Oliver Trade Rumours

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,602]

30 minutes ago, Undeeterred said:

It’s incredible how much the media drive the narrative to the point where marginal possibilities become self fulfilling prophecies 

Reminds me of the time Todd Viney came out to rule out that we had approached Luke Parker before saying that once they did tell Sydney they were not the source of the story, they decided they may as well ask the question...

[whatwhat say what 22,933]

1 minute ago, Mel Bourne said:

There are always exceptions to the rule. Nesbitt is clearly a one-club person whose dedication comes from a profound connection. Pert is - as it would seem - a professional “AFL” CEO who we imported from a cultural wasteland. 

i guess - no different to greg swann or brian cook or benny gale or craig vozzo etc

pert had 10 years at the filth for a decade after being the ceo of austereo and then in a senior exec position at channel 9

under his tenure they rose, won a premiership, fell again - but were one of the two or three most powerful and successful off-field sides in the competition

he's been with us since 2018, and seen us rise, win a premiership, and dipped badly in 2024 - we're yet to see if it's a blip or a long term fall - and has overseen record memberships and a genuine drive for two home bases at casey and now caulfield

do i think he's a particularly awesome ceo? not really

do i think he's a particlarly awful ceo? not really 

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,602]

The part I dont get is why Geelong? Did Pert choose them? Why would we be bolstering a potential rival or are we just throwing our hands in the air and admitting the window is shut at least for now?

[dazzledavey36 55,318]

Keen to hear @goodwindees thoughts in all of this.

[Superunknown 4,223]

Imagine how Gus is feeling

Robbed of his career and club - future captain maybe - and watching this play out. Blokes wasting careers, blokes playing the club 

[Jaded No More 68,973]

To say we’ve had enough of Clarry is one thing. To use him as a pawn in a game of power struggle between the CEO/board and the FD, in some deluded attempt to be seen as “getting serious about our culture” is another. 

You can’t ask someone who’s struggling with serious health issues to sort themselves out, but then hold every small indiscretion against them along the way. Recovery is never linear. You either accept them, warts and all, or you don’t. 

But you absolutely do not dangle them like they’re a piece of meat at an all you can eat buffet, for your own convenience. We can’t keep throwing him on the table and threaten to give him away. We are like the boy who cried wolf at this point. 

Hard to find a more shambolic football club than this one  

 

[adonski 12,427]

1 minute ago, Norm Smith's Curse said:

The part I dont get is why Geelong? Did Pert choose them? Why would we be bolstering a potential rival or are we just throwing our hands in the air and admitting the window is shut at least for now?

Either

1. Pert knew Jeelong were tracking him already, so decided to call who he knew was already interested (both lazy and incompetent, given the Cats lack of picks)

or

2. We did do the rounds, and it's Jeelong and only Jeelong who were keen

[Jjrogan 1,439]

1 hour ago, old55 said:

The trade value Geelong gives and the amount of salary cap they pay are inversely proportional.

Decent draft pick and we pick up substantial salary

Later draft pick and they pay all the salary

I'd probably rather take a trade value hit than a salary cap hit,  but both have long term implications, a good draftee can give 12 years service.

With potential relief from Brayshaw and ANB leaving the club probably already has a fair bit of room in the years ahead.  Adding 1.3mln to the pool is great and all but only if we think we can grab a player that will make a huge difference for a flag.  But the club doesnt seem to be a destination right now.  Otherwise we'll end up just overpaying the current players which is not a great scenario either.  

We can afford to pay 300k or 400k of his salary for an extra future first or second in my opinion.   

[SPC 3,551]

I must admit I haven’t followed the Clarry situation all that closely as it all makes me pretty flat. But someone told me today that Clarry has not got the message and does not appear to be keen to turn his career around at Melbourne- so what choice do we have but to move him on. Sacrifice one to save the rest!

Agree with most we should have handle the media better, but the media appear to know more that our coach and have a direct line to the club gossip department.

We move Oliver, we get the best we can in return, we keep Trac and start to stabilise our culture. It’s painful, but it might be the only way forward.

[Mel Bourne 4,534]

1 minute ago, whatwhat say what said:

i guess - no different to greg swann or brian cook or benny gale or craig vozzo etc

pert had 10 years at the filth for a decade after being the ceo of austereo and then in a senior exec position at channel 9

under his tenure they rose, won a premiership, fell again - but were one of the two or three most powerful and successful off-field sides in the competition

he's been with us since 2018, and seen us rise, win a premiership, and dipped badly in 2024 - we're yet to see if it's a blip or a long term fall - and has overseen record memberships and a genuine drive for two home bases at casey and now caulfield

do i think he's a particularly awesome ceo? not really

do i think he's a particlarly awful ceo? not really 

I was of the same opinion only just a couple of days ago. 
 

As for his CV….Austereo, CH. 9 and the Collingwood FC. 
 

Yeah it would seem “cultural cancer” is the guy’s specialty. 

