Last minute deals

[GawnWithTheWind 604]

I think a play for Jesse White is essential. He is perfect for what we need, a big young body to crash packs in our forward line and then go into the ruck for Jamar. I would be willing to give up a fringe player and pick 32 for him.

Say Bate, Warnock, Maric?

I might even be convinced for Bate+Maric+Pick 32..

BTW, Whats happening with Bruce?

[GawnWithTheWind 604]

Just out of interest, who was the last player traded to the Melbourne Football Club during the exchange period?

Could it be Meeson or Pickett?

[jayceebee31 761]

Just out of interest, who was the last player traded to the Melbourne Football Club during the exchange period?

Technically the last trade pick was last year,when we gained pick 11- and got Jordon Gysberts.However, by memory the last player gained trade was Clint Bizzell .Others will correct me if I'm wrong.If memory serves me correct gained Bizzell for picks 2001 - Clint Bizzell to Melbourne for picks #17 (James Kelly) & #41 (Henry Playfair)

The last trade where we lost a player was Travis Johnstone - for pick 14- Jack Grimes in 2007. I think they are the last but I stand to be corrected.

Edited October 10, 2010 by jayceebee31

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

In:

2005 - Byron Pickett and picks #54 Port Adelaide Melbourne Draft Picks #28, #44

Out:

2009 - Brock McLean Carlton for pick 11 (Gysberts)

[reynolds46 1,247]

think it was Meeson

[old55 23,590]

Happy for you to have an opinion, but why wouldn't Sydney buy that deal? We are giving them a 2nd round pick, plus a player that has obvious ability but never given enough opportunity, who was also a number 21 draft pick and is only 20 years old. Plus they have a proven history of being very open at trade time.

Yeah, yeah, while we're at it Sydney could trade us Trent Dennis-Lane and pick 38 for Liam Jurrah - jist as likely.

[old55 23,590]

Warnock for Setanta is worthy of consideration if Setanta could ruck a bit.

[Left Field 313]

Warnock for Setanta is worthy of consideration if Setanta could ruck a bit.

What qualities has Setanta shown you Old? I rate him alongside Minson as a hard hitting heavywieght who seems to do little or no damage with the ball.

[demoniac 1,333]

Warnock for Setanta is worthy of consideration if Setanta could ruck a bit.

Setanta turns 28 next year and his best footy has been played as a mobile non marking tall forward which is really a not quite right position. That'd be a no for me. At best a late pick if Footy Department thinks he can pinch hit as the secnd ruck/utility tall.

Warnock actually plays a position so I think he is of more value than Setanta. If not to others then to us. Perhaps Ol 55 has been getting to friendly with Talking Carlton types!

[old55 23,590]

What qualities has Setanta shown you Old? I rate him alongside Minson as a hard hitting heavywieght who seems to do little or no damage with the ball.

I don't think you could call either of them smart footballers, and although Setanta does have an excuse it doesn't help us. I think Setanta is more of a threat up forward than Will, Minson definitely has far greater rucking creds. I think we're looking for FWD-ruck so that leans me towards Setanta, he doesn't solve #1 ruck depth but that's a different question. I don't think Will really provides much forward threat. I think Setanta gives 100% and he's reasonably agile for his size - well more than Hale or Minson - so he could apply some forward pressure. On the other hand he has some history that questions his mindset. He'd be a big question mark but I think Matthew Warnock is going to rely on injuries to get a game in 2011 and even then is maybe not next selected - he's OOC at the end of 2011 and who could blame him for being off for greater opportunities then?

Demoniac, I haven't been to TC for a while but I might pay them a visit. BTW, it's a long time since our old R.S.F.A days and we still haven't won a flag!

Edited October 10, 2010 by old55

[demoniac 1,333]

rumour and speculation via a bigfooty report off SEN...Cheney off to Hawthorn

[Old Man Rivers 326]

rumour and speculation via a bigfooty report off SEN...Cheney off to Hawthorn

There is also a thread on BIG FOOTY titled

"Jessie White Off To Demons"

Should we get excited yet?

