Top 5

[Guest Gotzy15]

Yes folks it's that time of year. Saw on 'on the couch' tonight that mikes top 50 will be out soon and just saw robbos top 10 on twitter.

For those who like to have a bit of fun and healthy debate let's go top 5 in afl and top 5 at the dees (in order)

For mine:

AFL

1.Franklin

2.Pendlebury

3.Ablett

4.Judd

5.Cox

Dees:

1.Moloney

2.Frawley

3.Trengove

4.Jamar

5.Jones or possibly Mitch Clark

Edited March 5, 2012 by Gotzy15

[Pennant St Dee 13,301]

Yes folks it's that time of year. Saw on 'on the couch' tonight that mikes top 50 will be out soon and just saw robbos top 10 on twitter.

For those who like to have a bit of fun and healthy debate let's go top 5 in afl and top 5 at the dees (in order)

For mine:

AFL

1.Franklin

2.Pendlebury

3.Ablett

4.Cox

5.Stevie J

Dees:

1.Moloney

2.Frawley

3.Trengove

4.Jamar

5.Jones

1) ABLETT

2) PENDLEBURY

3) FRANKLIN

4) JUDD

5) GODDARD

DEES

1) FRAWLEY - MUST STAY FIT

2) JAMAR - AS ABOVE

3) JONES - ON THE UPWARD CURVE

4) SYLVIA - IT'S TIME TO REALISE THE POTENTIAL

5) CLARK - ONE OF THE MISSING PIECES IN THE JIGSAW

Unlucky to miss out TRENGOVE & BEAMER if these guys all have big years and GREEN gets back to 2010 form we make the 8 easily

[Guest Gotzy15]

Which means 3 of my top 4 players in the afl and my number 1 demon were all melbourne supporters as kids. Talented bunch us supporters aren't we??

[Guest Gotzy15]

And yeh pennant st dee just made me realise I should probably have squeezed Sylvia in there somewhere

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

AFL

1. Pendlebury

2. Ablett

3. Franklin

4. Swan

5. Folau. Just kidding... probably Judd

Dees:

1. Frawley

2. Sylvia

3. Clark

4. Jamar

5. Jones

[Dr. Mubutu 866]

AFL:

1. Ablett

2. Franklin

3. Pendlebury

4. Bartel

5. Judd

Dees:

1. Frawley

2. Jamar

3. Sylvia

4. Trengove

5. Moloney

[The Chazz 4,077]

AFL;

1. Ablett

2. Judd

3. Swan

4. Selwood

5. Goodes

Melbourne;

1. Frawley

2. Jamar

3. Moloney

4. Sylvia

5.

I have left number 5 vacant, as I think there are a lot of players that are fighting for that spot, including Trengove, Jones and Garland. I can't put Clark in our top 5 yet.

The 2014 MFC Top 5 could be an interesting list, with players like Howe, Watts, Tapscott, possibly Viney (hoping he may have an impact similar to how Selwood did in his first season or 2 at Geelong), as well as the players mentioned above.

[Jonesbag 487]

AFL

1. FRANKLIN

2 .ABLETT

3. GODDARD

4. JUDD

5. PENDLEBURY

DEES

1. SYLVIA

2. FRAWLEY

3. TRENGOVE

4. MOLONEY

5. GREEN

[Barney Rubble 1,576]

AFL:

1. Ablett

2. Franklin

3. Pendlebury

4. Bartel

5. Judd

Dees:

1. Frawley

2. Jamar

3. Sylvia

4. Trengove

5. Moloney

I think the Good Doctor has nailed it.

He has even realised that Swanny is in his Transition to Retirement stage.

[Mac7 309]

AFL

1. ABLETT

2. FRANKLIN

3. JUDD

4. N. RIEWOLDT

5. J. SELWOOD

DEES

1. MOLONEY

2. JONES

2. FRAWLEY

3. WATTS

5. TRENGOVE

[Hannibal 5,814]

1. Ablett

2. Judd

3. Franklin

4. Scarlett (the best full back I've seen)

5. Pendlebury

-------------------

6. Cloke

7. Selwood

8. Goodes

9. Cox

10. Bartel

Goddard had a poor year.

Frawley

Jamar

----------

Trengove

Sylvia

Moloney

The top 5 I'd like to see by year's end:

Trengove

Frawley

Clark

Watts

Grimes

Edited March 6, 2012 by Ben-Hur

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

AFL

1. Judd

2. Ablett

3. Franklin

4. Pendlebury

5. Selwood

MFC

1. Frawley

2. Jamar.

3. Trengove

4. Garland

5. Sylvia

[Kento80 83]

1. Franklin

2. Judd

3. Ablett

4. Pendlebury

5. Bartel

1. Frawley

2. Moloney

3. Jones

4. Jamar

5. Sylvia

[Guest Jackie]

Since money talks loudest these days, T$ is top of the list. The rest are not worthy.

[Dan Fantastik 50]

Im not sure how anybody cannot have Ablett as number one!

[Eth 4]

AFL:

1. Ablett

2. Franklin

3. Pendlebury

4. Murphy

5. Bartel

Melbourne:

1. Frawley

2. Jamar

3. Jones

4. Trengove

5. Moloney

[Tatu 416]

1. Ablett

2. Swan

3. Judd

4. Pendlebury

5. Franklin

1. Frawley

2. Grimes

3. Jamar

4. Garland

5. Jurrah

[BIG JIM 508]

1. Moloney

2. Jones

3. Grimes

4. Magner

5. Chip sorry only care about the dees but i will say moloney could well be top 5 in the brownlow this year.

[Fork 'em 6,990]

Ablett.

Judd.

Franklin.

Bartel.

Hodge.

And if the game was in the balance and something had to happen .... Bartel would be the man .

[Grandson of a gun 276]

Franklin- Unstoppable when on and can single handedly destroy teams and win games

Ablett- See above

Pendlebury

Judd- Still rate him higher than Murphy because he does it with 3 blokes hanging off his back

Hodge- Another who when he is fit is almost unstoppable

And for the Dees i have tried to go with our top 5 most critical to success:

Jamar

Frawley

Clarke

Sylvia

Moloney

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

Surprising seeing how the reigning Brownlow Medallist makes so few of these lists...

[Grandson of a gun 276]

Surprising seeing how the reigning Brownlow Medallist makes so few of these lists...

Not really.

Johnathon Brown.

Wayne Carey.

No brownlows there but at their peak they had no peer.

Swanny was extremely consistent but if all 5 or 6 of the best were playing at their peak, I believe other players ate ahead of him.

[Disco Demons 92]

For dees to play finals...these guys need to have a good year

Captains...

Grimes

Trengove

Mids

Jamar->Moloney

Jones

Fwds

Clark

Green

Def

Frawley

Garland

Rivers

Utility

Sylvia

Martin

Edited March 6, 2012 by disco_demon

[Dr. Mubutu 866]

Surprising seeing how the reigning Brownlow Medallist makes so few of these lists...

IMO, he gets a lot of the ball, which attracts the umpires' attention, but is far less damaging with it than any of those players mentioned. Very rarely able to change the trajectory of a game off his own back.

[H_T 3,049]

AFL

1. Ablett

2. Swan

3. Pendlebury

4. Judd

5. Selwood

Melbourne

1. Frawley

2. Jamar

3. Jones

4. Grimes

5. Sylvia