National U18's Carnival

[Bossdog 2,002]

Like the look of Mcdoughou (Cant't spell for nuts) 2 Classy goals after six last week also Whitfield is playing well

[mdemonski2 403]

Hey deers

Have not noticed stringer at all. So not sure what has happened there.

Nascent, agree mate. Toumpas is so balanced and disposes beautifully. I like wines but would go toumpas anyday.

Whitfield, can see why there is the hype with him at 1. Another vc bloke who looks like a bulocking darling type forward in tim membrey. Looks ok.

[Bossdog 2,002]

Hey deers

Have not noticed stringer at all. So not sure what has happened there.

Nascent, agree mate. Toumpas is so balanced and disposes beautifully. I like wines but would go toumpas anyday.

Whitfield, can see why there is the hype with him at 1. Another vc bloke who looks like a bulocking darling type forward in tim membrey. Looks ok.

Membrey kicked 3 in the 1st quarter

[mdemonski2 403]

Jack v is playing game 2 accorsing to a pretty reliable sauce, his old man!

[Guest KingDingAling]

My boy Oliver Wines showing them how its done.

[olisik 4,060]

I can see a potential Wines v Toumpas v Stringer thread happening

I rate them as

1 - Stringer

2 - Wines

3 - Toumpas

Wines beats Toumpas due to chemistry with young jacky boy, but thats my opinion.

[mdemonski2 403]

Yeah wines racking em up this quarter. Solid young fella. Reminds me a helluva lot of a young col sylvia - that a good or a bad thing!?

[mdemonski2 403]

AnY way we could take whitfield of gc hands?

[Bossdog 2,002]

AnY way we could take whitfield of gc hands?

No....but I will take Wines Edited July 4, 2012 by Bossdog

[olisik 4,060]

AnY way we could take whitfield of gc hands?

Maybe if no1 bids for Viney, we could try trade pick 3 & 4 for him.

GC will be unbelievable in a few years, Swallow, O Meara and Whitfield in the mid-field...

[mdemonski2 403]

Fair call re wines/stringer/toumpas.

I see it diFferently:

1. Toumpas

2. Wineds

3. Stringer

But reckon I'll defer to todd on viney on this one!

Added note, wines def picked it up a notch in scond half - v impressive.

Game overall a really good standard. Some impressive kids I reckon will also be picked up later in draft.

[DEELIGHTED 16]

If Wines is good now imagine how good he will be when he "matures"????

[wattsup 470]

is viney playing didnt see him on team lineup

[Biffen 12,939]

If Wines is good now imagine how good he will be when he "matures"????

he might need to develop with Sellars-Viney could give him a good start ,and then he could shape himself around Glass .

Edit :sorry if those jokes are not your vintage.

But if you dont like them it's probably a case of sour grapes.

Edited July 4, 2012 by Biffen

[daisycutter 29,482]

is viney playing didnt see him on team lineup

playing

[Grapeviney 9,604]

he might need to develop with Sellars-Viney could give him a good start ,and then he could shape himself around Glass .

Edit :sorry if those jokes are not your vintage.

But if you dont like them it's probably a case of sour grapes.

put a cork in it biff !

[mdemonski2 403]

Yeah viney listed as 35 in record here but I reckon he is 28. Can anyone confirm for me?

[wattsup 470]

Yeah viney listed as 35 in record here but I reckon he is 28. Can anyone confirm for me?

yep definently 28

[wattsup 470]

bombers are getting an absolute bargain this year daniher would go number 1

[mdemonski2 403]

I reckon daniher is bloody huge, mobile + skillful. Trifecta for the bummers.

[mdemonski2 403]

Thanks watts up. Viney going well but surely only worth a second rounder ;-)

[Guest KingDingAling]

Thanks watts up. Viney going well but surely only worth a second rounder ;-)

He's not worth pick 3.

[dazzledavey36 53,478]

viney has been quite but shows he is a quality player. but to the melbourne football club please do everything you can to get oliver wines the kid is going to be a star! him and viney would be a masterstroke! reminds me of mark reccuito with his hardness and kicking.

[Geddy Lee 582]

He's not worth pick 3.

NO he certainly isn't.

*wink wink*

[whatwhat say what 22,352]

watched most of both games thus far. real stand-outs in the first game for me were:

grundy (sa ruckman)

stringer (vic c winger / half forward / 3rd tall forward type)

wines (vic c in-and-under midfielder)

toumpas (smooth moving sa in- and outside mid)

kennedy (small, zippy sa outside mid / small forward)

membrey (bullocking vic c third tall forward type - be interesting to see where he fits in the afl)

whitfield (vic c ball magnet - beautiful off both sides)

based on what i've seen of the vic m-wa clash thus far, no way is viney worth #3 in the draft. still hope we get him for that second round pick tho!

Edited July 4, 2012 by DemonAndrew