Hate to say it but Pies have killed it again.

Aish at 6 and Scharenberg at 10 would have been killing it.

What they got was no more impressive than what St Kilda did.

Time will tell Jumbo

People forget that in past 2 years Pies have lost Dawes, Wellingham, Thomas, Shaw and a bunch of others to get the picks used on the kids. Of they mess up development they are in big trouble. Also they have thrown away any 2014 premiership aspirations with the youth policy.

Anyone else notice Aish has put on some serious size in the last 2-3 months!

Happy with this, no risk, going to be very very good

People forget that in past 2 years Pies have lost Dawes, Wellingham, Thomas, Shaw and a bunch of others to get the picks used on the kids. Of they mess up development they are in big trouble. Also they have thrown away any 2014 premiership aspirations with the youth policy.

With all due respect, I'd take their last two years over ours.....

They're too well run and have too much coin to be in big trouble.

Aish at 6 and Scharenberg at 10 would have been killing it.

What they got was no more impressive than what St Kilda did.

Scharenberg and Grundy the last 2 drafts are absolute gifts. The Dogs and Saints are mad to pass on Scharenberg.

I was up on the Gold Coast for work the last couple of days and bumped into Kevin Sheahan at the airport. I asked him who he would take at 9 between Salem and Freeman and he stated Salem without a seconds thought. Whilst mentioning he thought either would be good he stated beautiful kick, hard at it and more positional flexibility than Freeman. I then boarded the same flight that Salem was on and that was enough of an omen for me.

Welcome to the Dees Christian.

Looks very slight and a couple of years off at least

Welcome Witchy.

It'll catch on.

So... Whats happened to the like button?

Scharenberg and Grundy the last 2 drafts are absolute gifts. The Dogs and Saints are mad to pass on Scharenberg.

Grundy at 18 was an anomaly. Big ups to Collingwood for pulling it off but also big question marks as to why and how it happened.

Scharenberg not so much, both feet considerably busted up is a big deal-breaker. It was enough to put the first 5 selections off him, what's to say he wouldn't have lasted to 10? If they took the punt of that happening and got Aish at 6, then yes I'd say they killed the draft. But they pulled the trigger early and got Freeman instead, not killing it for mine.

Plays like Chris Yarren I think.

So... Whats happened to the like button?

I can't even like your post, to show my agreement!

Wtf?

Grundy at 18 was an anomaly. Big ups to Collingwood for pulling it off but also big question marks as to why and how it happened.

Scharenberg not so much, both feet considerably busted up is a big deal-breaker. It was enough to put the first 5 selections off him, what's to say he wouldn't have lasted to 10? If they took the punt of that happening and got Aish at 6, then yes I'd say they killed the draft. But they pulled the trigger early and got Freeman instead, not killing it for mine.

Sharenberg wouldn't have got past us. Credit where it's due, the trade with WC to get pick 6 was a killer deal and in the end both clubs got what they wanted. As for the feet, well lets see in a couple of years. I think the Saints and Dogs made a big mistake…I actually think GWS did too, not their first one.

edit: Grundy wasn't an anomaly, just conventional wisdom about rucks that is a load of BS.

Edited November 21, 201311 yr by rjay

People forget that in past 2 years Pies have lost Dawes, Wellingham, Thomas, Shaw and a bunch of others to get the picks used on the kids. Of they mess up development they are in big trouble. Also they have thrown away any 2014 premiership aspirations with the youth policy.

Yet have cleaned up with Grundy, Kennedy, Adams, Sharenberg and Freeman.

They will still play deep in the finals next year and win another flag in 2 or 3 years im afraid..

Salem is very classy ... but set more for round 1, 2015

I think Jesse Hogan sums it up well hahaha

When Salems name was read out i was so upset, but i have calmed down now, and after watching his highlight reel i think he will go good for us (alot like Yze) but still would have rathered Freeman any day of the week.

Key criteria seemed to be skilful kicks, line breaking and speed.

Salam's left boot is a weapon (better than Freeman).

Kind of looks like a darker skinned Scully?!

What is his ethnicity? Greek?

What is his ethnicity? Greek?

Yeah, close enough. Lebanese.

Kind of looks like a darker skinned Scully?!

I actually think he looks a little like Rhyce Shaw, another Roos Sydney connection......jokes