12 good reasons

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,783]

When I daydream I often wonder which would give me the greater enjoyment - thrashing Collingwood in a Grand Final like we did in 1955 or coming from behind to beat them like we did in 1964.

[nutbean 8,838]

In 1900 the population of Melbourne was 477 000 so I don't think 20 000 was a crap crowd.

The ground was probably full.

Based on today's population the comparative crowd would be186,000

[DeeVoted 583]

When I daydream I often wonder which would give me the greater enjoyment - thrashing Collingwood in a Grand Final like we did in 1955 or coming from behind to beat them like we did in 1964.

I would take a grand final win by any margin. And beating those scumbags by 1 point or 100 pts, doesnt matter to me.

[DeeVoted 583]

Based on today's population the comparative crowd would be186,000

Add to that stat. The price of a 7oz galss of beer back then was 8d. Almost 10c for a glass of COLD beer. Not in a plastic cup either.

[old dee 23,792]

Add to that stat. The price of a 7oz galss of beer back then was 8d. Almost 10c for a glass of COLD beer. Not in a plastic cup either.

That seems high for 1900 ?

[DeeVoted 583]

No 9 of 12:

Our 2nd 3peat. We are flying.

1957 Grand Final Results Saturday, 21st September , M.C.G

MELBOURNE 6.2 9.9 12.11 17.14 (116)

ESSENDON 2.3 4.4 7.8 7.13 (55)

Umpire: Nash

Attendance: 100,324

MELBOURNE

B: J. Beckwith (Capt.), P. Marquis, R.Fenton-Smith

HB: D. Williams, J.Lord , K. Carroll

C: B. Dixon, L. Mithen, I.McLean

HF: G.Tunbridge, R. (Tassie) Johnson, G.Case

F: R. Barassi, A. Webb, I. Ridley

R: R (Bob) Johnson, C.Wilson, F.Adams

RES: I.Thorogood, P.Brenchley

Goals: Barassi 5, Ridley 4, Webb 3, R.Johnson 2, Tunbridge 2, Case.

Best: Denis Cordner, Barassi, Melville, McLean, McMahen, Marquis

COACH - Norm Smith

ESSENDON

B: Suter, Knowles, Pascoe

HB: Shearman, Gamble, Towner

C: Burgess, Clarke, Sewell

HF: Hebbard, Fox, Booth

F: Leek, Gallagher, Birt

R: Gill, Mitchell, Hutchison (Capt.)

Res.: Moloney, Heenan

Goals: Gallagher 3, Birt, Gill, Hebbard, Clarke.

Best: Clarke, Shearman, Mitchell, Leek, Towner, Birt.

COACH - R. (dicky) Reynolds

Melbourne was not so dominant in the 1957 home and away season, being defeated five times and drawing another match. However, it was still good enough for the Demons to top the ladder, ahead of (in order) Essendon, Hawthorn (making the finals for the first time) and Carlton.

Melbourne, naturally, was the flag favorite, but all the other finalists had claims to the premiership. Melbourne's remarkable run of finals victories ended when Essendon defeated the Demons by 16 points.

It was suggested - and probably with good reason - that the Demons went into the match over-confident, paying a hefty penalty. If there was complacency in the Melbourne camp it certainly was not evident the following week when the Demons thrashed Hawthorn by 68 points to challenge Essendon for the flag.

If Melbourne had been cocky in the semi-final, it was super-determined in the grand final. In fact, Melbourne scored the opening goal - through Ron Barassi - in the opening seconds. It was a message to the Bombers that Melbourne meant business and would defend its premier status to the very last breath. Melbourne's frenzy continued throughout the first half and, with a 35-point break, the job had been done.

Melbourne coach Norm Smith had instructed his forwards to stay wide and to break up the game with short, sharp handball. The Demons followed their coach's instructions to the letter, even though restricted by injuries.

Melbourne had gone into the match with several injury problems and Keith Carroll (thigh) was replaced by Ian Thorogood in the second quarter. The Demons shrugged these problems aside to defeat Essendon by 61 points to land a third consecutive flag for the second time in the club's history.

Edit: Revised Melb Team

Edited February 20, 2015 by DeeVoted

[DeeVoted 583]

That seems high for 1900 ?

I checked that was the going rate listed in a paper. Probably high octane, avaition fuel lol

[old dee 23,792]

I checked that was the going rate listed in a paper. Probably high octane, avaition fuel lol

Beer has always been pricey then!

[DeeVoted 583]

If you want to buy the 1957 GF number plates, Bobby Mac has them for sale I believe. 20 bucks for the set, in good nick.

Problem is, they are sold with the car. the car is worth 30 grand.

[ManDee 7,153]

No 9 of 12:

ESSENDON

B: Suter, Knowles, Pascoe

HB: Shearman, Gamble, Towner

C: Burgess, Clarke, Sewell

HF: Hebbard, Fox, Booth

F: Leek, Gallagher, Birt

R: Gill, Mitchell, Hutchison (Capt.)

Res.: Moloney, Heenan

Goals: Gallagher 3, Birt, Gill, Hebbard, Clarke.

Best: Clarke, Lucas, Mann, R. Rose, Sharp, Tuck

COACH - [censored] Reynolds

Even the auto censor didn't like Essendons coach

[old dee 23,792]

If you want to buy the 1957 GF number plates, Bobby Mac has them for sale I believe. 20 bucks for the set, in good nick.

Problem is, they are sold with the car. the car is worth 30 grand.

Seems like a cheap price for a working FE Holden

[daisycutter 29,616]

No 9 of 12:

Our 2nd 3peat. We are flying.

