my 3 word player analysis V The Tilers

[joeboy 2,993]

Bail - continues to impress

Bartram - reliable disposal again

Bate - continues working hard

Bennell - had little impact

Bruce - prolific but wasteful

Davey - outstanding in spurts

Dunn - getting it together

Frawley - improved second half

Garland - old reliability returning

Green - enjoyed his game

Grimes - the designated rebounder

Jamar - tapwork brilliant again

Jones - great all day

McDonald - superlatives aren't enough

MacDonald - tough and creative

Moloney - racked up possessions

Petterd - always a presence

Scully - creative and aware

Sylvia - outstanding second half

Trengove - some impressive movements

Warnock - was always solid

McKenzie - seemed very composed

Edited April 18, 2010 by joeboy

[Demon16 69]

Frawley - improved second half

very kind, he was owned today.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,000]

Frawley was on Reiwolt?

[John Dee 441]

Bail - continues to impress

Bartram - reliable disposal again

Bate - continues working hard

Bennell - had little impact

Bruce - prolific but wasteful

Davey - outstanding in spurts

Dunn - getting it together

Frawley - improved second half

Garland - old reliability returning

Green - enjoyed his game

Jamar - tapwork brilliant again

Jones - great all day

McDonald - superlatives aren't enough

MacDonald - tough and creative

Moloney - racked up possessions

Petterd - always a presence

Scully - creative and aware

Sylvia - outstanding second half

Trengove - some impressive movements

Warnock - was always solid

McKenzie - seemed very composed

Grimes - invisible but effective

[joeboy 2,993]

Grimes - invisible but effective

Thanks , now rectified

[Bring-Back-Powell 13,641]

Moloney - racked up possessions

Was his report serious? Is he likely to be suspended for 2 or 3 weeks?

[titan_uranus 23,225]

Quite unbelievable how Frawley could go from BOG to having an absolute shocker in 7 days. He was pantsed by Riewoldt. He was holding him when he didn't need to, pushing when he didn't need to, being led to the ball, not spoiling like we know he can.

Odd.

[southparkboy 0]

Was his report serious? Is he likely to be suspended for 2 or 3 weeks?

Watching the replay of it, it didn't hit his head more upper shoulder and neck area personally I think he should get off minimum 1 week

[Geddy Lee 582]

Probably good that Frawley got a big wake up call. He has a very big task next week and must give his all.

[Demon16 69]

Frawley was on Reiwolt?

yep

[Vagg 2,422]

Probably good that Frawley got a big wake up call. He has a very big task next week and must give his all.

Absolutely! We'll need him to stand tall next week against the Brown/Fev show! This week may have reminded him he aint quite invincible just yet...

[Guest Rojik of the Arctic]

Was his report serious? Is he likely to be suspended for 2 or 3 weeks?

Looked like a legit hip and shoulder to me.

[Jaded No More 60,095]

I think Frawley wasn't well today, and there were rumours circulating (as another poster suggested in a separate thread), that one of the defenders was ill coming into the match.

He really couldn't run and he was rotated far more heavily than he usually is.

Edit: Scully- bloody friggin brilliant

Edited April 18, 2010 by Jaded

[titan_uranus 23,225]

I think Frawley wasn't well today, and there were rumours circulating (as another poster suggested in a separate thread), that one of the defenders was ill coming into the match.

He really couldn't run and he was rotated far more heavily than he usually is.

That would explain it. It was just so far removed from the brilliance of last week.

We need him fit and firing if we're any chance vs Brisbane. He and Warnock have a big week ahead of them.

[Guest watts04]

I was one to jump on Trenners as a star but Scullys run will be brilliant

Real test comes next week, especially our backline

Well done to the captain today - awesome

[Adzman 2,086]

Hard to be unhappy with a 55 point win. I think Bailey will go in with the same team against the lions.

Scully- Rising Star Nomination?

[Hannabal 4]

Edit: Scully- bloody friggin brilliant

Some wanted him dropped this week for Newton

You have to love Melb supporters.

[Jaded No More 60,095]

Some wanted him dropped this week for Newton

You have to love Melb supporters.

I don't think anybody wanted him dropped because he was no good.

I certainly think that he let the pressure get to him over the past 3 weeks (giving away poor frees, dropping marks etc), and it was only a matter of time before he started to feel comfortable at this level and dominate. There was never ever a question of talent or application.

Having said that, the best thing we can do to our team is play them and Scully was awesome today, and I'm glad he got to play against poorer opposition to give him the ability to get a lot of the ball and build his confidence going forward. He is awesome.

[Daz's Dee's 113]

Some wanted him dropped this week for Newton

You have to love Melb supporters.

Are you serious?? What is wrong with some people what do they expect brownlow votes or back to the VFL, next they will want to trade Watts!

[rusty_kingswood 0]

I don't think anybody wanted him dropped because he was no good.

I certainly think that he let the pressure get to him over the past 3 weeks (giving away poor frees, dropping marks etc), and it was only a matter of time before he started to feel comfortable at this level and dominate. There was never ever a question of talent or application.

Having said that, the best thing we can do to our team is play them and Scully was awesome today, and I'm glad he got to play against poorer opposition to give him the ability to get a lot of the ball and build his confidence going forward. He is awesome.

As good as he was today. the same mistakes were still there. I am NOT one for dropping him, but I think a week or two in the 2s isnt too far off. Its only healthy.

[Felix 92]

Bartram - reliable disposal again

Bruce - prolific but wasteful

Frawley - improved second half

Bartram was crap today, Bruce [censored] me off, Frawley had a bad game compared to his last few.

Quite unbelievable how Frawley could go from BOG to having an absolute shocker in 7 days. He was pantsed by Riewoldt. He was holding him when he didn't need to, pushing when he didn't need to, being led to the ball, not spoiling like we know he can.

Odd.

Going to be difficult against Brown or Fev next week.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Bail - Looks very classy

Bartram - Solid performance

Bate - Finding form

Bennell - Quiet but useful

Bruce - Should be dropped

Davey - Solid performance

Dunn - Looks good forward

Frawley - Well beaten

Garland - Solid performance

Green - Looks great forward

Grimes - Great overhead marking

Jamar - Red hot form

Jones - Surprisingly classy performance

McDonald - Very good again

Macdonald - Becoming very important

Moloney - Sublime kicking skills

Petterd - Great hands

Scully - Best game yet

Sylvia - Brilliant kicking skills

Trengove - Showing positive signs

Warnock - Solid performance

McKenzie - Quiet game

[Hannabal 4]

As good as he was today. the same mistakes were still there.

Expand on those mistakes you saw today.

[45HG 1,539]

I thought Jones was very good today, which was nice to see.

I was shocked to see Moloney had 37 touches! Scully's handballing is amazing.

[rusty_kingswood 0]

Ill try H.

There were a number of occasions were he was caught with the ball stupidly. Some of his disposals today weren't fantastic, and put other under pressure.

Last week he did the same, the only difference was, it wasn't his fault. He found space (allot) but because no one was forward of the ball, or team mates were too flat footed, he got caught, and it made him look bad.

I am not out to hang the guy, he's played 4 pretty amazing games. All i am saying id that a week or 2 in the 2's certainly wouldn't hurt. Trengove will need to, as well soon. There young kids.

Having said that, it as by far his best game for the Dees, and he has taken a step forward. But a break probably isn't far off.

Edited April 18, 2010 by rusty_kingswood