Changes v Essendon

[Dr. Mubutu 778]

In: McDonald, Kent, MacDonald

Out: Gillies, Watts, Dunn

Sellar down back where he belongs, McDonald up forward where he played well at the end of last year, Watts out for a disgustingly laconic game.

Tapscott survives through his lack of gametime in the last couple of years.

While I agree about Watts putting in a poor effort yesterday, I do believe that there were some mitigating circumstances to that. And while it's not exactly making up for the poor on-field showing, at least he's had the intestinal fortitude to face up to the media since the game, which is more than can be said for his teammates.

[Little Richard 6,216]

While I agree about Watts putting in a poor effort yesterday, I do believe that there were some mitigating circumstances to that. And while it's not exactly making up for the poor on-field showing, at least he's had the intestinal fortitude to face up to the media since the game, which is more than can be said for his teammates.

I was umming about Watts as I think he is a confidence player above all else and might be more detrimental to drop him than effective. That is a good point but changes really do need to be made.

[Megzie666 1]

**FORFEIT**

At least then the club won't experience humiliating losses

FFS - if there are issues "in house" do us all a favour and fix it quickly, no matter what it takes. Wouldn't care if it was someone like Garry Lyon - club is bigger than any person and if the performance of the team is failing because of one or more persons - SACK THEIR ARSE!!

[titan_uranus 24,677]

I don't mean to be childish here (or maybe I do), but Dunn has to go, and to all those who wanted him in for Round 1 - I told you so.

He's completely useless and the fact he's played 100 games is a reflection of where this club's at right now.

From the parts of the game I've seen, I can't see the addition Pedersen gives to the side, and if Dawes is fit, surely that's a direct swap. Hopefully McDonald can take Gillies' place (no idea how Gillies played, but McDonald walks into our side and sounds like Gillies wasn't that good anyway).

Davey in as a wingman maybe? Blease to play a full game? Anything to give us more run. Although run can't be the only thing, since it seems Nicholson, one of our quickest, turned it over a lot.

Tapscott's likely to become our next Matt Bate - looks the type physically, shows promise early, but stagnates badly and goes nowhere over the course of 2-3 years. Thought Terlich did enough pre-season to get a game, so maybe that's a swap too.

[CBDees 3,165]

In: McDonald, Kent, MacDonald

Out: Gillies, Watts, Dunn

Sellar down back where he belongs, McDonald up forward where he played well at the end of last year, Watts out for a disgustingly laconic game.

Tapscott survives through his lack of gametime in the last couple of years.

I would bring in Terlich as well and drop Nicholson and Sellar [for dropping those marks] ahead fof Dunn and Watts for the same reasons that Dr M. gave

[stranga 328]

I'd have no issue with record changes. Terlich, Jetta, Kent, Evans , Macdonald, Mcdonald, Davey rather than the likes of Dunn, Watts, garland, Pedersen, Tappy, Sylvia and even Frawley and Mckenzie.

Edited April 1, 2013 by stranga

[What 18,810]

In - Dawes, Trengove, Terlich, Spencer, Jetta, Davey, T McDonald

Out - Tapscott, Jamar, Sellar, Nicholson, Gillies, Pedersen, Rodan

[Grimseyisgod 378]

IN: Jack Trengove, Chris Dawes, James Magner, Dean Terlich, Tom McDonald

OUT: Tom Gillies, Luke Tapscott, James Sellar, Nicho, Dunn

[McQueen 17,864]

Watched the weekends game at a mates place who's Port supporter. His comment as we were all leaving was "you need another 5 or 6 Viney's."

This was after I drank all his beer and kicked the crap out of his cat on the way out.

Seriously, if the team can bring a similar effort to that of young Jack, we will be competitive.

[McQueen 17,864]

If Nicholson is picked this weekend I will explode.

[Swampfox 190]

I can't understand how tapscott was selected in the first place. He hardly earned his spot based on his pre-season form -this simply doesn't happen in the good sides, if you're borderline best 22 you have to show some kind of form to warrant inclusion.

Can anyone tell me what his optimal position is? His 7 possessions today tells me he isn't a half forward flanker.

Other than being solidly built he hasn't shown anything in his career so far, other than laying a few bumps.

Had a decent debut playing on the half back flank and with that booming kick got the job of the kicking the ball back into play

Had high hopes for Tappy as he looked an excellent prospect predraft

Needs to control his aggression and concentrate on the basics of playing simple footy

IMO he is a robust forward flanker who should kick it to the top of the square as soon as he gets the ball

Part of the DO don't think group we seem to have too many of

To me he (and others) seems to be confused or timid about making a mistake which i fear is the result of being over coached

Absolutely stick to team rules but as long as it isnt a 10 page book then i really cannot see a problem in using his greatest asset .....KICKING THE BLOODY THING

Players under 50 games should play on instinct as that is what got them picked up in the draft in the first place

[dee-luded 2,959]

Sam Blease to play for Casey.... Seriously.

yep...

IMO the Senior side should be composed of this group which ever are fit...

start with our hardest heads in the side first, then as we gain confidence, introduce some more skill to the side.

31 Jack Grimes

9 Jack Trengove

2 Nathan Jones

11 Mitch Clark

6 Chris Dawes

8 James Frawley

40 Mark Jamar

13 Jordie McKenzie

10 Shannon Byrnes

7 Jack Viney

25 Tom McDonald

12 Colin Sylvia

15 David Rodan

28 Joel MacDonald

38 Jeremy Howe

34 Dean Kent

39 Neville Jetta

44 Rohan Bail

20 Colin Garland

19 James Strauss

45 Matt Jones

46 Dean Terlich

32 Michael Evans

& we might add Magner

------------------------------------

the rest can work their butts off with Casey & earn a spot.

4 Jack Watts

5 Jimmy Toumpas

14 Lynden Dunn

17 Sam Blease

21 Cameron Pedersen

26 Daniel Nicholson

27 Tom Gillies

30 James Sellar

33 Dom Barry

35 Luke Tapscott

36 Aaron Davey

37 Max Gawn

41 Troy Davis

42 Jake Spencer

43 Rory Taggert

46 Josh Tynan

48 Jack Fitzpatrick

& some have worked hard, & are coming along, thus far : Jack Fitzpatrick, Max Gawn, Jake Spencer, Jack Watts,,,,,

# edit: I forgot maximus

Edited July 23, 2013 by dee-luded