1957 Grand Final Results Saturday, 21st September , M.C.G

MELBOURNE 6.2 9.9 12.11 17.14 (116)

ESSENDON 2.3 4.4 7.8 7.13 (55)

Umpire: Nash

Attendance: 100,324

MELBOURNE

B: J. Beckwith, P. Marquis, Trevor Johnson

HB: D. Williams, N. McMahen (Capt.), K. Carroll

C: F. Adams, K. Melville, B. Dixon

HF: J. Sandral, C. Laidlaw, L. Mithen

F: R. Johnson, A. Webb, I. Ridley

R: Denis Cordner, R.D. Barassi, S.Spencer

RES: T. Gleeson, R. Lane

Goals: Barassi 5, Ridley 4, Webb 3, R.Johnson 2, Tunbridge 2, Case.

Best: Denis Cordner, Barassi, Melville, McLean, McMahen, Marquis

COACH - Norm Smith

ESSENDON

B: Suter, Knowles, Pascoe

HB: Shearman, Gamble, Towner

C: Burgess, Clarke, Sewell

HF: Hebbard, Fox, Booth

F: Leek, Gallagher, Birt

R: Gill, Mitchell, Hutchison (Capt.)

Res.: Moloney, Heenan

Goals: Gallagher 3, Birt, Gill, Hebbard, Clarke.

Best: Clarke, Lucas, Mann, R. Rose, Sharp, Tuck

COACH - [censored] Reynolds

Melbourne was not so dominant in the 1957 home and away season, being defeated five times and drawing another match. However, it was still good enough for the Demons to top the ladder, ahead of (in order) Essendon, Hawthorn (making the finals for the first time) and Carlton.

Melbourne, naturally, was the flag favorite, but all the other finalists had claims to the premiership. Melbourne's remarkable run of finals victories ended when Essendon defeated the Demons by 16 points.

It was suggested - and probably with good reason - that the Demons went into the match over-confident, paying a hefty penalty. If there was complacency in the Melbourne camp it certainly was not evident the following week when the Demons thrashed Hawthorn by 68 points to challenge Essendon for the flag.

If Melbourne had been cocky in the semi-final, it was super-determined in the grand final. In fact, Melbourne scored the opening goal - through Ron Barassi - in the opening seconds. It was a message to the Bombers that Melbourne meant business and would defend its premier status to the very last breath. Melbourne's frenzy continued throughout the first half and, with a 35-point break, the job had been done.

Melbourne coach Norm Smith had instructed his forwards to stay wide and to break up the game with short, sharp handball. The Demons followed their coach's instructions to the letter, even though restricted by injuries.

Melbourne had gone into the match with several injury problems and Keith Carroll (thigh) was replaced by Ian Thorogood in the second quarter. The Demons shrugged these problems aside to defeat Essendon by 61 points to land a third consecutive flag for the second time in the club's history.

some funny best players for the scum there dv

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,783]

Even the auto censor didn't like Essendons coach

I know it's the software and not the Demonland administrator's fault, but auto-censoring the diminutive of Richard is patently ridiculous.

[hardtack 10,537]

I know it's the software and not the Demonland administrator's fault, but auto-censoring the diminutive of Richard is patently ridiculous.

Actually, I would have thought that what is acceptable and what is not could be controlled by the user/administrator... that is, there would be an editable file containing words and "D ick" would be in there by default.

Edited February 19, 2015 by hardtack

[daisycutter 29,616]

I know it's the software and not the Demonland administrator's fault, but auto-censoring the diminutive of Richard is patently ridiculous.

bit freudian, ldv - ri[censored]ulous

[ManDee 7,153]

bit freudian, ldv - ri[censored]ulous

Its a bit [censored]tatorial really, like Stalin or Hitler. Not sure on the spelling had to look it up in a [censored]tionary.

[daisycutter 29,616]

Its a bit [censored]tatorial really, like Stalin or Hitler. Not sure on the spelling had to look it up in a [censored]tionary.

yeah, bit like living in [censored]amstown. guess that's why they are called wanchors

[Vagg 2,439]

Just noticed in the 1939, 1940 & 1941 teams a guy in the back pocket named Emselle. Does anyone happen to know if he was related to Ken Emselle, who played with us in the 60s? Not a very common surname.

[DeeVoted 583]

Just noticed in the 1939, 1940 & 1941 teams a guy in the back pocket named Emselle. Does anyone happen to know if he was related to Ken Emselle, who played with us in the 60s? Not a very common surname.

Yep That is Ken Emselle's father.

[DeeVoted 583]

some funny best players for the scum there dv

Not much has changed from then to now. They slipped in some 'filth' players to beat us.

Good 'ol cut and paste has got me again. Good pickup daisy, I'll have to see what happened there.

[ManDee 7,153]

yeah, bit like living in [censored]amstown. guess that's why they are called wanchors

Wanchors, is that a navy term for weigh anchor? Any way its about 5 kilos.

[DeeVoted 583]

Seems like a cheap price for a working FE Holden

Might not to working by the time it made the trip from Perth to Melb.

[Red and Bluebeard 2,084]

yeah, bit like living in [censored]amstown. guess that's why they are called wanchors

Must be an e[censored]t from the AFL about this somewhere ... or maybe the presumably American software is ad[censored]ted to censoring ... Perhaps we should just roll the [censored]e ...

[Vagg 2,439]

Yep That is Ken Emselle's father.

Is that right? How about that! I never knew Ken's Dad played for us! Thanks, DeeVoted. That's nice to know.

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,783]

bit freudian, ldv - ri[censored]ulous

After the post went live I notice that. So I can't claim it was deliberate...which suggests the possibility of a Freudian slip.