[The Chazz 4,077]

Warnock for Setanta is worthy of consideration if Setanta could ruck a bit.

I'll ask a similar question that you asked me - why would Melbourne give up Warnock for Setanta?

[sylvinator 96]

rumour and speculation via a bigfooty report off SEN...Cheney off to Hawthorn

I like Kyle, but he's not quick enough to take the best small forwards, and he's not skillful enough to be an attacking rebounding defender. Would probably spent next year at vfl level. In terms of medium defenders, he's behind Bartram, J.Macdonald, Grimes and Bruce. Also, guys like Bennel and Bail would be put to half back before Cheney would be put in the team.

It would goodwill by Melbourne to trade him considering he's in contract, but has asked to be traded for more opportunities.

I'm not against it, if we can get a pick in the 50s (considering that's what we originally drafted at).

[Arrow 1,257]

Hawthorn have apparently offered pick 51 for Cheney. Hope he gets a game for them, and i can enjoy him trying to keep up with our fast small forwards with his slow foot.

Hilarious.

[deeflog 679]

Technically the last trade pick was last year,when we gained pick 11- and got Jordon Gysberts.However, by memory the last player gained trade was Clint Bizzell .Others will correct me if I'm wrong.If memory serves me correct gained Bizzell for picks 2001 - Clint Bizzell to Melbourne for picks #17 (James Kelly) & #41 (Henry Playfair)

The last trade where we lost a player was Travis Johnstone - for pick 14- Jack Grimes in 2007. I think they are the last but I stand to be corrected.

Brock McLean wants to know if he has been forgotten that quickly at the MFC?

[old55 23,590]

I'll ask a similar question that you asked me - why would Melbourne give up Warnock for Setanta?

A 26yo who has played 51 games including 13 this year and is currently playing VFL for a 27yo who has played 72 games including 14 this year and is currently playing VFL.

[The Chazz 4,077]

A 26yo who has played 51 games including 13 this year and is currently playing VFL for a 27yo who has played 72 games including 14 this year and is currently playing VFL.

Carlton had no Key Forward this year, Setanta had ample opportunity to step up and make it his own, yet played 14 games?

Warnock's best is up there with any full back in the league, but struggled to get a game toward the end of the season, with his spot taken by an All Australian defender.

Can't really see how this is more realistic than my trade offer for White.

Edited October 10, 2010 by billy2803

[Summer Blease 0]

There is also a thread on BIG FOOTY titled

"Jessie White Off To Demons"

Should we get excited yet?

For free too!! Yeah we should be bloody excited haha

[GawnWithTheWind 604]

But most of the Melbourne guys have left for China, so does this mean no trades will be done today from us?

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Warnock's best is up there with any full back in the league, but struggled to get a game toward the end of the season, with his spot taken by an All Australian defender.

His spot was taken by Rivers and not Frawley.

Warnock is an honest defender whose best footy is capable. It is not up there with the best of any FB in the AFL.

But most of the Melbourne guys have left for China, so does this mean no trades will be done today from us?

Shrewd thinking.

[e25 5]

A mate that works for the age just told me Daniel Kerr to Carlton for something involving Andrew Walker.

Also bombers are chasing Simon Black, offering him a truckload more than Lions?

He's heard nothing involving the dees and doubts a Cheney deal will get done.

We'll see.

I'm not sure either of these deals would get over the line.

Edit: looks like "deep throat" has twittered these deals too.

I'm still skeptical.

Edited October 11, 2010 by E25

[e25 5]

Jay Clark is twittering that the Tarrant to Collingwood deal has been done, with 4 teams involved and swaps of picks & players.

He's short on the detail.

[GawnWithTheWind 604]

Tim Harrington just arrived........

[titan_uranus 25,020]

There's an article out there I just read (can't find the URL for some reason) that also says Tarrant to Collingwood is done.

The whispers are that Carlton is going to land a 'big fish', and there are separate whispers saying Kerr is on the move. Putting two and two together...