Boomer

[beelzebub 22,813]

but he didn't hit above the shoulder

it was the accidental following head clash after the bump that caused a glancing blow which didn't even faze selwood

minor clash, deserved a free kick, that's all

harvey may be a plick but doesn't deserve to be reported/convicted for that or we'll end up with players missing games every week for trivialities

Must admit watching it it didnt look like much...just a bump

[iv'a worn smith 1,979]

Looking at the vision again, to me Harvey hit Selwood, some distance from the ball, lined him up in a clumsily disguised effort to 'shepherd' and jumped at the point of impact. Can only point to one thing ...... guilty. As has already been made patently clear, unlike the old tribunal days, you can't use precedent as a defence. Harvey was dill for doing what he did and will get his just desserts. Mind you, the "finals discretionary power" may come in and save him. By the way, how's your nose Pedo?

Edited September 16, 2014 by iv'a worn smith

[iv'a worn smith 1,979]

Must admit watching it it didnt look like much...just a bump

He lined him up some distance from the ball!!!!

[Sir Why You Little 35,409]

It was an off the ball incident Harvey also was in the air when contact was made. He lined him up. Yes it wasn't huge contact, but Selwood was jogging off the play.

He has to go

[daisycutter 28,730]

It was an off the ball incident Harvey also was in the air when contact was made. He lined him up. Yes it wasn't huge contact, but Selwood was jogging off the play.

He has to go

so what.....a free kick

contact off the ball happens all lot through a game. it wasn't forceful enough to warrant a report/conviction

[Sir Why You Little 35,409]

so what.....a free kick

contact off the ball happens all lot through a game. it wasn't forceful enough to warrant a report/conviction

No. Harvey lined him up. Left the ground and half got him. He was aiming for more.

GAWN

[iv'a worn smith 1,979]

so what.....a free kick

contact off the ball happens all lot through a game. it wasn't forceful enough to warrant a report/conviction

Under the current MRP rules it does. The incident, together with his carry over points more than suggest he's stuffed. You might not like the rules which govern the current judicial framework, but right now, that's what we have and we are stuck with them.

[daisycutter 28,730]

well my money says he gets off tonight

and that will be the right decision

[sue 8,683]

well my money says he gets off tonight

and that will be the right decision

My money says he will get off, but it won't be the right decision.

[Sir Why You Little 35,409]

If Harvey gets off tonight then it makes the head a fair target this weekend and next.

[daisycutter 28,730]

If Harvey gets off tonight then it makes the head a fair target this weekend and next.

rubbish. selwood's head wasn't targetted

[Uncle Fester 2,843]

Nothing in it, but I hope he gets two weeks.

Can't stand the little snot

[nutbean 8,837]

If Harvey gets off tonight then it makes the head a fair target this weekend and next.

why ?

The only consistent thing with the MRP is their inconsistency.

[iv'a worn smith 1,979]

rubbish. selwood's head wasn't targetted

Maybe, maybe not, but Selwood was targeted without a doubt, hence Harvey has to take the consequences, whether the ensuing contact to the head was accidental or not. The charge on Selwood was clearly premeditated.

[Moneider96 1,045]

Maybe, maybe not, but Selwood was targeted without a doubt, hence Harvey has to take the consequences, whether the ensuing contact to the head was accidental or not. The charge on Selwood was clearly premeditated.

premeditated or instinctive? that's a question for the jury

[Bitter but optimistic 21,627]

Hate his guts, and hate North and their insufferable whinging coach.

Hope they get smashed.

Love your work Jaded.

[daisycutter 28,730]

Maybe, maybe not, but Selwood was targeted without a doubt, hence Harvey has to take the consequences, whether the ensuing contact to the head was accidental or not. The charge on Selwood was clearly premeditated.

the accidental contact to the head was not forceful

watch the replay, selwood gave no indication of being hit in the head nor did harvey

it was only a little later when he felt a trickle of blood he raised his hand to see what it was

it was also the side of his eyebrow away from harvey

it doesn't take much contact to make an eyebrow bleed

selwood has come out himself and said there was nothing much in it

harvey was a dill and did the wrong think, but it only warranted a free kick

[bluey 932]

Festival Hall clearly bashed a fellow off the ball a few years back in a Prelim. the AFL stepped in so they could manufacture a Sydney Premiership, let me say the games corrupt.....

[sue 8,683]

premeditated or instinctive? that's a question for the jury

Some players premeditate so often that it becomes instinctive.

[gsmith12 491]

Don't like Boomer at all but I reckon he was a tad stiff and with Selwood's help could well got off this evening.

[iv'a worn smith 1,979]

the accidental contact to the head was not forceful

watch the replay, selwood gave no indication of being hit in the head nor did harvey

it was only a little later when he felt a trickle of blood he raised his hand to see what it was

it was also the side of his eyebrow away from harvey

it doesn't take much contact to make an eyebrow bleed

selwood has come out himself and said there was nothing much in it

harvey was a dill and did the wrong think, but it only warranted a free kick

Unfortunately for him the system; the very system which provides the sanctioning power to the MRP do not agree, whether we like it or not. I'm afraid its a touch of the caveat emptor here.

Edited September 16, 2014 by iv'a worn smith

[iv'a worn smith 1,979]

Festival Hall clearly bashed a fellow off the ball a few years back in a Prelim. the AFL stepped in so they could manufacture a Sydney Premiership, let me say the games corrupt.....

Different system back then.

[daisycutter 28,730]

the mrp's inability to apply common sense, as against rigidly sticking to some formulaic process is legendary

[iv'a worn smith 1,979]

the mrp's inability to apply common sense, as against rigidly sticking to some formulaic process is legendary

Cue Adrian Anderson.

[beelzebub 22,813]

Boomer cleared.

some sense shown