I havent started one of these threads for a few years but we have a positive ledger so couldnt help myself.

Votes Player (Club)

8 Harris Andrews (BL)

8 Kade Chandler (MELB)

8 Harvey Langford (MELB)

3 Lachie Neale (BL)

2 Charlie Cameron (BL)

1 Kysaiah Pickett (MELB)

Assume Andrews gets 4,4 from the coaches and Chin/Langford get the 5,3 for either Fagan or Kingy

Neale with the 2,1 and Charlie with the other 2 and Kozzy with the other 1.

Pity Gawny was left out but i think he would have been next in line.

Edited April 20Apr 20 by GS_1905

Hard to argue with those votes

Great to see the young blokes dominating games

Ed Langdon is stiff but agree Chandler and Langdford hard to split as BOG for us.

Edited April 20Apr 20 by chook fowler

Given it was only a 2pt win, totally fair. Andrews was good.

I also struggled with BOG, but for me it was Chandler by a chin over Langford

I'll see myself out.

Both coaches very fair.👍

6 Chin

5 Disco

4 Langford

3 Lingers

1 Mihocek

1 Rooh

1 Howes

Edited April 20Apr 20 by Demon Dynasty

In the (unlikely) event that I’m being completely unbiased, that’s probably close to how I would have awarded votes.

With my red and blue glasses on (but slightly out of focus), I would have had Tholstrup or Lingers ahead of Cameron.

1 hour ago, Red But Mostly Blue said:

Given it was only a 2pt win, totally fair. Andrews was good.

I also struggled with BOG, but for me it was Chandler by a chin over Langford

I'll see myself out.

1 hour ago, Red But Mostly Blue said:

for me it was Chandler by a chin over Langford

I love chin so much I've got two of them.

Very fair votes. Langdon was better than Pickett imv but beauty is in the eye of the beholder. It breaks Gawn's streak of 10 consecutive games polling coaches votes. Very happy for Chandler and Langford and Harris Andrews is an absolute champion of the game and without him Brisbane lose that game by 5 goals.

Gawn was still very good but was not in our very top few, and we got the win over a quality opponent playing well.

The future we can hope for in 2027-28.

1 hour ago, Red But Mostly Blue said:

Given it was only a 2pt win, totally fair. Andrews was good.

I also struggled with BOG, but for me it was Chandler by a chin over Langford

I'll see myself out.

I called them jawdraw.

(Nice out here, innit RBMB)

Edited April 20Apr 20 by Timothy Reddan-A'Blew

Melbourne v Brisbane

8 Harris Andrews (BL)
8 Kade Chandler (MELB)
8 Harvey Langford (MELB)
3 Lachie Neale (BL)
2 Charlie Cameron (BL)
1 Kysaiah Pickett (MELB)

King. 5 Langford. 4 Chandler 3 Andrews 2 Neale 1 Pickett

Fagan. 5 Andrews 4 Chandler 3 Langford 2 Cameron 1 Neale

3 hours ago, Swooper1987 said:

Very fair votes. Langdon was better than Pickett imv but beauty is in the eye of the beholder. It breaks Gawn's streak of 10 consecutive games polling coaches votes. Very happy for Chandler and Langford and Harris Andrews is an absolute champion of the game and without him Brisbane lose that game by 5 goals.

Harris Andrews certainly is a key to their defence - though our guys upfield did help his cause by insisting on passing straight to him 🙄

Carlton v Collingwood

10 Nick Daicos (COLL)
6 Oliver Florent (CARL)
4 Jamie Elliott (COLL)
3 Patrick Lipinski (COLL)
3 Harry Perryman (COLL)
2 Sam Walsh (CARL)
2 Darcy Cameron (COLL)

Craig McRae. He’s the new Chris Scott. Pies barely beat the Blues. Barely!!

McRae votes : N Daicos 5, Elliott 4, Perryman /Lipinski 3, Florent 2, Cameron

Voss: N Daicos 5, Florent 4, Perryman/Lipinski 3, Walsh 2, Cameron 1

@spirit of norm smith are you just guessing how each coach voted?

2 hours ago, Demonstone said:

@spirit of norm smith are you just guessing how each coach voted?

Are we guessing it was the coaches?

Wonder if Voss made it a priority with all that was going on last Friday night.

18 hours ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Melbourne v Brisbane

8 Harris Andrews (BL)
8 Kade Chandler (MELB)
8 Harvey Langford (MELB)
3 Lachie Neale (BL)
2 Charlie Cameron (BL)
1 Kysaiah Pickett (MELB)

King. 5 Langford. 4 Chandler 3 Andrews 2 Neale 1 Pickett

Fagan. 5 Andrews 4 Chandler 3 Langford 2 Cameron 1 Neale

i actually think both coaches gave 4 votes to harris. The 5 was where they were undecided.

4 hours ago, Demonstone said:

@spirit of norm smith are you just guessing how each coach voted?

I don’t understand the assumption by some / many that coaches give votes to their own players. I’m inclined to think the reverse is true, and they judge their own players more harshly than the opposition.