The Josh Caddy Thread

[dee-luded 2,958]

Goldcoast had still taken players out of the draft who would have most likely been before 7, matera and May for starters

The draft was labelled weak in comparison to 2012, it may be average

And sorry i was 2 picks off,

Tut Tut, that will never do. Stand in the corner music maestro liurtzy

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

Thought the same thing whilst reading the Bombers interest in him this morning in Sunraysia country on hol's. At that time I didn't know that Clark had done a u-turn. Bit slow up here...

Still, am interested in improving the midfield and Caddy fits the bill IMO. If we're on the improve next season we won't have an early pick (other than Viney) and the compo picks will fall mid to late round. This kid is aggressive and I liked him as a draft prospect last year.

I say go for it. I wonder what GC would want in the way of player(s)....as well as one of our compo picks ?

The club would have to have the front running surely...

Agree.

Someone suggested compo + Warnock + Spencer. That should do. Hell, I'd throw both compo picks and Warnock.

A Caddy/Viney combo in the midfield would be damaging. It's worth throwing all Scully picks at. I'm confident we can land this man after landing Clark.

If we do this we are really going places!

[Fitz Fitzpatrick 886]

I think the club should be careful not to jump at the first kid that's up for trade. One compo pick would be right but no more. The powders dry and there will be plenty to choose from after next season once GWS has blooded them for us!

[Jordie_tackles 354]

Agree.

Someone suggested compo + Warnock + Spencer. That should do. Hell, I'd throw both compo picks and Warnock.

A Caddy/Viney combo in the midfield would be damaging. It's worth throwing all Scully picks at. I'm confident we can land this man after landing Clark.

If we do this we are really going places!

We all want signings but i dont see how this kid can be worth 2 top 15 picks after 2 games?

I seem to be the only one not all over him though, maybe i missed it all

[Fitz Fitzpatrick 886]

No Jordie, I agree. Theres a rush of blood to the head after Clarks signing but Im sure TH will be carefully planning the allocation of these picks. Id like to see the club keep them for next year. After a season of GWS playing their new kids there may emerge some guns that dont want to stay in sydney. as well as the high demand for 1st round picks from other clubs.

[Jordie_tackles 354]

Just ventured to the Goldcoast boards on BF, one of the Brisbane moderators said he was in the know about Caddy, and that Essendon were up to sneaky buggers, of the highest order, this guy doesnt talk crap, and was PMing Suns guys last night around 10, wouldnt post the news. interesting.

[GRUN DEE 69]

We might see the Dee's trade one compo pick + a player for Caddy. Possibly even 36 or 39 (Bate?) also. If we dont, well we will have two super compo picks too keep. Allows us too keep upper hand next season.

I dont think the Bombers can do the deal. But the Tigers could!

[Lutz 76]

Bombers very little chance.

I get the feeling Gold Coast know we're likely to be the only contenders that can offer what they want, or enough, hence their public demand for 2 compensation picks (who else has 2?).

We'd be mugs to hand over the 2 picks for Caddy though.

I also get the feeling that the "sneaky buggers" comment, is the ruse about Caddy's old man's heart condition and the subsequent "need" to go home.

As others have said, if he were that desperate, Caddy would be canvassing all Melbourne clubs, willing to go anywhere to get it done - not aiming for Essendon and having last minute deals scraped together.

It'd also have been very publicly on the radar from day one of trade week.

Although, this is all out of the mouth of the Essendon worshipping Mark Robinson...

[tarzan16 40]

i have it from good authority (and i'm not saying who so don't ask) that he would love to come to the dees, get the deal done please!!!

[hardtack 10,158]

i have it from good authority (and i'm not saying who so don't ask) that he would love to come to the dees, get the deal done please!!!

You don't need to name names... is the "good authority" from within one of the clubs or caddy's management company... if not, then it is hardly any authority at all. If I had a dollar for every post that stated the info was "on good authority", I would have as many dollars as there are posts that say the info is "on good authority".

[beelzebub 22,376]

Also spoke about Suns needing a ruckman. I would offer compo pick, Spencer and Warnock if they want him. That trumps Bombers by a mile unless they throw in star player. Their best pick is 19. That would mean we have replaced the bloke who left with Caddy and another compo pick next year.

GC are going to need to continually bolster stocks for a while yet . Next season they come back to the pack in selections. Mijgth very well appeal. The package deal you suggest holds some water.

[tarzan16 40]

You don't need to name names... is the "good authority" from within one of the clubs or caddy's management company... if not, then it is hardly any authority at all. If I had a dollar for every post that stated the info was "on good authority", I would have as many dollars as there are posts that say the info is "on good authority".

sent u a PM to satify ur reply, maybe think before u post

[hardtack 10,158]

sent u a PM to satify ur reply, maybe think before u post

As you will see in my PM'd response, perhaps you should be taking your own advice.

[Dr. Gonzo 22,641]

So any news on this kid? Is he a chance to go to another Vic club (us, Tigers, North?) or is it Bombers or bust?

[hardtack 10,158]

Hopefully this will be a similar scenario (but cheaper) to that of the Clark signing - the MFC will keep their cards very close to their chest and make a move when it is likely to be most effective; I doubt very much that they are sitting on their hands.

Edited October 17, 2011 by hardtack

[Dr. Gonzo 22,641]

Would love to land this kid but not at any price. Wouldn't want to give up 2 compo picks which has been touted, would rather keep them for next year. 1 compo pick and a player (Warnock, Spencer?) would be a great result.

[Deeoldfart 7,822]

The Bombers now have Gumbleton and Hooker on the table together with pick # 19. Apparently still a long way off meeting GC requirements and the parties are now in mediation.

[dee-luded 2,958]

We all want signings but i dont see how this kid can be worth 2 top 15 picks after 2 games?

I seem to be the only one not all over him though, maybe i missed it all

I think your right Jordie.

May have been caught up in the trading excitement.

He's not proven anything yet, and isn't worth 2 top 15 picks. One pick + steak knives.

[Dr. Gonzo 22,641]

Would we offer anything for Hooker? He's a decent KP defender isn't he? Maybe we could get involved in a 3-way trade. We need someone to take the gorilla forwards/resting ruckman still. Martin may be able to fill that role now that we have Clark up forward but just a thought. If not is there anyone else on Essendon's list we would want who they might give up for a compo pick? (obviously not Hurley, Heppell etc)

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

If we are going to get him it better be quick. I think we will be tied up sorting out bate and warnock.

[IWAP 168]

Emma Quayle:

Essendon and Gold Coast are in mediation at the moment over Caddy. Melbourne I think had made a pitch

[beelzebub 22,376]

If we are going to get him it better be quick. I think we will be tied up sorting out bate and warnock.

Have a sneaking supsicion its all incestuous...and that one affects another and so on.

[beelzebub 22,376]

Emma Quayle:

Essendon and Gold Coast are in mediation at the moment over Caddy. Melbourne I think had made a pitch

I think the Dees are a spanner in the works re Ess and GC..... terrible huh !! lol

[PeterJames 46]

Trade week radio also said we have thrown our hat in!

[Yoda 33]

Hutchy just announced that we're into Caddy late and are definitely having a sniff around.