Trengove suspended for 2 ... now 3 weeks

[Eth 4]

Tinney reading medical report from Adelaide doctor. States that Dangerfield suffered concussion, and was unable to continue playing. His symptoms increased by the end of the game. Report also states that Dangerfield is still having his cognitive function monitored daily.

Load of [censored]. Dangerfield's had so many concussions...the doctors obviously don't know what a headache is.

[Jonesy!!! 27]

"Tinney reading medical report from Adelaide doctor. States that Dangerfield suffered concussion, and was unable to continue playing. His symptoms increased by the end of the game. Report also states that Dangerfield is still having his cognitive function monitored daily."

[censored] off adelaide.. dangerfield better not play footy this weekend if he is as bad as they are trying to make it out to be. they are just [censored] off that they got absolutley BELTED on sunday

[Jack son 5 162]

Unhappy with the medical report from Adelaide doctor.

Just the facts I suppose.

[AllenIsLord13 1]

bad start - we don't even have a Silk! (ie QC!)

oh, and Dangerbrains 'cognitive functions' are still being monitored daily... the dude would get concussion opening the paper!

[RalphiusMaximus 6,088]

Loving our evidence so far.

O'Donnell says Trengove's tackle was shown in the team's match review on Monday as an example of an excellent tackle.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,088]

bad start - we don't even have a Silk! (ie QC!)

oh, and Dangerbrains 'cognitive functions' are still being monitored daily... the dude would get concussion opening the paper!

They don't say that he has suffered any sort of impairment though. Daily monitoring would be a standard part of the treatment for such an injury. They're trying very hard to make it sound worse than it is.

[Eth 4]

Loving our evidence so far.

Yep, O'Donnell might save JT here.

Iain Findlay calls Melbourne assistant coach Kelly O'Donnell to the witness stand. He's giving evidence about how the Demons teach their players to tackle.

O'Donnell says he believes Jack Trengove has near-perfect tackling technique. Chest close to opponent, twisting of the hips and pulling back to affect the opponent's disposal or dispossess.

18:42

O'Donnell says Trengove's tackle was shown in the team's match review on Monday as an example of an excellent tackle.

[Jaded No More 68,974]

Loving our evidence so far.

Our evidence should be "this is no netball, [censored] off".

Ridiculous!

[Jack son 5 162]

Not looking good.

Would love to sling Tinney to the ground!

[Demon_spurs 1,867]

What sort of defense is " we use this all the time at training"? Doesn't make it legal

[RalphiusMaximus 6,088]

Tribunal chairman David Jones asks O'Donnell: 'So, the consequence of the tackle doesn't come into it?'

That's exactly what is wrong with this rule dude. The consequences can't be taken into account.

[Demon_spurs 1,867]

Tinney asks: 'So is your teaching to bring the opponent to the ground with as much force as possible

This is a cheap shot by Tinney

[Jaded No More 68,974]

What sort of defense is " we use this all the time at training"? Doesn't make it legal

It shows that we don't believe it's dangerous to tackle this way or else we wouldn't tackle this way at training, thus risking injury to our own players.

[The Backyard Charizard 1,202]

Tinney asks: 'So is your teaching to bring the opponent to the ground with as much force as possible?

No TinnArse, we teach them to go in half-hearted and hope like all hell that our players don't get injured....

JOKE!

[The Great One 99 125]

Mark Macgugan: Tinney asks: 'So is your teaching to bring the opponent to the ground with as much force as possible?' O'Donnell: no, we teach them to tackle in a way that will dispossess the opponent or affect his disposal. We don't see the technique that we teach as involving undue force.

Maybe Trenners should politely ask Patrick to let go of the ball.....please

[Jordie_tackles 354]

how the F... can you tackle someone these days? cant tackle their legs its tripping, cant go around their arms.... head high etc so you have a 1 foot gap to hit them where it has zero impact on them....and their disposal etc this is a joke

[AllenIsLord13 1]

all this talk about tackling is giving me a concussion - 3 weeks Forums!

[waynewussell 6,241]

Mark Macgugan: Ball highlighting that Dangerfield was in a kicking motion as he was tackled. His leg comes through and misses the ball, which contributes to the momentum with which he falls towards the ground. Trengove also loses his footing, giving him less control as he carries out the tackle.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,088]

Ball also says that Dangerfield did get an arm out on his way down, and both his arm and chest/torso hit the ground before his head did. Doesn't deny that Dangerfield's head hit the ground though.

Thank you! How can they claim he couldn't protect himself when he had an arm free and got it to ground before his head hit?

[waynewussell 6,241]

Mark Macgugan: Ball also says that Dangerfield did get an arm out on his way down, and both his arm and chest/torso hit the ground before his head did. Doesn't deny that Dangerfield's head hit the ground though.

Tuesday May 10, 2011 18:56 Mark Macgugan

[The Backyard Charizard 1,202]

Cracking response to the You Tube video

"Totally worthy of a report. A legitimate tackle these days involves cradling the opposition player in one's strong yet gentle arms, and singing a tender lullaby while carefully lowering him onto some downy soft pillows. So the MRP believes, anyway."

[waynewussell 6,241]

Jack Trengove now taking the witness stand

[The Backyard Charizard 1,202]

Mark Macgugan:

Ball being questioned by Tinney now. Tinney: Dangerfield looked helpless.

I'm sure he meant "Hopeless"

[waynewussell 6,241]

Mark Macgugan: Trengove: As he grabbed the ball, I grabbed his hand. Reason for doing that was to prevent him from handballing. Next thought was he'd then try and kick it. To prevent him from doing that I pulled him back, as taught by the club.

[waynewussell 6,241]

Mark Macgugan: Trengove says he is aware of his duty of care to other players. Doesn't believe he did anything wrong in this tackle. Says he was technically correct, and didn't use excessive force.

Tuesday May 10, 2011 19:01 Mark Macgugan