What Would Happen If We Abolished The Draft

[Guest Dr Who]

What Would Happen If We Abolished The Draft - what do you think?

Would the rich dominate? or Would we get a fairer comp?

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

What would you propose instead?

If it was a players choice where to be drafted we would be up poo creek without a paddle because as sad as it is to say what reason do we give young to players to come to our club, especially if they had other offers from continually successful Clubs?

Edited April 22, 2012 by The Song Formerly Known As

[rpfc 28,046]

Or would we capitalise words that are not nouns mid-sentence?

Seriously, HO007, we have had this argument before. It doesn't work without a draft.

There, I saved Demonland about 100 posts.

[praha 11,110]

Or would we capitalise words that are not nouns mid-sentence?

Who gives a [censored]?

[rpfc 28,046]

Who gives a [censored]?

It's a Little annoying is All...

[Sir Why You Little 36,608]

without a draft, we would have to spend up big from the go, & get it absolutely right.

A large risk, but maybe the shot this club needs.

I would prefer a ranking system of the salary caps as per ladder positions.

Premier Team plays 100% top $...Bottom team pays about 85-90% of the salary Cap

Put some incentive into climbing the ladder...not to plummet into the welfare trough.

[Guest Dr Who]

What would you propose instead?

If it was a players choice where to be drafted we would be up poo creek without a paddle because as sad as it is to say what reason do we give young to players to come to our club, especially if they had other offers from continually successful Clubs?

I had noticed someone on another thread suggesting it -

But yes I could see no alternative too - "players choice where to be drafted we would be up poo creek without a paddle because as sad as it is to say what reason do we give young to players to come to our club, especially if they had other offers from continually successful Clubs?"

I agree we would be in a "poo" - attitudes would have to change.

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

The draft was set up to try t o make the competition a level playing field, without it [censored] teams wouldnt have access to high draft picks. the fact that we screw most of ours up is another story.

If we abolished the draft we would have no currency to trade with and we are such an unattractive prospect we would surely fold in time. we would become even worse

[Jordie_tackles 354]

What Would Happen If We Abolished The Draft - what do you think?

Would the rich dominate? or Would we get a fairer comp?

It depends on if we make full free agency ect available, i cannot see it helping the MFC thats for sure.

I like the draft and think it does its job

[Chook 14,993]

Who gives a [censored]?

Whoever invented the capital letter would be right royally [censored] off to see you abusing it like that. No respect!

If we kept a salary-cap which was strictly regulated and could be sure there'd be no Judd-style deals, and if we could guarantee every player would be more interested in earning money than winning a Premiership, then abolishing the Draft would work. But players can (and do) get payed off-book by wealthy clubs, and many people would simply just go running in search of a Premiership, leaving the poorly-performed clubs high and dry. In short, we'd probably be screwed.

Edited April 22, 2012 by Chook

[Guest Dr Who]

It depends on if we make full free agency ect available, i cannot see it helping the MFC thats for sure.

I like the draft and think it does its job

So you support protectionism by the AFL? You support restriction of players being able to choose their own employer from day 1 of their career?

[Guest Dr Who]

Whoever invented the capital letter would be right royally [censored] off to see you abusing it like that. No respect!

If we kept a salary-cap which was strictly regulated and could be sure there'd be no Judd-style deals, and if we could guarantee every player would be more interested in earning money than winning a Premiership, then abolishing the Draft would work. But players can (and do) get payed off-book by wealthy clubs, and many people would simply just go running in search of a Premiership, leaving the poorly-performed clubs high and dry. In short, we'd probably be screwed.

Why have a salary cap if "players can (and do) get payed off-book"?

[Chook 14,993]

Why have a salary cap if "players can (and do) get payed off-book"?

Because getting payed off-book is morally wrong. It's like saying "Why have money if people can (and do) steal what they want." Not everyone gets payed off-book, so the current system is (mostly) effective. If there were no draft, then there would be no real club loyalty, and those clubs which could (or were willing) to rort the system would win every premiership, fostering a climate of success that would draw in every other success-driven (as opposed to money-driven) player.

[Guest Dr Who]

Because getting payed off-book is morally wrong. It's like saying "Why have money if people can (and do) steal what they want." Not everyone gets payed off-book, so the current system is (mostly) effective. If there were no draft, then there would be no real club loyalty, and those clubs which could (or were willing) to rort the system would win every premiership, fostering a climate of success that would draw in every other success-driven (as opposed to money-driven) player.

Wouldn't clubs be forced just to treat their employees like they are treated in the real world? Why would there be no "club loyalty"?

Edited April 22, 2012 by Dr Who

[Jordie_tackles 354]

So you support protectionism by the AFL? You support restriction of players being able to choose their own employer from day 1 of their career?

More so that the AFL as a strong competition that people would want to support cannot work without a salary cap, as only 4-6 clubs could truly compete.

Players choosing to play AFL as a profession do so knowing they have a restricted earning capacity. if they are good enough a club will pay them millions, nobody is currently that good though.

[Rogue 585]

You support restriction of players being able to choose their own employer from day 1 of their career?

I do.

[Nasher 33,607]

I had noticed someone on another thread suggesting it -

If you mean my post in the Barry thread, I was taking the piss out of you. This was a crazy idea last time you suggested it and it still is.

[Waltham33 475]

We need the draft, we just need to use it better.

[Guest Dr Who]

If you mean my post in the Barry thread, I was taking the [censored] out of you. This was a crazy idea last time you suggested it and it still is.

I've never suggested to abolish the draft but I do think it needs some more fine tuning. Abolishment of the open pp selection is fantastic. But I do think the new FA laws will help and I'm sure the AFL will further tweak them over coming years.