Don't even need to read any of the posts.

The answer should be no.

Okay.

Bad idea.

It's a moot point anyway. If he plays anywhere next year it will be for a side that's in with a shot at a flag. That won't be us in 2016.

My tip is Norf if he plays on.

Okay.

Bad idea.

I still think, in theory, that we shouldn't overlook the opportunity to add some further experience to our side. We still have some kids who will need time and getting a 'rental', like Daniel Cross, for a few years isn't necessarily a bad idea. It just has to be the right player.

Steve Johnson isn't it. We need guys who will come in, provide good leadership skills and be an excellent role model for the kids. Johnson can get away with slotting in to a Top 8 side without much trouble, but he wouldn't be good for us.

Someone like Jed Adcock has the potential to provide what Cross did for us, and is an example of the type of experience we should be looking at getting.

Does "good footy brain" mean his head is full of air?

A big no from me. We are nowhere near enough to a premiership to need to invest in a player of his ilk.

He is declining fast. We need to find players on the incline, not decline.

His flogness outweighs his scoring prowess and he'd be a dick to be around. That's a no

Has lost his pace and is starting to succumb to injury.

But most of all, absolute culture killer. Massive no from me.

Yes why would we want an extroverted winner in amongst our introverted losers, would definitely kill the culture. By the way Freo Fyffe has been reported 3 times this year better get rid of him

Yes why would we want an extroverted winner in amongst our introverted losers, would definitely kill the culture. By the way Freo Fyffe has been reported 3 times this year better get rid of him

Yeah why would we want someone who has been banned by his own club for his behaviour amongst our weak culture and kids hey?

And you're really comparing Fyfe to Stevie J, and Freo's culture to ours? Get out of the shallow end of the pool mate...

know for a fact that he isn't popular amongst playing group and never has been really. Prefers to hang out with older crew like Brownless etc. Players love him as a player, but as a person, he is a [censored] of the most supreme order.

Edited September 5, 201510 yr by The Song Formerly Known As

Yeah why would we want someone who has been banned by his own club for his behaviour amongst our weak culture and kids hey?

And you're really comparing Fyfe to Stevie J, and Freo's culture to ours? Get out of the shallow end of the pool mate...

10 years ago ffs. You're probably one of those who bangs on about MFC only having nice boys on the list. By the way if Hodge or Sewell became available better avoid them, too rough for our club. A team full of choir boys will get you no where. Get out of you own poll.

Declining fast ... does anyone actually watch the footy? Stevie J was one of Geelongs best and would be a perfect mentor to others. His bad boy days are so far in the past. Why are the cats dumping him? to allow salary cap room for Dangerfield & Svitt Selwood.

Stevie J would be better than most our stragglers. Perfect 3 year half forward goalkicker. We need mids but also need GOALKICKERS

10 years ago ffs. You're probably one of those who bangs on about MFC only having nice boys on the list. By the way if Hodge or Sewell became available better avoid them, too rough for our club. A team full of choir boys will get you no where. Get out of you own poll.

There's a big difference between being tough and being a d#*khead.

You should know...

Declining fast ... does anyone actually watch the footy?

Perfect 3 year half forward goalkicker.

You just proved that you don't actually watch the footy.

Terrific Footballer, but our resources could be more positively utilised

You just proved that you don't actually watch the footy.

Cut out the insults they,re all just opinions including yours

10 years ago ffs. You're probably one of those who bangs on about MFC only having nice boys on the list. By the way if Hodge or Sewell became available better avoid them, too rough for our club. A team full of choir boys will get you no where. Get out of you own poll.

Cut out the insults they,re all just opinions including yours

Classic Demonland stuff right there.

Yes stevie j replaces the 1 of 6 .

Would love him to shuffle over to the Bombers next year. They may have a dozen empty places to fill on their list in 2016.

After today I think we can be fairly selective about the 'experienced' players we get in (if any).

By which I mean NO...

After today I think we can be fairly selective about the 'experienced' players we get in (if any).

By which I mean NO...

Second that. Ditto Luke Hodge when the Hawks decide his indiscretions would be unpardonable were they to find out he voted Labour. In the end, we don't want thugs and snipers and selfish duckheads. Yes, I know there are there among you who want a team of Grinters . I'd prefer a team of Flowers, Schwarzes and Vineys. And Wights and Styne's and Alves and Wells and Lovetts.

Thank you very much.

.

He will be at the Tigers next year !

Hey, we can have Harley Bennell & Stevie J. Anymore idiots out there?

Honestly, would you rather play Stevie J than give experience to someone like Harmes?

He will be at the Tigers next year !

I think he's a perfect fit for them.