The Trade/Draft Rumour Mill

[Bitter but optimistic 22,241]

Mr Bitty Spank.... Has a nice ring to it. Suits your avatar too. Gives you an air of sofistomakashun Bitty.

As a retort, that's a clear failure Moonie. You'll need to do better than that. But another time another thread - or we'll be hijacking.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,053]

I posted a few days ago on the rumours about St. Kilda being in trouble and, despite the positive spin the Saints have put on their trading of Ben McEvoy, I can't accept that the trade spells anything else but that they're in a bit of strife.

So I'll add another rumour to the mill.

There's another big one to come from St. Kilda in the next few days.

If it's Stevens for Pick 2 I'll kiss you Jack.

There was an article earlier today quoting someone at the saints where they listed Fisher, Reiwoldt and Montagna as being untouchable in terms of trades. I noted with great interest that they made no mention of Stevens in that statement. Combining that with the stated goal of getting three first round picks for the upcoming draft I have to wonder if they aren't quietly working on a deal for him. He's one of the few players they have left who would command a first round pick. I'm not sure I'd be happy with us giving up our pick 2 for him, but maybe they could stack things a bit by offering us something to go with him?

[beelzebub 23,377]

Would rather wait a week to land an awesome trade than have a heap of [censored] trades like last year

Amen to that brother

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,602]

Imagine their supporters if we scored jack Steven for pick 2?

[Wiseblood 24,637]

We only need to look at the McEvoy trade today to see that anything can happen in trade week - McEvoy had not been mentioned anywhere and all of a sudden he is traded to Hawthorn. While we may not be mentioned as much as some would like that doesn't mean we aren't very active behind the scenes.

I'm still convinced we will get the deals done that we want and we will see some improvement to our list over the next few months.

[tonatopia 278]

Lets deal with facts.

We have pick 2.

Who really wants to recruit on of the best young players in the leauge?

Adelaide want Aish. Ok. Well we can give you Aish (conditional to asking GSW), how about we trade for;

Sloane or Crouch

We can sweeten the deal if you like. How about Jamar and pick 50odd aswell?

===================================

Or, if GWS are not going to pick Boyd, we can offer boyd up for trade.

Who wants Boyd?

Carlton

Bulldogs

StKilda

Brisbane

Fremantle

Ok, lets do a deal.

Carlton, how about you give us Duigan & Robinson and pick 12, for pick 2, (for example)

and so on.

Stkilda, how about a straight swap for Stevens. You might end up with another Plugger!

Edited October 10, 2013 by tonatopia

[Jerry Lundergard 420]

The trade period is [censored] stupid. Why don't they have free agency for the 1st week then trade period the next 2. Surely this is a waste of time and over indulgence by the AFL.

They should just have a trade window. None of this rubbish of getting clubs all together in the one place where journos can hang around like vultures and feed us crap.

Let the clubs just do business between themselves from the comfort of their respective cities and offices, and when a deal gets done, lodge it and let us all know.

[deeko 952]

Wow there is some rubbish around in the media. I'm lucky enough to know Walker and firstly you wouldn't meet a better bloke and secondly he adores Mick as a coach and he is playing with ridiculous confidence right now.

Now something that doesn't probaby belong on this thread (just to hard to search old ones on the phone) is our new "Josh Kennedy like" (not actually him but) midfielder we will have this year in one Jack Trengove.

Roos will be playing him on ball all year and will he modelling his whole game on JPK. Told after the meeting with Roos the whole group walked out a foot taller after they were hanging on every word they said. All ridiculously excited to start as they will be playing a lot more attacking footy this year.

Told from a mate (i know that sounds dodgey to) but he is pretty close with trenners and thinks he will be having a bumper year.

[Machsy 2,858]

?

That's essentially exactly what it is, except the AFL facilitate the process and act as mediators when needed to expedite trading.

It's not a bad thing.

[thedirtydog24 18]

We only need to look at the McEvoy trade today to see that anything can happen in trade week - McEvoy had not been mentioned anywhere and all of a sudden he is traded to Hawthorn. While we may not be mentioned as much as some would like that doesn't mean we aren't very active behind the scenes.

I'm still convinced we will get the deals done that we want and we will see some improvement to our list over the next few months.

