Jamar and Rivers gone

[Guest Trade tracker]

I will only say this once.

Jamar and Rivers are off to Port Adelaide.

In return pick 8 and Justin Westhoff, you can expect an annoucement as soon as tonight or tomorrow morning. This is locked.

I hear Everitt is coming to Melbourne for pick 18 which looks certain to happen but I can't comfirm this one.

Edited October 3, 2009 by Trade tracker

[Roost It 1,434]

[censored], it's all happening

[... 11]

Hell of a first post.

[Old Gregg 1]

I'll wait for official confirmation before I take it from a first poster.....no offence mate

[PRIME 41]

I dont believe Rivers will be going he is highly rated at melbourne and finally got a full year under his belt he is much more pivotal to melbournes defence than most people give him but we will soon find out. I have no idea about the Everett trade but i dont want him at Melbourne.

[LeBron James 41]

Yeah - I doubt it.

I wouldn't mind if it was true though.

[Guest Trade tracker]

I should add that please post sensibily and do not blast me. Just wait for the announcement before you judge. I will be here for 6 more days.

[Diablo Deemon 220]

Couldn't find somewhere for Juice, Barty or Miller to go first?

[Grand New Flag 3,226]

Trade tracker: If this is true, and you have pulled this off you will be in a league of your own. To this date every first poster that has made a massive call, or declared rumour fact on their first post has turned out to be bullshiit.

We will wait and see but your trade sounds fair, though I would also be suprised if we traded our only good ruckman and our general of the back line. This trade would create two holes in a list that already has many missing pieces.

I give this a 10% chance of being true. I will take my hat off to you if it proves otherwise.

Edited October 3, 2009 by Grand New Flag

[Guest Watts=Saviour]

Can someone fill me in on Westhoff? I know bugger-all about him.

[45HG 1,539]

Where do I sign?

[Luck Lucy 0]

I will only say this once.

Jamar and Rivers are off to Port Adelaide.

In return pick 9 and Justin Westhoff, you can expect an annoucement as soon as tonight or tomorrow morning. This is locked.

I hear Everitt is coming to Melbourne for pick 18 which looks certain to happen but I can't comfirm this one.

Funny. I was just wondering the other day whatever happened to Chilliboy?

[Jaded No More 58,976]

We've gone a bit nuts with trades, haven't we?

It wouldn't surprise me if Rivers asked for a trade, especially now that his best mate has left the club. But can we please not get Justin Westhoff?!

This is surely a conspiracy to get rid of all my favourite players!

[MadAsHell 4,089]

First off, I don't believe it until I see it.

Secondly, no thankyou!

Thirdly, I doubt it. Both Rivers and Jamar are required and Melbourne wouldn't trade them unless they requested to be traded.

[fredblackham 17]

Stop knocking rookie posters.

Liam Jurrah was a rookie player this year - do you trust that he will be the future of the MFC forward line?

[Diablo Deemon 220]

Who's paying out Westhoff's contract he's tied to port till 2011.

[cooko 124]

I dont believe Rivers will be going he is highly rated at melbourne and finally got a full year under his belt he is much more pivotal to melbournes defence than most people give him but we will soon find out. I have no idea about the Everett trade but i dont want him at Melbourne.

isnt Andrejs Everitt supposed to be a highly rated young ruckman? wouldnt he be handy? or is he overrated? i dont know much about him

[titan_uranus 22,731]

Flaw number 1: Port Adelaide does not possess Pick 9. They have pick 8.

Flaw number 2: Melbourne would never agree to this. Westhoff is an over-rated piece of crap.

[Ryan Dee 140]

We've gone a bit nuts with trades, haven't we?

It wouldn't surprise me if Rivers asked for a trade, especially now that his best mate has left the club. But can we please not get Justin Westhoff?!

This is surely a conspiracy to get rid of all my favourite players!

7000 post and 4 years on here and you still believe this sort of thing? Poor shot on Rivers' character as well.

As much as I wouldn't mind seeing Jamar go for something decent there is NO WAY MFC would let Jarred Rivers go. Demonlanders use some basic logic.

I admit I am a gullible person but not Jamar and Rivers, including that a senior player in Mclean has already gone this is just crap.

Edited October 3, 2009 by Mr Morton

[Jaded No More 58,976]

Flaw number 1: Port Adelaide does not possess Pick 9. They have pick 8.

Flaw number 2: Melbourne would never agree to this. Westhoff is an over-rated piece of crap.

Port will be getting pick 9 from Hawthorn for Burgoyne, and are desperate for a ruckman. I definitely think they'll trade that pick on in order to acquire one.

Westhoff is indeed an over-rated piece of poo, and does not somehow balance the deal out. Pick 9 for Rivers or for Jamar is fine, pick 9 for both requires something extra from Port, hopefully their second round pick or a decent player!

7000 post and 4 years on here and you still believe this sort of thing? Poor shot on Rivers' character as well.

Never said I believed it, but it's definitely not the most ridiculous trade rumour that has been posted on here.

It is probably a load of crap, but there is nothing better to discuss at the moment.

[flog 20]

I should add that please post sensibily and do not blast me. Just wait for the announcement before you judge. I will be here for 6 more days.

Ok, you sound confident so i will believe you for now. 4 picks in the top 11 sounds pretty good to me. 3 mids and a tall. Everitt is a defender or thats were i have seen him play so would take the spot of rivers. Jamar is no loss, im sure we can find a ruckman in the next year or two when were challenging, they seem to swap clubs all the time.

[Ryan Dee 140]

Never said I believed it, but it's definitely not the most ridiculous trade rumour that has been posted on here.

It is probably a load of crap, but there is nothing better to discuss at the moment.

Good point, but still I would bet all of this weeks AUSTUDY money that it is not true.

[demoniac 1,243]

No deal for mine.

Jamar has finally started to show frm in the ruck and his departure would leave us with ruck stocks of Meeson and Spencer.

Rivers has finally got his body right and is an important player down back.

Justin Westhoof is basically a skinny 198cm half forward, nowhere near a genuine key position player. we have planty of mid forwards.

[WonnaJurah 5]

didnt Mcnamara want to go SA,Swap him with Rivers

[Diablo Deemon 220]

Or we could throw Trengove in as well.

Jamar, Rivers and Trengove

4

Make believe