Changes v GWS

[DeeSpencer 23,686]

FB: Dunn Frawley Garland

HB: Strauss McDonald Terlich

C: Toumpas Jones M. Jones
HF: Tynan Dawes Tapscott
FF: Howe Fitzy Byrnes
Foll: Gawn Viney Sylvia
Int: Trengove, Grimes Watts Clisby

OUT: Blease, Davey, Pedersen, Kent

IN:Tynan, Strauss, Garland, Terlich

I'm that sick of Blease, Davey and Kent. They don't tackle, they don't chase and they don't find the footy. They are complete passengers. Kent's spent a lot of time as sub and he's young so he needs a rest back in the VFL but there is no excuse for the other 2. It's time to give Josh Tynan a go as a guy who is a natural defender and maybe limited as a footballer but he leads Casey in tackles most week and will have a crack. He can also find the footy which is more that can be said for Blease.

I'm hoping Frawley is ok and Garland and Terlich can come back in. We missed their ability to actually back themselves and rebound the ball today. Pedersen is complete garbage and Clisby needs a freshen up which I'd give him through the sub vest. I see no reason he can't come on and play half back or wing and give us something. Strauss has more than earnt his spot compared to half the guys who get gifted games each week.

Craig made the right call to keep the side settled whilst we had some improved performances but todays effort was abysmal and we have to make some changes. I think 4 and not including Magner is conservative.

[Jaded No More 60,129]

Not that I really give a sh!t about this season anymore, but if I see Dunn and Pedersen in the team next week, I will officially go off the rails and lose it.

Two of the most pathetic, extrodinary poor footballers going around. Dunn has been screwing us for years, and Pedersen is just an enormous facepalm moment from our dearly departed Neeld. Horrendous.

Time to bring in those who have been serving time in the VFL and find out if they are worth retaining. If we don't do it now, we will never know.

Davis, Strauss, Jetta, just bring them in and let them play. They can't possibly do worse than lose by 120 points!

P.S.- NO GILLIES!

[titan_uranus 23,228]

I've been a big fan of Craig's decision to try to maintain stability as best he can since he started. Fitzpatrick is a perfect example of how that can work for you.

However, not rotating the players after the Darwin game sapped us probably hurt us today, and there are quite a few players who have been passengers the last month. Changes really need to be made.

Even if Garland's not ready, Pedersen goes. There aren't enough tall forwards at GWS to warrant having him anyway. Kent and Clisby maybe could use a spell at Casey to refresh, Toumpas possibly as well. Blease and Davey need to be dropped, Dunn possibly as well given his abysmal use of the ball.

As for who comes in, Strauss, Jetta, Tynan, Taggert all could be looked at to make the final call on them. It's all deckchair shuffling though, really.

[Demon Jack 6,436]

Magner in.

[Redleg 38,585]

Not that I really give a [censored] about this season anymore, but if I see Dunn and Pedersen in the team next week, I will officially go off the rails and lose it.

Two of the most pathetic, extrodinary poor footballers going around. Dunn has been screwing us for years, and Pedersen is just an enormous facepalm moment from our dearly departed Neeld. Horrendous.

Time to bring in those who have been serving time in the VFL and find out if they are worth retaining. If we don't do it now, we will never know.

Davis, Strauss, Jetta, just bring them in and let them play. They can't possibly do worse than lose by 120 points!

P.S.- NO GILLIES!

Did you actually watch the game today. I thought Dunn was about our best. He played on Thomas, who kicked 7 last week and was thrashed by Dunn today. Gee give him some credit for a good game.

You want to talk about gutless, hello Flash. If it was me he would have played his last game for us today.

[titan_uranus 23,228]

Did you actually watch the game today. I thought Dunn was about our best. He played on Thomas, who kicked 7 last week and was thrashed by Dunn today. Gee give him some credit for a good game.

It's harder to assess off the radio. Each time I heard his name it seemed to be associated with a turnover.

I guess if he's beating his man then that's a step up from the other 21 players.

[Mr Steve 3,820]

G W S is leading the Pies. maybe they will get their one win this week. Or win both and sink us even lower.

[Whispering_Jack 28,118]

Did you actually watch the game today. I thought Dunn was about our best. He played on Thomas, who kicked 7 last week and was thrashed by Dunn today. Gee give him some credit for a good game.

You want to talk about gutless, hello Flash. If it was me he would have played his last game for us today.

Sadly, I think you're right on the button about Aaron. His days are numbered.

[stuie 7,374]

Time to stop treading water and find out more about our list...

IN: Taggert, Tynan, Davis, Jetta, Spencer, Strauss

OUT: Who cares

Make or break for spots on our list.

[titan_uranus 23,228]

Time to stop treading water and find out more about our list...

IN: Taggert, Tynan, Davis, Jetta, Spencer, Strauss

OUT: Who cares

Make or break for spots on our list.

Fair sentiment, but Spencer in for whom? Gawn was one of our better players today. If we're going to make wholesale changes, we should at least start with the ones who gave us zilch.

[Mr Steve 3,820]

Redleg- The flash can not be part of our future so why are we playing him at all.

[stuie 7,374]

Fair sentiment, but Spencer in for whom? Gawn was one of our better players today. If we're going to make wholesale changes, we should at least start with the ones who gave us zilch.

