Come on Neeldy prove the masses wrong

[Soidee 1,496]

This bloke was appointed because his reputation was solid at Collingwood. Somehow for reasons we are not privy to it has all come apart for him.

Surely he is better than this....surely!! We have to give this man time and show some faith.

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

But if you ain't got the cattle, you ain't got the cattle.

[jazza 1,323]

its all positive from here on in, should beat brizzy and we will all be on the road to happiness

This bloke was appointed because his reputation was solid at Collingwood. Somehow for reasons we are not privy to it has all come apart for him.

Surely he is better than this....surely!! We have to give this man time and show some faith.

[rpfc 28,727]

He has a few months to get something going.

[Waltham33 475]

The time is now - go Dees

[H_T 3,049]

But if you ain't got the cattle, you ain't got the cattle.

And if you've got the 18th ranked midfield, you're prone to being ranked really low for i50's and ranked really high for defensive i50 entries.

For Neeld's sake he needs the midfield to generate into something effective. And with Jones, Jamar, McKenzie (inj- coming back), a splattering of first year players in Viney, Toumpas, and some mature players who may be inconsistent - Sylvia, Bail, Jones......plus our skippers...

It really is an underwhelming midfield lacking quality and any cohesion at present.

Edited April 11, 2013 by H_T

[Sir Why You Little 37,119]

He has a few months to get something going.

he has weeks...

[stinga81 210]

I hope for his sake he starts winning, but the players will decide his fate in the coming weeks.

[old dee 23,870]

But if you ain't got the cattle, you ain't got the cattle.

That is the sad truth

IMO we have the worst list including the newbys

I doubt JC could turn them into a side above fourth last.

In the same breath it is hard to believe that this list is 19 goals worse than Port.

In the first two Games we have not been AFL standard.

Is the list that bad?

I don't know but another similar result on Saturday and I will say yes

[jazza 1,323]

be positive. looking for 2nd win against brizzy. and then things will seem better for all of us

he has weeks...

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

i'm a firm believer that we need to give Neeldy a good 5 year crack at it.
He has been handed a big ol' mess. Give him longer than 2 years, please.

Edited April 11, 2013 by The Song Formerly Known As

[tonatopia 278]

i'm a firm believer that we need to give Neeldy a good 5 year crack at it.

He has been handed a big ol' mess. Give him longer than 2 years, please.

[Tricky 341]

he has weeks...

[old dee 23,870]

he has weeks...

Sadly I think you are correct.

NO AFL team could keep their coach if he continued to coach and get results like the last two weeks.

On field currently we are a shambles.

That cannot continue for months, a few weeks pehaps but not months.

Lets not forget he has taken an average side to a poor side to one that is currently not even worthy of being in the competition.

God I hope they show some fight this weekend

[old dee 23,870]

be positive. looking for 2nd win against brizzy. and then things will seem better for all of us

So you have forfeited this week or next week?

[rpfc 28,727]

he has weeks...

You are supposing a clataclysm occurs against GWS.

I am expecting changes to the mindset of the players against WCE and solid improvement leading into the GWS game. I don't expect a loss.

[demon3165 2,798]

he has weeks...

lmfao........some people still do not understand.

[binman 43,704]

I am hoping that some magic has been weaved at Sorrento and he has connected with the players.

Whilst i agree our mid field is woeful (which does beg the question why Neeld has been so focused on talls) by far the the biggest issue is the players are not playing for him.

If that is not solved he's gone. If he can fix whatever is broken then things will improve and he'll stay. I sincerely hope he gets to stay.

Edited April 11, 2013 by binman

[Sir Why You Little 37,119]

I tend to agree.

GWS could be the nail / straw...

i want Neeld to survive but he has to prove his ability in a matter of weeks.

There was no spark in either Round 1 or 2

No life = Death.

[H_T 3,049]

No life = Death.

[Sir Why You Little 37,119]

Mildly amusing.

Good Boy.

[Jack7 528]

Neeld's coached 24 games so far and he's on his 3rd gameplan already.Remember the first few games last year where we hugged the boundary line coming out of the back pocket and by the time we played West Coast in round 4 or 5,Niknat would stand 5 metres in from the boundary line all day and he took mark after mark.Then he changed it up using more of the corridor and we got cut up on the rebound because of our poor foot skills.Now it the zone defence where we are standing 5-6 metres off our opponent and we get carved up by teams with pinpoint kicking and we are so far away from our opponents,we can't even lay tackles and pressure the ball carrier.

Sorry,but there has never been a coach that has done so much damage in 24 games of coaching,sent us back 3 years and don't get me started on the recuiting of VFL hacks.I shudder to think if Neeld coaches us for another 2 years.

[Moonshadow 17,676]

I am hoping that some magic has been weaved at Sorrento and he has connected with the players.

Whilst i agree our mid field is woeful (which does beg the question why Neeld has been so focused on talls) by far the the biggest issue is the players are not playing for him.

If that is not solved he's gone. If he can fix whatever is broken then things will improve and he'll stay. I sincerely hope he gets to stay.

I think he tried real hard to get midfielders from elsewhere that we're on the move or OOC, eg, Wellingham, BJ, etc, but they were not interested.

[Grand New Flag 3,227]

Responsibility for our demise rests on this muppets shoulders.

He should resign in shame.

He should go for the good of the team.

[jumbo returns 6,741]

Responsibility for our demise rests on this muppets shoulders.

He should resign in shame.

He should go for the good of the team.

Name a replacement?