30 minutes ago, Diamond_Jim said:

Agree.. they are vulnerable

Darcy will play back. He had an excellent VFL season in 2022 as a forward. Was tried early 2023 at AFL level as a forward and then moved back. Dropped and then injured for most of the season

Darcy isnt playing

35 minutes ago, demoncat said:

Looks a much stronger team than last week (although we’ll be missing Bowey 😢)

I’m guessing if BBB is listed then TMac has been bought in to play back? I do like the flexibility he offers and the fact that he can chop out for Max in the ruck

He would need to have had a miraculous summer (physically).  He couldn't get off the ground to contest any ruck work late last year and barely managed to contest imv.

Wary of the dogs. Middle of the Rd last few years yes....but this is what they do. Putter around mid table for years then have one year out of the box where they are nigh-unbeatable. Their midfield depth looks significantly better with Sanders (who is a gun) and Harmes - I still would rather him playing for us rather than them. 

Down back they do look a little green, so we need our forwards to fire. 

Don't underestimate them - have similar weapons to us really

“And in a daring and bold move the Melbourne coach swung Tom McDonald up forward where he managed to do nothing for the remainder of the game”

27 minutes ago, sue said:

You're working you way to the top of the list of negative for negative's sake posters.  How about you sprinkle something positive -  just for comic relief.

This is on WCW for opening the "Good News Week - Positive only" thread.

I fear Roost is now balancing out his "negativity" here!

1 minute ago, Demon Dynasty said:

This is on WCW for opening the "Good News Week - Positive only" thread.

I fear Roost is now balancing out his "negativity" here!

It’s the club who’s picked Templeton and Moore!!

Good to see Taj getting a game, would like to see him getting a fair crack this season.

2 minutes ago, Roost it far said:

It’s the club who’s picked Templeton and Moore!!

Moore did win a Brownlow when playing at MFC

I'll give you Templeton and raise you Diamond Jim Tilbrook

Just now, Roost it far said:

It’s the club who’s picked Templeton and Moore!!

Moore was ok!  Is that your positive offsetting the negative Roost!??

Just now, Diamond_Jim said:

Moore did win a Brownlow when playing at MFC

I'll give you Templeton and raise you Diamond Jim Tilbrook

Diamond's debut was one of the most exciting build ups of any MFC debutante i can remember, alongside Templeton & fabulous Phil.

2 minutes ago, Demon Dynasty said:

Diamond's debut was one of the most exciting build ups of any MFC debutante i can remember, alongside Templeton & fabulous Phil.

I forgot Fabulous Phil

And then there was our drafting of the Jarman brothers who refused to come over but joined Adelaide when they came into the comp.

We really were cursed

Schache was unretainable. Good luck to Brown who has played very well in this corresponding game the past two years. 

Pickett and Woey for Spargo and Laurie is significant improvement. Immediately more balanced and quicker. 

The Marty Hore story is a ripper. Let’s hope he holds up. The benefit to keeping Salem in the mid means it’s got double the potential payoff. 

Finally, TMac for Tomlinson. I didn’t think Tomlinson was that good last week but equally didn’t think he was so bad as to be dropped. Particularly not for TMac, who hasn’t played defence at AFL level for years and hasn’t played good AFL football for 2 years either. I think, perhaps, the idea is that he follows Lobb into the ruck to relieve Gawn and allow us to leave JVR forward. If that’s it, I can see it, but I’m so wary of whether he can hold up in the backline and fearful of turnovers by foot. 

Edited March 15, 20242 yr by titan_uranus

Just now, Diamond_Jim said:

I forgot Fabulous Phil

And then there was our drafting of the Jarman brothers who refused to come over but joined Adelaide when they came into the comp.

We really were cursed

Yes ... with Darren initially joining the wee & pooh.  I'll never forget it as he punished everyone thereafter including us

Expendables 4

T Mac and BBB are back!!

T Mac might be playing ruck/fwd, might not even be in defence

Could he even be sub....! Used or unused?

10 minutes ago, titan_uranus said:

Particularly not for TMac, who hasn’t played defence at AFL level for years and hasn’t played good AFL football for 2 years either. I think, perhaps, the idea is that he follows Lobb into the ruck to relieve Gawn and allow us to leave JVR forward. If that’s it, I can see it, but I’m so wary of whether he can hold up in the backline and fearful of turnovers by foot. 

Reckon JVR's done ok playing the chop out and forward.  Maybe they just want to see how he goes playing the solo role?

Edited March 15, 20242 yr by Demon Dynasty

14 minutes ago, Diamond_Jim said:

And then there was our drafting of the Jarman brothers

We drafted Darren in the first ever VFL draft in 1986 but he refused to leave South Australia and our hold on him lapsed after three years. 

Andrew wasn't drafted by us at any stage.

I think TMac will play on Lobb and follow him into the ruck.

Brown and JVR can be left to play as proper forwards.  Tmac or brown get subbed if we need run late.

Really thrilled for Hore. Am a fan.

play Taj - he looked ok when played 

edit - for consideration - Taj = WW2 (Woewoe 2)

Edited March 15, 20242 yr by Superunknown

Chandler is so very lucky! Gone backwards at warp speed 

It will hurt if we lose...but it makes sense to give the old guard a shot early in the season. If they can't do it and we fail, it will be time for the kids and recruits.  

Verrall, Fullarton, disco (eventually), etc...

IN: M.Hore, K.Pickett, T.McDonald, T.Woewodin, B.Brown
OUT: A.Tomlinson (omitted), J.Bowey (collarbone), J.Schache (omitted), C.Spargo (Achilles), B.Laurie (omitted)
 

Tmcd and BBB on the voltaren big time. 

 Welcome back Marty. 

Woey jnr and Kozzzy in. 👏👏👏

?? Tomo !!! Wtf 

Fullarton ?? Maybe not ready yet.  

47 minutes ago, Demon Dynasty said:

This is on WCW for opening the "Good News Week - Positive only" thread.

I fear Roost is now balancing out his "negativity" here!

Hey! Don’t blame me!!! The Rooster is negativity personified no matter what thread he chooses to besmirch (ie, all of them). To his credit though, he’ll be the first to admit that he’s partial to a bit of sch!tt stirring, unlike the inherently pessimistic sadsacks who seemingly enjoy wallowing in negativity. 

So we plan on running Gawn into the ground again it seems, none of the other talls are going to give him enough chop

5 hours ago, DubDee said:

i recall Hore being a nice kick but could be wrong

I recall him being a beautiful kick when under no pressure. Under a little pressure, he would start to dump kick. Hopefully, Hore Mark 2 will show more composure with the heat.