Rumour going down

[sylvinator 96]

i would 100% say Ryan Murphey is worth pick11...

the player we pick up at 11 would NOT be, Kruiser,cotchin,morton,ebert,masten,henderson,Rance or Mcenvoy...that means we'll be left to pick up the next best midfielder or key position.

ryan murphey is ready to take the competition by storm. he is big, strong and a great kick. AND YOUNG

he will slot straight into CHF which is a massive hole in our team.

that leaves Murphey, Newton, Bate and even Dunn as some seriously good big forwards to take over Neitz who has only 1 season left in him...

people should also remember that we will be getting Meeson for a 3rd rounder, which is an absolute steal. all things equal, Meeson would ussually be worth around pick 21 (a young, talented ruckman drafted at pick 8 only a couple of years ago). so with that steal, we can afford to give up a little more to gain Murphey~

GET MURPHY TO MFC!!!!

trapper is definitely worth sacrifising. he is 27 turning 28, and is a perenial underachiever.

id prefer to start our next generation without him there.

then also we can use pick 4 on Morton, Ebert, Palmer or Cotchin, who will all turn out to be gun midfielders replacing Trapper

[CURTIS 0]

tj past it is rubbish!

that has been made up and will never happen! didnt even bother reading after the first paragraph!

our only trade will prob be to get meeson and trade caroll!

[45HG 1,539]

why would the crows want to lose two ruckmen for picks 43 and 53?

[Goodvibes 3,596]

why would the crows want to lose two ruckmen for picks 43 and 53?

They don't but they may not have much choice.

[beelzebub 23,351]

It may not be Trappers choice in the end. Or am I misinformed ?

[titan_uranus 25,014]

Sydney

Gain: Travis Johnstone, Brad Miller, pick 36

Lose: Pick 11, pick 43

They are the winners here - getting Trapper and a KPP for Pick 11, and bettering their pick 43 with 36.

[Freak 100]

on the flip side. Miller is a disadvantage and TJ is over the hill.

[Goodvibes 3,596]

on the flip side. Miller is a disadvantage and TJ is over the hill.

You can say many things about TJ but suggesting at 27 going on 28 that he's over the hill is a little unfair - not only to TJ but to any of the Demonlanders who find themselves over the age of 30!

[Demon2 58]

Fremantle will then on-trade this pick 11, as well as their own pick 7 to lure jed adcock to the dockers

hahahha jed adcock is good but if carlton are not prepared to give two first rounders for Judd.....i don't think freo will give them up for adcock...

don't people look at the feaability of trades??

don't get me wrong i love a bit of rumour mongering i love the rumours that come up during trade week....but at least make them somewhat believable

[Freak 100]

ummm, there is a hell of a big difference between picks 1 and 3 and pick 7 and 11. Nathan Thompson, Brad Ottens acheived two first round picks and Jed Adcock is no exception. Carlton would be prepared to offer 2 first round picks(provided it wasnt their number 1 pick)..but they dont have another pick between 5 and 15 which would help them out.

[Jerry Lundergard 420]

Can someone please explain to me the difference between an inconsistent foward stuggling to get a run in the firsts for a team that didn't make the finals, who we are going to trade with TJ for Pick 11. To another inconsistent foward who is struggling to get a run in the firsts for a team that didn't make the finals who we are going to receive for pick 11.

Am i missing something. If Ryan Murphy is as good as everyone is saying he is, shouldn't he have been playing and contributing in the Dockers team all year? Was he injured? Or do we think he is better than he is because of last year's final against us? And if that's the case we may as well keep Miller, or trade him outright for pick 11 if we are only getting a similar player in return.

[jacey 333]

Can someone please explain to me the difference between an inconsistent foward stuggling to get a run in the firsts for a team that didn't make the finals, who we are going to trade with TJ for Pick 11. To another inconsistent foward who is struggling to get a run in the firsts for a team that didn't make the finals who we are going to receive for pick 11.

Am i missing something. If Ryan Murphy is as good as everyone is saying he is, shouldn't he have been playing and contributing in the Dockers team all year? Was he injured? Or do we think he is better than he is because of last year's final against us? And if that's the case we may as well keep Miller, or trade him outright for pick 11 if we are only getting a similar player in return.

I'm with u on this one. Is Ryan Murphy that good?

ppl have being saying Pav and Tarrant's keeping him out but if his that good, shouldn't he be tearing it up on the third defender.

Then they want him to come to MFC to lead our attack which in theory will draw the number 1 defender.

If he struggles with the third defender, good luck beating the number one defenders.

btw don't think his a dud but def. not the superstar everyone here makes him out to be. Pick 11.

[barpen 0]

i dont think murphy is worth pick 11.

to have only played 7 matches in 2007 does not justify 1st round pick

3rd rounder at most- could be a good pick up for that

[Gorgoroth 12,947]

Don't forget connolly was coaching.

[Demon16 69]

anyone who thinks murphy is not worth pick 11 should have a look at freo's history of trading away gun players. how much were peter bell and james clement giving to freo before they traded them? maybe it's the clubs inability to develop youth thats the problem, not the ability of the player. murphy is a damn good footballer and was a high pick in the draft, he's definately worth pick 11 and if he's on the market freo would want nothing less. as for brad miller........

[Slartibartfast 17,262]

Can someone please explain to me

I very much doubt it Jerry.

[Yencks 8]

to reply to the post, im quite happy with that. is murphy better than pick 11, time might tell. however, im a little dissapointed alwyn isnt on the cards

[Red and Blue Flame 186]

alwyn isn't?? how do you?

[Old Man Rivers 326]

to reply to the post, im quite happy with that. is murphy better than pick 11, time might tell. however, im a little dissapointed alwyn isnt on the cards

Losing Miller is a must.

Losing Trapper is stupidity, he is one of the only blokes that can spot a target in heavy traffic.

Like Ottens this year for The Cats he is going to click big time eventually & contribute massively towards a flag.

We have invested a decade already & Dean Bailey might just be the Trigger to consistency for Trapper.

Don't do It CAC, I have visions of Trapper winning a Norm Smith in Red & Blue.

[Red and Blue Flame 186]

gee he better click soon mate...drafted back in 97

[Demon16 69]

I very much doubt it Jerry.

you don't seriously need to know the difference between murphy and miller. surely.

[rolling fog 1,207]

Doubt whether CAC1963 would allow the club to get screwed over like that.

So true - reckless endangerment

[titan_uranus 25,014]

Losing Miller is a must.

Losing Trapper is stupidity, he is one of the only blokes that can spot a target in heavy traffic.

Like Ottens this year for The Cats he is going to click big time eventually & contribute massively towards a flag.

We have invested a decade already & Dean Bailey might just be the Trigger to consistency for Trapper.

Don't do It CAC, I have visions of Trapper winning a Norm Smith in Red & Blue.

Quite right you are. However we have invested 5 or so years in Miller, maybe Bailey will get something out of him too?

[kramer 0]

did we come out in front????

[Bruce Almighty 0]

Okay, Firstly, The blues would not give up Marc Murphy for anything, he didnt want to play for brisbane when they could of got him father/son so what makes you think he would want to now. Secondly, if Symes can't get game time for port how is he gonna get game time for geelong considering there star studded line up. And what do the eagles get out of all this???? they lose judd and end up with nothing, i think not! And also why does everyone want to trade Johnstone and Miller, i think they can both really start to perform well if they work hard in the off season and i think the new coaching staff will get that out of them. As for your source i dont think it is a very reliable one.

Peace!