It was widely known that McEvoy was on the trade table. SEN mentioned it on Monday on The Run Home.

[1964nowMORE 489]

The saints did put something out saying they would be trading and it would be unpopular

Somehow I suspect that McEvoy isn't the only one. Considering they said Montagna won't be leaving and everyone knows about Nicky Dal I suggest it is another of their better players. No way is it Jack Steven though, they still need some decent young established players

Armitage so my mad passionate saints fan mum says!

[What 18,810]

Max Gawn > Billy Longer

[Wiseblood 24,637]

It was widely known that McEvoy was on the trade table. SEN mentioned it on Monday on The Run Home.

So it was mentioned once on SEN three days ago.

Point is that the trade took many by surprise and no one really saw it coming.

[Lordweaver 235]

Are there any other demonlanders out there who are concerned that what with 50,000 players out there (slight exaggeration) going left, right and centre from one club to another and the dees HAVE DONE NOTHING. They are like an inert gas!

of course, and anyone who says they aren't is a liar or in denial

[titan_uranus 25,020]

Are there any other demonlanders out there who are concerned that what with 50,000 players out there (slight exaggeration) going left, right and centre from one club to another and the dees HAVE DONE NOTHING. They are like an inert gas!

1. The fact we have not done anything in the first of a multi-week period is not cause for alarm. Only Richmond, Carlton, Hawthorn and St Kilda have traded players yet. That's 4/18 clubs. Just 4.

2. Inert gases actually do many things.

[deeko 952]

Well if we have the same team as last year and still are as disgusting as we were then at least we can put to bed the blame on the coaches and then be put out of our misery and fold.

But i still blame the last three for everything. Including why demonland has been playing me up forcing me to actually do some work during the day.

The bastards

[Lordweaver 235]

I don't doubt that there will be appointments/changes, just thought we might have been a little more prominent early re coach in waiting, re midfielder appointments/trades given our year, the appointment of the messiah. Early mail indicates a preference by players to steer clear of the red and blue

[dee-luded 2,959]

Fools rush in...as they say

where saints fear to tread?

[brey9186 102]

Rumour is armitage is on the move from saints too, with saints keen on longer from Brisbane. Arma is a QLD boy but if he wants to stay in VIC, surely our pick 20 to Brisbane, with longer to saints good enough to snare him! Stuck behind a few blokes in saints middle, but runs all day and would fit in well here

[bing181 9,240]

Early mail indicates a preference by players to steer clear of the red and blue

Like who?

Examples please, of players we want/need, but who have gone to other clubs.

[Demonsterative 3,020]

It seems to me every available player who has expressed an interest in going to another club equates (to many here) that they are turning their back on the MFC. I have yet to hear or read a comment that these same players have said "I do not want to go to the MFC"

[mikeydemon 126]

There was an article earlier today quoting someone at the saints where they listed Fisher, Reiwoldt and Montagna as being untouchable in terms of trades. I noted with great interest that they made no mention of Stevens in that statement. Combining that with the stated goal of getting three first round picks for the upcoming draft I have to wonder if they aren't quietly working on a deal for him. He's one of the few players they have left who would command a first round pick. I'm not sure I'd be happy with us giving up our pick 2 for him, but maybe they could stack things a bit by offering us something to go with him?

A news station (i think 7) said that Fisher may be part of a deal to get Bruce from GWS to the saints. Not sure how credible they are but they also said if Hawthorn recieve pick 20 as compo for Buddy (i was under the impression it was pick 18, which would go down to 19 if Dale Thomas compo is pick 11, would be traded to the Saints for the second rounder as a sweetener for the McEvoy deal.

[dee-luded 2,959]

Max Gawn > Billy Longer

for about another 5 months.

[dee-luded 2,959]

I don't doubt that there will be appointments/changes, just thought we might have been a little more prominent early re coach in waiting, re midfielder appointments/trades given our year, the appointment of the messiah. Early mail indicates a preference by players to steer clear of the red and blue

the better value players may appear, after all the big names have been paid for?

We may already have some organised, but waiting for the appropriate time to be registered?

[stuie 7,374]

Mitch Clark and Chris Dawes nboth came to the MFC

Its an absolute myth that nobody wants to play here

We have a salary cap tho, there's only so much preference you can buy.