Bennell or Jetta

[Bring-Back-Powell 15,257]

To those who saw our praccy game V's Sydney and Bulldogs, what are your thoughts and opinions on these 2 boys.

What did you like about them?

What do they need to work on?

What positions did they mostly play?

Is one more ready than the other?

Have a feeling one of these 2 boys will be selected tonight due to a few injuries.

Feedback appreciated as these 2 guys are hopefully going to be 10 year excitement machines for the club!

[Guest petjud]

Hello,

Have watched both of them four times already and spoken to them twice.

They are two completely different players which is good.

Bennell is the silky smooth (as in Andrew McLeod mode, no I am not comparing him), knows where to go and seems to have time and has already thought through what he is going to do before he does it. Good kicking skills

Jetta is more the Byron Pickett model, tough, loves the hard stuff with moments of extraordinary brilliance, knows exactly where the goals are.

Benell has been played down back across the half back line and in the pocket. (DB says he can play anywhere)

Jetta has been up forward (DB seems him as a midfielder/goal kicking forward)

Not sure what 'AFL ready' means, nobody knows that until they are out on the field, both could do with a bit more size, but neither would disgrace if they made their debut tonight.

DB has namechecked Jetta as pushing for selection, but you never know ever before the first game of the season how many smokescreens are being put up.

(away from the topic slightly I think Meesen will be picked tonight, and if he fails then the possie is Spencers from then on)

When I spoke to both, Bennell was the same, smooth, thanked me for my best wishes for his future, Jetta stuck his chest out and said 'you looking forward to a bit of excitement!

[montasaurus 0]

bennell has a real up and under kick and IMO ATM is a week link across half back. Pro's-gets plenty of the ball and seems to do a job.

Jetta is polished and looks snr standard for mine.

[The Emblem 1]

bennell has a real up and under kick and IMO ATM is a week link across half back. Pro's-gets plenty of the ball and seems to do a job.

Jetta is polished and looks snr standard for mine.

Both have the "X" factor

IMO Bennell is an elegant footballer, Jetta is a more the gritty type

[H_T 3,049]

I think Jetta is closer.

[Hannabal 4]

Jetta

[torpedo 33]

From what I've seen Bennell is further ahead in development, seems very poised and settled out there playing as a reliable small back, he has to compete with the likes of Whelan, Cheney & Grimes to get a spot in a solid defence though.

Jetta plays forward and our forward line is rubbish, so due to this I think Jetta will get his opportunity first. I like Jetta, looks an exciting player, but from what I've seen he is neither the size nor style of player to ever be an AFL midfielder.

[JJJ 1,333]

Jetta is closer to playing for 2 reasons.

1. He plays in an area of the ground which we are deficient (injuries and lack of depth). IE the forward line.

2. He is physically bigger and stronger and looks like he could cop the punishment.

For mine, Bennell is a better prospect long term but he will take a while to fill out from the looks of him. His comment in the Melbourne Magazine about adding only 2 more kilos is laughable. He is pretty fearless in my eyes but he bounced off a couple of Doggies players a couple of weeks ago.

[titan_uranus 25,176]

There's an article in The Age today about these two; I can't find it online.

Both of them have put on a couple of kgs since they joined us. From the article it would seem that Jetta will debut first, possibly this week. Bennell seems to think he'll need time at Casey before he gets a game (he's being groomed as a half-back flanker).

[e25 5]

Jetta is closer to playing for 2 reasons.

1. He plays in an area of the ground which we are deficient (injuries and lack of depth). IE the forward line.

2. He is physically bigger and stronger and looks like he could cop the punishment.

For mine, Bennell is a better prospect long term but he will take a while to fill out from the looks of him. His comment in the Melbourne Magazine about adding only 2 more kilos is laughable. He is pretty fearless in my eyes but he bounced off a couple of Doggies players a couple of weeks ago.

That entire post is 100% spot on.

[The Wrecker 4]

Yeah, Jetta for mine.

Looks strong enough to play at the top level and we need some excitment in our somewhat "noname" forward line. Although I too was very impressed with Bennell against the Doggies. Will be a future star for the Demons if he continues his development.

[dee-luded 2,959]

Toss a coin, but Jetta's more aggressive persona probably gives him an advantage to take on any apprehensiveness.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,103]

From the two times i've seen them play, I think that Bennell is perhaps a classier player, but Jetta is the most likely to be playing. Basically because there is more room in the team for a small forward than for a half back flank.

[Freddy Fuschia 764]

Bennell or Jetta, Who's closer to AFL standard at the moment?

A dead heat!

[stevenDEMON 0]

i think they are both in. if the teams in the HUN are correct.

Oh and just a small tip don't buy a horse