Your votes please.

6: Tom McDonald

5: Angus brayshaw

4: Daniel cross

3: jeff Garlett

2: Aaron vandenberg

1: Lynden Dunn

6: McDonald
5: Brayshaw
4: Garlett
3: Dunn
2: Cross
1: Pedersen

6 - McDonald

5 - Garlett

4 - Garland

3 - Cross

2 - Pedersen

1 - Hogan

6. McDonald

5. Garlett

4. Garland

3. Cross

2. Brayshaw

1. Pedersen

6. McDonald

5. Garlett

4. Dunn

3. Brayshaw

2. Hogan

1. Cross

Edited May 3, 201510 yr by Clint Bizkit

6 - T McDonald

5 - L Dunn

4 - A Brayshaw

3 - M Jamar

2 - C Salem

1 - C Garland

We got smashed in the midfield so it's hard to justify giving any of them votes. Garlett could be unlucky not get votes but I not sure his defensive pressure warrants it (and if your a forward not providing defensive pressure then you had better be applying a LOT of scoring pressure) - we also got smashed with the ball coming out of defence.

6 - McDonald

5 - Garlett

4 - Garland

3 - Cross

2 - Pedersen

1 - Hogan

no brayshaw?

WTF

6. McDonald - Our only defender

5. Garlett - Our only forward

4. Brayshaw - Absolute gun. Continues to impress in all aspects of the game.

3. Cross - Solid game all round.

2. Grimes - Played well on Ballentyne (I think) who had no influence.

1. Pederson - Had a real crack. Took 8 marks and contested pretty well.

Edited May 3, 201510 yr by Demon Jack

Tmac

Brayshaw

Garlett

The midfield who all had a crack

Umpire 28

6: McDonald
5: Brayshaw
4: Garlett
3: Pedersen
2: Cross
1: Hogan

6- McDonald

5- brayshaw

4- garlett

3- garland

2- jamar

1- cross

The midfield who all had a crack

They were truly monstered.

6. McDonald

5. Brayshaw

4. Garlett

3. vandenBerg

2. Cross

1. Hogan

Salem until injured - honourable mention

[Zero votes to the "Melbourne fan" behind me who lambasted McDonald as a total dud / spud whenever he had the ball.]

6 - McDonald

5 - Brayshaw

4 - Garlett

3 - Cross

2 - Pedo

1 - Dunn

6.TMac

5.Garlett

4.Brayshaw

3.Dunn

2.Garland

1.Cross

6. T-Mac

5. Garlett

4. Garland

3. Brayshaw

2. Cross

1. Grimes

6 - McDonald

5 - Brayshaw

4 - Garlett

3 - Cross

2 - Garland

1 - Jamar (more for effort than anything else).

6: McDonald
5: Brayshaw
4: Garlett
3: Pedersen
2: Cross
1: Salem

6 T Mac

5 Brayshaw

4 Garlett

3 vandenBURG

2 Cross

1 Salem

6. T McDonald

5. A Brayshaw

4. D Cross

3. J Garlett

2. C Garland

1. C Salem

6. McDonald

5. Brayshaw

4. Garlet

3. vandenBerg

2. Garland

1. Cross

6 - T McDonald

5 - L Dunn

4 - A Brayshaw

3 - M Jamar

2 - C Salem

1 - C Garland

We got smashed in the midfield so it's hard to justify giving any of them votes. Garlett could be unlucky not get votes but I not sure his defensive pressure warrants it (and if your a forward not providing defensive pressure then you had better be applying a LOT of scoring pressure) - we also got smashed with the ball coming out of defence.

Garlett's defensive pressure has been good in our first four games. He has hassled and harassed his opponents.

6. McDonald

5. Brayshaw- This kid going to be something.

4. Vandenburg

3. Garlett

2. Cross

1. Dunn

6:Tmac - great effort as it has been all season high on confidence and backing himself, was our best in a defence under immense pressure. Hope Oscar is as good

5:Brayshaw - love this good a competitor and showing a lot of class, could be the smokey overall for the season in NAB RS

4:Garlett - good effort should have had 4 and was our most dangerous forward

3:Cross - honest as ever and very important in stemming the bleeding with Freo bursting out of the gates

2:Dunn - was good with the pressure applied to our defence throughout the game

1:Jamar - battled hard all day against possibly best current ruck tandem in the AFL