For anyone, I don't really care. Give Gawn or Fitzy a rest if we have to. Time to find out if those time wasters are up for it or not. Sick of having guys on our list who have played close to 0 games, what a waste.

[Jaded No More 60,129]

Did you actually watch the game today. I thought Dunn was about our best. He played on Thomas, who kicked 7 last week and was thrashed by Dunn today. Gee give him some credit for a good game.

You want to talk about gutless, hello Flash. If it was me he would have played his last game for us today.

Oh I watched it.

Dunn couldn't hit a target, is a dumb footballer and gutless.

His turnovers cost us numerous goals, so the fact that his opponent didn't directly kick goals on him, undoes all the good work defensively.

And it goes without saying that Davey is done. But giving him the rest of the season to play before he retires, won't change anything.

It's rewarding people like Dunn with game after game while Davis has been serving a 4 year sentence in the VFL, that is mind boggling.

I know what I can get from Dunn, and I hate it.

Edited July 27, 2013 by Jaded

[titan_uranus 23,228]

For anyone, I don't really care. Give Gawn or Fitzy a rest if we have to. Time to find out if those time wasters are up for it or not. Sick of having guys on our list who have played close to 0 games, what a waste.

Again, I'm happy to look at these players with question marks, but given we have so many spuds playing right now, it shouldn't be at the expense of the ones actually giving a yelp.

[stuie 7,374]

Again, I'm happy to look at these players with question marks, but given we have so many spuds playing right now, it shouldn't be at the expense of the ones actually giving a yelp.

That's all fine for teams tracking for finals or in a reasonably healthy shape, but we are in desperate need of finding out about our players.

[Redleg 38,585]

Redleg- The flash can not be part of our future so why are we playing him at all.

I have no idea.

[Redleg 38,585]

Oh I watched it.

Dunn couldn't hit a target, is a dumb footballer and gutless.

His turnovers cost us numerous goals, so the fact that his opponent didn't directly kick goals on him, undoes all the good work defensively.

And it goes without saying that Davey is done. But giving him the rest of the season to play before he retires, won't change anything.

It's rewarding people like Dunn with game after game while Davis has been serving a 4 year sentence in the VFL, that is mind boggling.

I know what I can get from Dunn, and I hate it.

Davey had directly cost us two goals at the point we were 13 points down in the 2nd.

I disagree Dunn cost us numerous goals.

Dunn is actually a good kick and is the only one who seems to be able to kick out and hit a target. Other than Watts no one else can.

He is no star but he played a good game today. He can also tag and be a run with player. Would you rather he have the ball in his hands or McKenzie?

I would also like Davis to get a run.

[titan_uranus 23,228]

Dunn is actually a good kick and is the only one who seems to be able to kick out and hit a target. Other than Watts no one else can.

This is completely incorrect.

Dunn may have done enough in beating Thomas to keep his spot in the side, and may well have been one of our best, but his field kicking is as bad as anyone else in the side. You're not watching enough games if you think Dunn hits targets kicking in. Again, while he may have hit one or two today, week in week out he reverts to bombing it 50 metres to a contest.

You may be right to defend him today, but in general his up-and-under kicking style is a liability.

[Lil_red_fire_engine 10,481]

Oh I watched it.

Dunn couldn't hit a target, is a dumb footballer and gutless.

His turnovers cost us numerous goals, so the fact that his opponent didn't directly kick goals on him, undoes all the good work defensively.

And it goes without saying that Davey is done. But giving him the rest of the season to play before he retires, won't change anything.

It's rewarding people like Dunn with game after game while Davis has been serving a 4 year sentence in the VFL, that is mind boggling.

I know what I can get from Dunn, and I hate it.

I am on record as I cannot stand Dunn and the sooner he is out of the side the better. However he clearly beat Thomas, did not shirk a contest today and to my recollection only cost us one goal with an error today.

Craig has gone on record as stating the rest of the year is about team and individual development. There is no benefit to playing Davey. I hope today was his last in the MFC jumper.

Edited July 27, 2013 by big_red_fire_engine

[What 18,810]

GWS are killing the Pies as we speak

Their midfield is 10 times better than ours

We will get smashed next week

[Generation dee 1,336]

Just play the kids. I'll handle 122pt loss knowing they are young and learning. But flash, Byrnes, pedo, Dunn, etc fill me with no optimism. Even blease can go back to vfl and just learn how to get the footy. Tynan, Davis, taggert, I don't mind who.

I've lost all discretion for caring about the players when they serve that filth. And they wonder why 16,000 people turn up. Here's a tip lads- no one will waste their weekend watching your abysmally inept effort at playing a team sport if you don't show any pride.

[Born to Run 204]

Well, if we get belted by GWS and they win today, we are likely to be on the bottom of the ladder and officially the worst side in the comp...

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

OUT: Pedersen, Dunn, Trengove, Byrnes, Davey

IN: Garland, Jetta, Taggert, Magner, Tynan

Edited July 27, 2013 by Clint Bizkit

[What 18,810]

Jeremy Howe can have a spell at Casey

[Pirlo 592]

Jeremy Howe can have a spell at Casey

Are you an idiot?

Anyone calling for Dunn to go can [censored] off too, he was fine today.

Give Davis a go for Pedersen btw.