Just read that tasman guy who does the big training reports on bigfooty mentioned that apparently we could be seriously looking at Brock McLean as a possible rookie selection.

Just read that tasman guy who does the big training reports on bigfooty mentioned that apparently we could be seriously looking at Brock McLean as a possible rookie selection.

Why would he want to join a club that tanked?

There are some things in life that I can believe.

This is not one of them.

You've got to be joking.

Persona non grata in my eyes.

Don't need him. Don't want him.

Take him. Proven midfielder, gives his all and at worst would be a depth player for 2 years. Like it or not he would be in our best 22

Its Dec 1 not April 1

I see this as a direct replacement for Trengove who will head straight to the long term injury list.

Im definitely not against the idea of him back at the club. We still need another mature head to help ease and guide these young kids who have just come in.

Recruiting Brock - our premiership window must be open.

What was his form like in 2014?

Saw very few Carlscum games. I have better things to do

Why would he want to join a club that tanked?

He joined Calrton, didn't he?

He joined Calrton, didn't he?

Think that was the point of the post

I'd take him. Useful midfield depth when we've got injuries or need to give the kids a rest.

Used to be my favourite player.

Tanking aside I reckon he loves the club. Wasn't he the only player to donate to the club from his own pocket.

I'd take him. Useful midfield depth when we've got injuries or need to give the kids a rest.

Used to be my favourite player.

Tanking aside I reckon he loves the club. Wasn't he the only player to donate to the club from his own pocket.

If he was in the side, he would be taking the place of others I would prefer to be playing. We drafted Cross and Vince to help out Jones as the seniors in the midfield - I don't think we need another.

past history aside, i can't see any point in it

and anyway didn't he just hate the trip to casey fields

I'd take him. Useful midfield depth when we've got injuries or need to give the kids a rest.

Used to be my favourite player.

Tanking aside I reckon he loves the club. Wasn't he the only player to donate to the club from his own pocket.

Except that the "Donation" was actually a penalty for doing burnouts after training in the car park.

I used to love Brock when he played for us......I think he has slowed down a lot (not that he was ever fast)....I think others have past him by and I think this would be a backward step.........I think the same for Sylvia as well.....

He couldn't hack the drive to Casey five years ago - the trip won't be any easier next year.

its a nice romantic thought but then you remember the On The Ouch interview and the [censored] he dropped us in

But maybe we should be thanking him because without that interview we may have never got rid of Schwab and co..

I can't believe we would be going down this track. Ugh!

I'd be furious, for non-football reasons.

I don't think he'd be able to get a game ahead of our kids, really [censored] him

i miss the smell of his burnouts out of the carpark after training.

its a nice romantic thought but then you remember the On The Ouch interview and the [censored] he dropped us in

But maybe we should be thanking him because without that interview we may have never got rid of Schwab and co..

It would have been much more difficult.

What Brock said on the couch was correct.

Whether he should have said it is another issue.

But it was a "No pain No gain" scenario

Somebody had to talk....

As long as he brought 500K along with him

He couldn't hack the drive to Casey five years ago - the trip won't be any easier next year.

Maybe he's moved into the area.

If Brock were to come back to the club it would be more about getting experience at Casey which is badly needed. I couldn't really see him pushing for senior selection now.