ROBERTSON DAMNS DEMONS

Sorry Robbo but that's the club's direction and Dean Bailey was just being honest with you.

Robbo should just leave gracefully and not air his dirty stuff.

Loved him dearly, but he is past his peak and appeared to be playing more for himself than for his team/mates/supporters.

At best he may be a hole plugger at another club.

Good luck Robbo, but dont pot us, please.

I avoided posting to the 'Farewell Robbo post' mainly because he lost me some years ago when he became a 'one trick pony', spending more time the ground (following another speccy attempt) than on his feet chasing.

Slagging the club that gave you the opportunity to play footy at the highest level serves no purpose Russell :angry: .

Any player that is forced to retire when they believe they still has something to offer will be upset. Robbo made some valid points, our forward line next year will be very inexperienced, but unfortunately for Robbo we need to get games into these guys and whilst I agree with him he could have offered something to our young forwards we need these young forwards to play together so they learn how to play together. From a recent DB Article he mentioned that was his goal to get our younger players to play 18-20 games together so the learn a bit about each other.

Robbo has been great, but he didn't help himself on a few occasions with body language and his lack of defensive pressure which saw him dropped a couple of times. In a year that you know could be your last at the club you just have do what the coach wants you to done, not what you have always done in the past.

I'm sure he would of had a few good things to say about the club, but nobody wants to read that.

Good luck Robbo I hope you do continue to play somewhere, you have given us over a decade of exciting football.

It's disappointing that Robbo's apparent chip on the shoulder is blinding his vision of where the Melbourne Footy Club is heading, and how he might have contributed. I enjoyed Robbo greatly in his heyday, and wish him well in whatever lays ahead of him, but IMO, if he had remained at Melbourne, he would have been 'teaching' the youngsers at least as many bad habits as he would good ones.

It's disappointing that Robbo's apparent chip on the shoulder is blinding his vision of where the Melbourne Footy Club is heading, and how he might have contributed. I enjoyed Robbo greatly in his heyday, and wish him well in whatever lays ahead of him, but IMO, if he had remained at Melbourne, he would have been 'teaching' the youngsers at least as many bad habits as he would good ones.

Exactly ... as my boss would say... "he just doesn't get it."

How could he not still teach Jurrah and co.

This is disappointing, but unfortunately not unexpected. He should be thankful for all the club gave him and listen to his own words in his parting speech.

If Robbo thinks he got the boot cause he's old he is sadly mistaken. McDonald is 3 years older and still on the list how can he explain that? He's an I man not a team man and this article vindicates it that is why he is no longer on the list. Pull your head in Robbo these comments don't do you or the club any good.

So what would he teach Jurrah et al? How not to man up or apply forward pressure? How to snap for goal when there's a team option open? How to flop around on the ground after a failed marking attempt? How to feign injury so as not to have to chase?

Some are over reacting to the article.

The only part I didn't hear when Robbo retired was this:

It's Robertson's view that the failure is not the making of coach Dean Bailey.

"It was a club and an organisation decision, they drew a line in the sand and said we have to build for the future.

"I do believe that Dean had pressure coming from all corners, but he would have loved for me to stay.

The rest he's said before.

What the hell?

"Robbo has a sook"!

You're saying this like he is Chris Judd or something.

Open your eyes, he's one of the best players to ever put on the red and blue.

Well said Doc

Must admit I shed a tear on the day he walked off the MCG in the red and blue for the last time, but now I think good riddance. Might just be sour grapes that he knows he will miss out on winning a premiership with the MFC. Really disappointing to see him keep rehashing this topic. Missing the limelight much?

I wonder if any of the offers he's received are from actual AFL clubs.

If Robbo is unhappy with the way he's been treated, and he thinks that the most sensible and mature way to deal with it is to go to the media and slag off the club, then that's disappointing, but it's his prerogative. But he really, really should not be airing details about football operations matters -i.e. by publicly suggesting that Dean Bailey is basically a lame duck, who is having list management decisions made for him by the board and the football operations department, which is what he seems to be inferring, even if he doesnt realize it. It really is poor form, and potentially damaging to the club.

Edited September 14, 200916 yr by two sheds jackson

A bit of sour grapes from Robbo. Understandably he may be a bit upset that the wasn't a spot for him for the future and he's been a great servant to the club, but I back the decision to move him on and look to the future. I think he needs to accept this decision.