[Fromgotowoewodin 1,606]

27 minutes ago, Oxdee said:

The issue is that they know much more about the situation and understand much more about football than our supporter base. You need to give them the benefit of the doubt because most here are just part time analysts 

Don’t be silly, everyone on here knows exactly what’s happening and why it confirms their existing views about whether it’s Pert or Goody or both that need to be sacked immediately 

[Undeeterred 3,124]

21 minutes ago, Oxdee said:

Blaming the media for this is a stretch 

Rubbish

They’ve developed the story each step of the way to make it practically impossible for him to stay

[Undeeterred 3,124]

22 minutes ago, Oxdee said:

Blaming the media for this is a stretch 

Rubbish

They’ve developed the story each step of the way to make it practically impossible for him to stay

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,602]

21 minutes ago, reynolds46 said:

Can the club just withdraw from the AFL and enter a team in the amateurs?

Remember we are the only club where an ex-player told the world that we did in fact tank and how we did it so that the AFL couldnt let it go. 

[spirit of norm smith 16,587]

77 pages 

[Young Blood 2,634]

6 minutes ago, Fromgotowoewodin said:

Don’t be silly, everyone on here knows exactly what’s happening and why it confirms their existing views about whether it’s Pert or Goody or both that need to be sacked immediately 

Oh please don't speak for all of us. I do not know exactly whats happening, nor do I believe that Pert or Goody should be sacked.

I'm certainly not basing any of my understanding or opinions on media speculation or assumptions that keep being made by posters here.

 

Edited October 3 by Young Blood

[DeesignerAU 383]

23 minutes ago, reynolds46 said:

Can the club just withdraw from the AFL and enter a team in the amateurs?

How would we attract players if we can't subsidised the private school fees as many clubs do in that league?
 

[Clintosaurus 7,861]

13 minutes ago, Return to Glory said:

I reckon you could make a fair case that DH's like Sam Manure deliberately seek to cause disruption. You only had to see their disappointment when CPL came back into the fold. Are they fully responsible? Absolutely not. But they are very keen to destabilize the club.

Media been trying to destabilize the club for 2 years now. Scum.

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,602]

1 minute ago, Clintosaurus said:

Media been trying to destabilize the club for 2 years now. Scum.

Sure but the fact that they have done it so successfully is because of a long list of own goals.

[Big Gun 48]

The problem that I need to overcome now is that sadly I have completely lost trust in the people running the club. I get that at every club there is a large degree of spin, carefully worded comms and positive messaging sent by the club leaders which I understand is super important in building the membership base and maintaining their support. But the events of the past year or so have me finally feeling more like a foolish, gullible [censored] for believing it all rather than the optimistic, supportive member I usually am. I’m pretty sure I am not alone here. Bit like a bad long term relationship I imagine. Heart says “all good, travelling beautifully” but the brain says “you have got to be kidding”. 

I usually get really angry at supporters threatening to cancel memberships and burn scarves etc. However, right now, I can’t say I blame them one bit. Make no mistake, we are yet again perceived as the laughing stock of the competition (a position I thought we had left behind us a few years ago.)
 

How is it our skipper consistently manages to front the press, tell it like it is (be it good or bad) and come away with most people’s respect and understanding for the honesty?

How can our highly educated and incredibly experienced club execs seem to lack such skills to the point that members will now struggle to believe anything that comes out of their mouths. 

Has any club self destructed so badly in such a short period of time since a flag? 

All I want is for the constant spin to stop (starting with the B & F tomorrow night) , some honesty, some transparency and to be treated with some modicum of respect. Once this mess is behind us, and hopefully very soon, if the club do these things I will be back on for the ride. For me, the next few months are critical as to how I feel about this club moving forward and I really feel so upset even saying this. 
 

[Fromgotowoewodin 1,606]

4 minutes ago, Young Blood said:

Oh please don't speak for all of us. I certainly do not know exactly whats happening at all.

I'm certainly not basing any of my understanding or opinions on media speculation or assumptions that keep being made by posters here.

 

You missed the sarcasm there fella

[layzie 33,991]

Has anyone asked the question why Clayton was at the Brownlow? If there really was a strict set of guidelines to be met this year then why were we more than happy to let him go? 

[Young Blood 2,634]

1 minute ago, Fromgotowoewodin said:

You missed the sarcasm there fella

Forgive me. This thread has fried my brain. Appreciate it.

Also not a fella 🙃

[The heart beats true 18,145]

48 minutes ago, corndog said:

I've been a fan my whole life and a  member for the last 15 years consecutive. If Oliver goes to Geelong I'm done.

Why? What if the teams get better? Who knows what the future holds. Nobody saw ‘21 coming. Sometimes you’ve got to make moves to improve.

Edited October 3 by The heart beats true

[Young Blood 2,634]

1 minute ago, layzie said:

Has anyone asked the question why Clayton was at the Brownlow? If there really was a strict set of guidelines to be met this year then why were we more than happy to let him go? 

Wait what were the strict set of guidelines? Is this going off of media speculation?