NAB Cup Friday 22nd February, 2013 @ 6.30pm

[Roger Mellie 4,015]

With Melbourne's first appearance in the NAB Cup less than 2 weeks away, it's time for a thread

On AFL.com.au:

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-02-11/suns-to-unleash-martin-in-nab-cup

It says that Jack Martin has received permission to play in the NAB Cup for GCS, but Melbourne haven't sought permission for Hogan (yet)?

[old dee 23,788]

Sorry RM and Rev.

But I don't want him playing in 2013.

Let the kid get to the right age before throwing him to the wolves.

We have been crap for years, lets do it right.

We have tried to be too clever too often in the last decade.

[rpfc 28,392]

Sorry RM and Rev.

But I don't want him playing in 2013.

Let the kid get to the right age before throwing him to the wolves.

We have been crap for years, lets do it right.

We have tried to be too clever too often in the last decade.

It's just the NAB Cup, OD.

I would say it was a Mickey Mouse comp, but I reckon even Mickey would be rested...

[My TD 156]

Sorry RM and Rev.

But I don't want him playing in 2013.

Let the kid get to the right age before throwing him to the wolves.

We have been crap for years, lets do it right.

We have tried to be too clever too often in the last decade.

Let 'im play.

Hes a different beast to Watts.

Hogans good to go.

[old dee 23,788]

It's just the NAB Cup, OD.

I would say it was a Mickey Mouse comp, but I reckon even Mickey would be rested...

That might be seen as tanking rpfc.

Don't agree I don't want him before he is 18.

Don't want him to have to wear the responsibility of a possible poxy result yet.

[Roger Mellie 4,015]

Sorry RM and Rev.

But I don't want him playing in 2013.

Let the kid get to the right age before throwing him to the wolves.

We have been crap for years, lets do it right.

We have tried to be too clever too often in the last decade.

Who says playing him is the wrong thing to do?

Gold Coast will have done it twice, indicating to me it might be a good idea at least.

The beauty of the NAB Cup is you can give him a taste of AFL level and are not locking him in to 2 hours of footy.

He could play between 1 min and 2 hours!

[H_T 3,043]

Hogan will play NAB Cup

[old dee 23,788]

Hogan will play NAB Cup

For once H_T I hope you are wrong

[Roger Mellie 4,015]

For once H_T I hope you are wrong

Nervous Nellie!

[old dee 23,788]

Nervous Nellie!

There is plenty of background for my opinion

[Roger Mellie 4,015]

Under Neeld?

[Gorgoroth 12,947]

Lets imagine the melt down if he plays and does not get a kick....

[old dee 23,788]

Under Neeld?

4 wins and 1 nab cup

Not sure there is a lot to consider there RM.

But I am nit picking.

I just believe we should not push the envelope with Hogan.

[old dee 23,788]

Lets imagine the melt down if he plays and does not get a kick....

You have my vote

Don't believe the kid needs the pressure at 17

[Satyriconhome 10,871]

Looking over your shoulder again Old Dee, have a look at the training photos from today, that is a 17yr old wrestling somebody who is over 100kg, great to see, looking fwd to seeing Hogan in the NAB Cup, I want Dom Barry to get an extended taste as well

[Carrot Top 947]

You have my vote

Don't believe the kid needs the pressure at 17

Pressure? It's a micky mouse training drill. I don't care if what happens in those games as long as no-one gets hurt.

[old dee 23,788]

Pressure? It's a micky mouse training drill. I don't care if what happens in those games as long as no-one gets hurt.

There you go

[rhaz 342]

Already got a stack of new players to suss out in the NAB Cup. Not a whole lot of point in risking Hogan in any way when he can't play this year.

[Satyriconhome 10,871]

Old Dee you can get hurt at training, just ask Max Gawn or Daniel Menzel or Morabito or and the list goes on

[old dee 23,788]

Old Dee you can get hurt at training, just ask Max Gawn or Daniel Menzel or Morabito or and the list goes on

Thats true what why push up the odds for a 17 year old

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

Age has nothing to do with it when you have a body like that. I say give him a taste- it's not for us, it's for him. He isn't playing any footy this year so let's whet his appetite with some real game time. The fact that it's NAB cup is enough to tell me it won't be overly physical and if he can get through a practice match he can get through a glorified one (hopefully) and as has been already said, injuries can happen anywhere, anytime.

Unleash the beast!

[Deestroy All 14,265]

As fun as it'd be to have a look at him running around in a match, it's a practice match, we need to practice kicking it to new key targets in Dawes and Pete O'File, players that'll actually be there in round 1.

Key position needs more drilling that bringing a kid off the bench to a flank.

[Bossdog 2,002]

Tim Watson played VFL at age 15.....

Just sayin.....

[Deestroy All 14,265]

Tim Watson played VFL at age 15.....

Just sayin.....

VFL isn't AFL level though.

*hides in the shadows*

[old dee 23,788]

After being crap for years the temptation is to want instant success is enormance.

We have seen what that has produced over the last 7 years I can wait another year to see Hogan.