Chris Judd's chicken winging of Leigh Adams

[Mac7 309]

Adams left the ground again late in the game in a lot pain holding his shoulder and those [censored] commentators laughed it off even saying "Juddy weakened him"

Those muppets at channel 7 surely are done after this year!?

[dazzledavey36 54,302]

i agree channel 7 are a disgrace!

[rpfc 28,266]

For those that don't think there was much in that - I have done my shoulder once this season, thankfully not that bad but if someone 'winged' me like that I would be on Land more, let's say that...

If someone had done that to Judd they would be a sense that they are in immediate and terrible trouble.

He should go and it should finish Carlton's season and they have no-one to thank but the great Champion of Recycling himself.

[Redleg 40,854]

Actually watching that now with the sound I have to say that the behaviour of the 7 commentators was only slightly less disgraceful. Their inane giggling at Judds actions really backs up the thoughts of the man in the street that this bloke is treated defferently to the rest by the media mugs.

Agree.

[IRW 1,387]

The response of the Kanga guys around the pack was remarkable.

When they realised what the bald gap mouthed creep was doing they reacted as if they were saving someone from being hit by a car,not 'flying the flag' in the usual tough guy argey bargey of football.

The blokes got form and its all gutless....Beamers boxing camp with one hand tied behind his back would be a fair penalty

[Bossdog 2,002]

I thought Judd was best on ground....It's a pity that frustration makes him do stupid acts like this...2 weeks.

[beelzebub 23,313]

The response of the Kanga guys around the pack was remarkable.

When they realised what the bald gap mouthed creep was doing they reacted as if they were saving someone from being hit by a car,not 'flying the flag' in the usual tough guy argey bargey of football.

The blokes got form and its all gutless....Beamers boxing camp with one hand tied behind his back would be a fair penalty

I loved their response...all rose as one and literally turfed the bastard in the air and on his arse.

I DARE the AFL to fine them for that !!..

Hes a cheap thug Judd.. thats all..

[titan_uranus 24,978]

Deserves weeks. That is really a low act.

[Ouch! 2,258]

and here is the Carlton response in regards to the incident

"Carlton assistant coach Alan Richardson defended Judd on Melbourne radio SEN, saying the skipper was intent on stopping Adams from handballing and did not want to hurt him."

FFS that would have to be one of the worst defences I have heard.

Hope he goes for that dog act!

[beelzebub 23,313]

and here is the Carlton response in regards to the incident

"Carlton assistant coach Alan Richardson defended Judd on Melbourne radio SEN, saying the skipper was intent on stopping Adams from handballing and did not want to hurt him."

FFS that would have to be one of the worst defences I have heard.

Hope he goes for that dog act!

crap !!!! We can smell you Carlton !!!

[monoccular 17,413]

and here is the Carlton response in regards to the incident

"Carlton assistant coach Alan Richardson defended Judd on Melbourne radio SEN, saying the skipper was intent on stopping Adams from handballing and did not want to hurt him."

FFS that would have to be one of the worst defences I have heard.

Hope he goes for that dog act!

"He couldn't get near his eyes so this was the next best thing"

[Moonshadow 17,675]

I reckon it won't be long before Judd starts squirrelling or doing a Hopoate.

Great player, champion, but what a weasel act to do to a defencless player on the ground.

If I was a Norf supporter, I would be very proud of my players reaction to Judd's arm twist. Putting him straight on his arse.

[Pates 9,660]

Why the hell is he being defended so heavily?! (Obviously not here!)

Is the media and the AFL so desperate to have a player of his quality so squeaky clean?! If this had been Sam Mitchell, Brent Guerra, or Steve Baker everyone would've been jumping up and down!

It was a dog act, forget whether or not he was meaning to hurt the bloke it could've done some serious damage.

MRP is already a joke but will be evn more so if he doesn't get at a least a week.

[beelzebub 23,313]

someone just needs to run through him.......accidentally..of course.

[Robbie57 2,020]

Disgrace.

[Whispering_Jack 29,812]

The news today is that Leigh Adams suffered a subluxed shoulder as a result of Judd's tackle. That's going to make it even harder for Judd to escape a penalty. I originally thought he might get just one week but I reckon that it's starting to look like two.

[Pates 9,660]

The news today is that Leigh Adams suffered a subluxed shoulder as a result of Judd's tackle. That's going to make it even harder for Judd to escape a penalty. I originally thought he might get just one week but I reckon that it's starting to look like two.

How will the MRP rate it though, there is no contact and no impact. It's him tugging the blokes arm out of the shoulder. This is a real challenge to the MRP because it doesn't fit into their system, and really if they can't work this one out send it to the tribunal.

[Moonshadow 17,675]

How will the MRP rate it though, there is no contact and no impact. It's him tugging the blokes arm out of the shoulder. This is a real challenge to the MRP because it doesn't fit into their system, and really if they can't work this one out send it to the tribunal.

Unduly rough contact? Intentional? Contact severe?

Just shoot the dog.

[Maybe next year 170]

Interested To note that when I was watching the Melbourne V Fremantle game on foxtel yesterday ( I live in Sydney) that they tried to say Colin Garland did the same and that maybe this is a new trend in footy. Personally isawnothing similar In the two acts other than there was a tackle. Let's see what happens.

[Range Rover 1,935]

How will the MRP rate it though, there is no contact and no impact. It's him tugging the blokes arm out of the shoulder. This is a real challenge to the MRP because it doesn't fit into their system, and really if they can't work this one out send it to the tribunal.

He should be charged with bringing the game into disrepute and left to the mercy of the tribunal. 5 weeks.

[DeeMfc 621]

He should be charged with bringing the game into disrepute and left to the mercy of the tribunal. 5 weeks.

This!

It is proven that he is a sniper of the highest order and shouldn't be held in as higher esteem as he is.

His brownlow medals should be handed back as he certainly has been the best in the past although the award's specific criterion is "fairest and best", reflecting an emphasis on sportsmanship and fair play.

[titan_uranus 24,978]

How will the MRP rate it though, there is no contact and no impact. It's him tugging the blokes arm out of the shoulder. This is a real challenge to the MRP because it doesn't fit into their system, and really if they can't work this one out send it to the tribunal.

He was charged with 'misconduct', which allows the MRP to send the incident directly to the Tribunal. Which they should do, as they can't properly assess it using their points system, as there wasn't really an 'impact'.

[Robot Devil 1,895]

I'm wondering if Judd has been sucked in by all the glory heaped on him in the media.

It almost seems to resemble a doctor with a God complex, in that only Judd can have/get the footy and that he alone controls the terms and outcome of the contest.

However he seems to have an urge to achieve that goal in a brutal manner and is unable to resist at the expense of all reasonable thought.

He has done some incredibly bizarre things, with many of the victims in a prone position unable to protect themselves, and it may be that these incidents become more frequent if the pressure to deliver for Carlton increases.

[keep13alive 78]

Gutless dog act like his previous cowardly acts.Should cop 8 weeks but the golden child will be lucky to get 2.

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

You were just listening to Finey on SEN, weren't you Keep13Alive?