him is footy players are going to be required with this new rotations cap of 90 will make it easier for footy players to beat athletes as mids will stay on the ground in forward roles for a rest.

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

Like his attack on the ball. Seems like a bit of a live wire - kind of makes things happen.

And I like the fact that he's a country boy. Son of a shearer - they're tough blokes.

The club will put meat on that frame.

[The Stigga 1,094]

[PartyTimeJohnny 537]

This photo reminds me of a young Ernie Sigley

[Brayshaw Self 847]

He doesn't have a slight frame at all. He will grow to a good size

[leucopogon 1,519]

He reminds me of one of the original oompa loompa's (see new avatar)

[stevethemanjordan 6,952]

He is obviously a talent but if we don't think he can build that frame, then we can't pick him.

One thing going for him is footy players are going to be required with this new rotations cap of 90 will make it easier for footy players to beat athletes as mids will stay on the ground in forward roles for a rest.

He'll build a frame as long as he has the desire to work as hard as he can, (which from what I've read, is one of his strengths).

He looks 'athletic' rather than skin and bone. The frame is there.

Obviously the most crucial element in this hypothetical is how we'd develop him, what position we'd play him early in his career and what role he'd be given early days.

As far as his attributes go, I think he'd compliment our midfield rotation nicely.

I look at what Collingwood have done with Steele Sidebotttom, Freo with Stephen Hill, Hawthorn with Bradley etc. From the day they were drafted they were developed and nurtured appropriately and obviously those individuals benefitted from having strong lists but I think Melbourne supporters are still scarred and scared about what happened with players like Toumpas, Gysberts, Morton etc etc.

I'll back our current coaching group to pick up whoever and give them the best preparation and chance to succeed at AFL level.

Our list depth/quality and coaching group now should alleviate these worries that supporters have when it comes to drafting players like Parish.

Whoever it is at 3 and 7, I'm confident they'll be staple best 22 players in a few years at the very least.

Edited October 28, 2015 by stevethemanjordan

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

Just not feeling it with him.. He's no Brayshaw- THAT was a highlights package!

Liking the look of Hibbert, has a bit of Bontempelli about him (in the physical sense, and that kick )

Kind of hoping we "reach" with 3 for the best available KPF and use 7 on the best available talent left over, but happy to just have faith with the recruitment team.

[rjay 24,917]

Just not feeling it with him.. He's no Brayshaw- THAT was a highlights package!

Liking the look of Hibbert, has a bit of Bontempelli about him (in the physical sense, and that kick )

Kind of hoping we "reach" with 3 for the best available KPF and use 7 on the best available talent left over, but happy to just have faith with the recruitment team.

You don't reach with early picks. The FD know who they want with this pick and if it was going to be a reach they wouldn't have bothered trading up...

[P-man 13,366]

Just not feeling it with him.. He's no Brayshaw- THAT was a highlights package!

I doubt anything will top that highlights package.

To be honest, Parish looks extremely vanilla to me. He's clearly rated highly by those in the know for a reason, but his highlights don't scream top 3 pick.

[old55 23,546]

As as been said by others - making judgement on highlights reel is not sound. And that video in particular has so little game action in it, it's ridiculous to draw any conclusions.

[P-man 13,366]

As as been said by others - making judgement on highlights reel is not sound. And that video in particular has so little game action in it, it's ridiculous to draw any conclusions.

If that's directed towards me, you are misinterpreting. I'm not ruling anyone in or out based on a highlights package. If those who have watched him extensively deem him worthy of pick 3, so be it. I'm merely saying that on initial appearances, I wasn't overly excited.

[Mach5 4,767]

I doubt anything will top that highlights package.

To be honest, Parish looks extremely vanilla to me. He's clearly rated highly by those in the know for a reason, but his highlights don't scream top 3 pick.

I'm not sure if you remember, but Brayshaw's "highlights" package was lacklustre leading up to the draft, and the impressive vision was saved for the MFC-generated post-draft package.

Edited October 29, 2015 by Mach5

[Moonshadow 17,676]

From little things, big things grow

(apologies Paul Kelly)

[Tough Kent 2,137]

He actually reminds me of Scotty West, both in appearance and in his ability to win the footy, break away from a pack and then make a good decision. In the little I've seen he is quicker and a more penetrating kick than Scotty. If he turns into 1/4 of the player Westy was we'll be very happy.

[TeamPlayedFine39 8,503]

I'm not sure if you remember, but Brayshaw's "highlights" package was lacklustre leading up to the draft, and the impressive vision was saved for the MFC-generated post-draft package.

Very true.

They released a lacklustre highlights reel for Brayshaw which had people on DL very nervous about his kicking. Week of the draft, they released the 'real thing' and DL rejoiced.

Highlight packages are a bit of fun, but you can't take too much away from them.

[TeamPlayedFine39 8,503]

FWIW...

Head says Parish

Heart says Curnow

Both have been known to be spectacularly wrong in the past.

[Swampfox 190]

I am really stumped as to who i prefer now that we have pick 3

Weitering is the standout and its likely he wont fall to 3 but its who i would select if he does

Just hope we get it right

Pick 7 will be far less scrutinized by the Media but i would really love to get Francis, Curnow etc here

[nutbean 8,838]

Just not feeling it with him.. He's no Brayshaw- THAT was a highlights package!

Couldn't disagree more - thought Brayshaws highlight package was ok ... nothing more.

It says nothing about Brayshaw and said everything about the highlight package.

I mentioned it elsewhere but there was two Petracca packages and one made his footskills ordinary at best - the other made his footskills look sublime.

The reliance on any of these packages is sheer folly.

[nutbean 8,838]

I'm not sure if you remember, but Brayshaw's "highlights" package was lacklustre leading up to the draft, and the impressive vision was saved for the MFC-generated post-draft package.

yes, yes and yes

[Devil is in the Detail 883]

Wasn't it said before that Goodwin has been at a few of Parish's games even talking to him during the game breaks. If true, pretty obvious who pick 3 will be.

[Ted Lasso 19,507]

He's the best player that's going to be there at pick 3, i'd say he's a lock

pick 7 is much less so

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

Couldn't disagree more - thought Brayshaws highlight package was ok ... nothing more.

It says nothing about Brayshaw and said everything about the highlight package.

I mentioned it elsewhere but there was two Petracca packages and one made his footskills ordinary at best - the other made his footskills look sublime.

The reliance on any of these packages is sheer folly.

I liked all the Brayshaw highlight packages actually, I could see the footballer in him. And I know how highlights work, they are all most of us have to go by, seeing as we aren't professional talent scouts.

[Bang Bang Bang 5,825]

There were two highlight videos released of Brayshaw last year. The first one was collated from the Championships and was fairly uninspiring. But the second one was collated from the TAC Cup and he was deadset crushing blokes in tackles and hitting forwards lace out in every clip.