And another one bites the dust - Cook

[Demon Disciple 12,127]

Lucas Cook is now said to be gone - trade or de-listed

Demons exodus continues with Lucas Cook

[Little Richard 6,262]

This is pretty impressive so far, good to see drastic action. I'm liking Neeld more and more, he's going to make a real football club out of the MFC.

[stuie 7,374]

No surprises so far, but I'll be disappointed if we lose Gysberts.

[whatwhat say what 22,757]

God, what a waste of a high draft pick.

[Demon Disciple 12,127]

God, what a waste of a high draft pick.

yep, we could've and should've taken Darling. I remember the exact moment when we read out Cook's name on the radio, which lead me to say in shock "woooaaahhhhh", i knew right then and there that we had stuffed that pick up.

Thanks again Barry, also wanted to get Talia with pick 11 in the '09 draft. I know we all think we are expert recruiter's, but i honestly think i would have chosen better prospects than BP did, which goes to show how [censored] of a recruiting manager he was.

[stuie 7,374]

yep, we could've and should've taken Darling. I remember the exact moment when we read out Cook's name on the radio, which lead me to say in shock "woooaaahhhhh", i knew right then and there that we had stuffed that pick up.

Thanks again Barry, also wanted to get Talia with pick 11 in the '09 draft. I know we all think we are expert recruiter's, but i honestly think i would have chosen better prospects than BP did, which goes to show how [censored] of a recruiting manager he was.

9 other clubs were into him.

It just didn't pan out, which is why drafting isn't an exact science.

Get a grip.

[Lord Travis 10,730]

This is pretty impressive so far, good to see drastic action. I'm liking Neeld more and more, he's going to make a real football club out of the MFC.

Or run it into the ground! We'll have to wait a few years to see how it pans out, but he's certainly making some bold moves and won't die wondering. Good to see a different approach I guess!

Very disappointed by this news though. Not necessarily by losing Cook, as he has shown nothing, but the fact we wasted our first pick in that draft for nothing. We could've been safe and picked 30-40 players who would've given us good service, so it was just a baffling choice and a waste that sets us back further.

[w00dy 146]

very early call on Lucas. Would've liked to see him have another season at least, to see if he came on, but it would appear he won't get that opportunity.

Clubs are said to be interested in him, what do we think we'll get for him? 2nd / 3rd round draft pick would be nice? I think we'd look to get a player instead of a pick for him however.

[angrydee 842]

I believe GWS are offering a used fafafel wrapper.

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

Let the "We should have taken Darling" posts begin.

[QueenC 74]

Let the "We should have taken Darling" posts begin.

All too true (on all fronts).....

This is quite sad (esecially given his draft number), but I wouldn't exactly call it a big shock.

[Glenn Molloy 494]

This does surprise me a bit, never seen him play apart from the odd bit on telly so can't really judge it. Although he's made slow progress I figured that they might give him some more time given that he's a tall. That said, I'm not upset about it, because having seen him over the past couple of years they must be in a position to know whether or not he'll make it, and to cut him now suggests they just don't think he'll cut the mustard. Real shame given what else was on offer in that draft but as Stuie says, it just didn't pan out....I just wish some of our high pick recruits WOULD pan out though !!!

[Guest KingDingAling]

Cook and Gysberts were both surprise picks at where they were taken.

Head scratchers.

Very poor drafting, but whats done it done.

[pantaloons 2,019]

There were two surprising points in that article: one, that it said we are to turn ver as many as 10 players this offseason (I wouldn't put a ceiling on it); and two, that nine clubs are interested in Cook, presumably mistaking him for a chef.

[Undeeterred 3,124]

Why are we telling people that he would be delisted otherwise?

Surely that reduces his trade value...

[beelzebub 23,376]

Huge loss, absolutely shattered.......

[old dee 23,791]

Why are we telling people that he would be delisted otherwise?

Surely that reduces his trade value...

Maybe because he is not much chop and the football world knows it anyway.

IMO there is not much there when after 2 years a supposed AA CHF cannot maintain his spot in Casey Seniors.

Finally we are seeing what most people have known for some time.

We have a crap list.

Sadly because I am running out of years It is start again time.

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

There were two surprising points in that article: one, that it said we are to turn ver as many as 10 players this offseason (I wouldn't put a ceiling on it); and two, that nine clubs are interested in Cook, presumably mistaking him for a chef.

I can't understand why so many clubs would be interested in a fringe VFL player.

[old dee 23,791]

Huge loss, absolutely shattered.......

I am struggling to eat my banana this morning bb.

some clubs do have em.

[beelzebub 23,376]

Why are we telling people that he would be delisted otherwise?

Surely that reduces his trade value...

Melbourne have invoked the "reality' act.

Theres a time for ducks and drakes...and then theres occasions like this.

Cook's cooked

[old dee 23,791]

I can't understand why so many clubs would be interested in a fringe VFL player.

GTG you can read the article that way or that the clubs we keen at draft time.

[beelzebub 23,376]

I am struggling to eat my banana this morning bb.

some clubs do have em.

cant even bear to look at my breakfast Old...., just devastating

[Bristling T 11]

Jeremy Howe was also a surprise selection

[DemonTux 97]

.... Jai Sheehan and Leigh Williams are easily more of a presence at Casey, the former I think has been great the last 3 weeks (yes i have been there) the latter was also very good in his last appearance especially considering the issues he has had this year. Yes waste of pic but Jai at least on exposed form and talent in terms of list management looks to be and upgrade.

Had to feel for Lucas though, on the weekend he just got monster ed, got to the fall of ball OK but always had the defender who was 2x his size on him knocking him out of the way.

[Bitter but optimistic 22,241]

The exodus of players is one thing but as the toll mounts who are we going to replace them with? The list of available experienced "name" players is dwindling -eg Boak gone, Cloke not wanted, Tippett going north if anywhere. If we replace all our losses with draft picks or fringe players from other clubs, I fear we are going to sit in the doldrums for many, many years.