And Robbo, you don't need to teach Jurrah anything. Let him do his thing!

<_<

I was hoping this wouldn't happen but I knew he would do this sooner or later. Similar to what Jeff White did on twitter :angry:

The part about teaching Jurrah new tricks was ridiculous. He's already got more tricks than Robbo ever had and why would Bails and co. want him teaching our forwards not to chase and tackle and do the team things. He's delusional if he thinks a club will pick him up.

This is the type of culture that i am glad bailey is getting rid.

These players are mediocre players who never won a premiership, they had there time they failed see ya later

I was expecting worse when I read the article. He's said nothing inflammatory there. He disagrees with an all-encompassing youth policy. I see nothing wrong with that.

I don't agree, but I don't think he's damaged anyone's reputations at all.

Some are over reacting to the article.

Yes. There are a lot of hypersensitive posters here.

Anyone who's seen the short video of his retirement speech to the group couldn't seriously doubt Robbo's respect for the club or not see that he's a fairly level headed man.

He thinks there's a potential danger in an all-encompassing youth push, has just lost his job and still feels like he has something to offer. I thought what he said in the article is neither surprising nor in the least bit inflammatory.

There are a lot of over-zealous people round here.

Edited September 15, 200916 yr by Ho Chi Dee

yet mcdonald, a man who turns 33 next year, i think, continues on.

robbo it's not about age, it's about character, and building the right culture. of all the blokes bailey has let go, or cut short, how many of them have that hard edge to them, that never say die attitude.

White, Yze and Robbo all were heroic when things were going well. I dont want to slag off players, but it's clear Bailey is building a culture, not just ditching blokes because they are old. Otherwise McDonald would have gone 2 years ago.

To those who seem to think Robbo has not said anything negative.............please read and COMPREHEND what he said and clearly meant.

I also gave up local footy when I could no longer do things I had done in earlier years. I didn't pot my ex club though.

It wasn't just his speech to the players, it was what he told Bigpond Sport in an interview.

I wouldn't think all his ex team mates, coaches and management would be loving what he said in this interview.

He loves attention and got it for over 10 years, it's not the clubs fault he wouldn't chase and now cant help his former team mates out anymore.

Robbo, go and end your career in a lower comp where every mark that you attempt can be a speccy. In that level leave the chasing and pressure up to others!!! It may not be an issue there. You'd probably enjoy it.

There has been a bit of a culture of accepting mediocrity but our new regime wont accept this anymore.

I for one am ,sick of under achievement and love what is happening around the club. Anyone not prepared to do the team thing, every time, will find a consequence happens to them.

For those interested in developing a successful on ground team, this is the ONLY way to go.

Our club's actual existence was severely challenged and now this culture of playing pretty football is DEAD.

Our only recipe for eventual euphoria is to do the hard work on an ongoing basis....always.

Robbo was spectacular and a great entertainer, he is now past playing at this level, period!!

This is THE MELBOURNE DEMONS FOOTBALL CLUB, not the pink butterfly admiration society.

Now lets get on with working respect back into the Demons.

Yes. There are a lot of hypersensitive posters here.

Anyone who's seen the short video of his retirement speech to the group could seriously doubt Robbo's respect for the club or not see that he's a fairly level headed man.

He thinks there's a potential danger in an all-encompassing youth push, has just lost his job and still feels like he has something to offer. I thought what he said in the article is neither surprising nor in the least bit inflammatory.

There are a lot of over-zealous people round here.

Agree.

It's disappointing that Robbo's apparent chip on the shoulder is blinding his vision of where the Melbourne Footy Club is heading, and how he might have contributed. I enjoyed Robbo greatly in his heyday, and wish him well in whatever lays ahead of him, but IMO, if he had remained at Melbourne, he would have been 'teaching' the youngsers at least as many bad habits as he would good ones.

Fair assessment.

....

Storm in a teacup. Get over it.

Good audition for a special comments role in the media, I reckon. He needs to show potential employers that he's got an opinion and he's willing to air it. Good on him.

As for the content of his interview, I've got no problem with what he said at all. His comments were frank and measured and he's entitled to some disappointment.

Edited September 14, 200916 yr by MikeyJ