PREGAME: SF vs Carlton

[Red But Mostly Blue 4,547]

42 minutes ago, deelusions from afar said:

I'm a no for Schache (I want to see him do well but he just doesn't seem a competitor) but you've argued that pretty well.

Goody and the match committee are very much process driven people.  Each player plays a role and if someone is injured or suspended then the next person in line comes in.  If Schache is not to play in this circumstance then why re-sign him.  If the delivery is good, he is actually capable.  Could his job be to nullify Weitering?

(Btw I'd still lean to Grundy))

Yeah agree, surely we didn't draft him just to play in the 2s. 

He would be a decent matchup for Weitering. Very possible. 

haha yeah, it's hard to argue in favour of leaving out an AA ruckman who can kick a goal or two 

Really interested to see which way we'll go!!

[Kent 2,906]

4 hours ago, rpfc said:

He’s a star mate. A tough, premiership player. Literally had the norm smith until CP5 went platinum in the last 40 mins.

Agree Mate was a star clearly injured or crook cant kick or turn premiership was a world back in the past

[beelzebub 23,313]

1 hour ago, Bring-Back-Powell said:

Imagine what Grundy would be thinking on Friday night when he's up in the stands watching Schache taking his first centre ruck contest of the night.

I understand the potential selection because one can play forward and the other can't, but it's still hard to get your head around.

 

 

And when the siren sounds..  I'm outta here, tossing his cap in the bin on the way out 😞

[binman 42,629]

52 minutes ago, SthSea22 said:

Hard ask for 2 blokes 193cm up against a 211cm and 204cm 

Sure.

But most opposition rucks are pretty tall. 

[Go Lordie 297]

40 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:

Not only does he barrack for the Demons, at the rate our forwards are falling, he is odds on to line up at FF this week

It's an old one, but... Back in the day, a church in Hawthorn put up the topic for next week's sermon: "What would you do if Jesus came to Hawthorn?".  A couple of days later there was a scrawl underneath that said: "Move Brereton to centre half forward!"

[H_T 3,043]

“When all is said and done, more is said than done.” 

• Composure

• Support

• Execute well.  
 

#RespectGus

[Go Lordie 297]

44 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:

Not only does he barrack for the Demons, at the rate our forwards are falling, he is odds on to line up at FF this week

And I think there are spots for at least six of the Apostles in the forward line, too. 

[Go Lordie 297]

44 minutes ago, poita said:

Just to clarify what I read in the last minute regarding Tomlinson & Hibberd:

We had a team that was winning and playing well with Tomlinson alongside Lever & May.

We dumped Tomlinson after Richmond, brought him back against Hawthorn, then dumped him again for no reason to play Turner against Sydney. Turner wasn't great, but the team still won.

We then dumped Turner to play Hibberd against Collingwood. After a slow start Hibberd was okay, but the team lost.

We are now bringing back Tomlinson to play against Carlton without McKay, even though he didn't play when McKay did play in round 22. 

The question is why, oh why, would you keep stuffing around with the competition's best defence at this stage of the season?

Binman reckons Tomlinson's failure to play all-team defence cost us three goals against the Hawks. Good enough reason to leave him out when we are losing by less than two goals each week? 

[beelzebub 23,313]

5 minutes ago, H_T said:

“When all is said and done, more is said than done.” 

• Composure

• Support

• Execute well.  
 

#RespectGus

You been on hols ?? 😉

[Chook 15,012]

55 minutes ago, Roost it far said:

As I’ve already said Hibberd is needed against Cameron and Elliot the next 2 weeks and can’t play 4 games in a row on his Achilles. 

This. Hibberd is incredibly close to the end and simply can't back up multiple weeks in a row even though he is still good enough when he can get up for the game.

[DubDee 25,590]

Keep Hibbo on ice for the GF

🤪

[demoniac 1,330]

23 minutes ago, Go Lordie said:

It's an old one, but... Back in the day, a church in Hawthorn put up the topic for next week's sermon: "What would you do if Jesus came to Hawthorn?".  A couple of days later there was a scrawl underneath that said: "Move Brereton to centre half forward!"

I think the answer was, "Move Hudson to Centre Half forward" though at the old Glenferrie Oval Full Forward is not that far from Centre Half Forward.

[Go Lordie 297]

Just now, demoniac said:

I think the answer was, "Move Hudson to Centre Half forward" though at the old Glenferrie Oval Full Forward is not that far from Centre Half Forward.

Correct. Thanks demoniac.  Brereton was never FF. 

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,589]

22 minutes ago, Go Lordie said:

Binman reckons Tomlinson's failure to play all-team defence cost us three goals against the Hawks. Good enough reason to leave him out when we are losing by less than two goals each week? 

Because last week we wasted Lever as a lockdown for most of the game. Third tall means Lever can actually do what he does best

[Deebauched 1,220]

17 minutes ago, Go Lordie said:

Correct. Thanks demoniac.  Brereton was never FF. 

I thought the original response was..... "play him at CHF"  .... inferring that  Peter Hudson is God and remains at FF.  I never saw it in person but a few relatives did.

Well over 50 years ago.

Edited September 14, 2023 by Deebauched

[Dido 78]

Demon fans traveling in Turkiye. Me and my die hard son. Managed to find a bar in Istanbul to watch the Dees and Maggies. But now heading into more rural areas. Can anyone suggest a way to watch the Carlton dees game on our phone? Would appreciate any help. Go red legs!

 

[Tolstoys Nudge 1,616]

So it’s feeling like Grundy, Spargo, Jordon into the 23 with Schache the dark horse now.. considering Turner didn’t train. 
 

im gonna go with Thommo as sub, Jordon & Spargo in… massive risk but admits and McDonald can compete might help the bombing be less prevalent 

Edited September 14, 2023 by Nudge

[daisycutter 29,603]

22 minutes ago, Deebauched said:

I thought the original response was..... "play him at CHF"  .... inferring that  Peter Hudson is God and remains at FF.  I never saw it in person but a few relatives did.

Well over 50 years ago.

no, it was move hudson to chf

[biggestred 5,015]

7 minutes ago, Dido said:

Demon fans traveling in Turkiye. Me and my die hard son. Managed to find a bar in Istanbul to watch the Dees and Maggies. But now heading into more rural areas. Can anyone suggest a way to watch the Carlton dees game on our phone? Would appreciate any help. Go red legs!

 

hey mate a few years ago i watched a few games on my phone while travelling the UK. it was pricey and i cant rememeber the name of the app. 

[daisycutter 29,603]

https://www.theage.com.au/entertainment/art-and-design/funny-that-20051127-ge1bke.html

[beelzebub 23,313]

10 minutes ago, Nudge said:

So it’s feeling like Grundy, Spargo, Thommo into the 23 with Schache the dark horse now.. considering Turner didn’t train.

Did Grundy train today ? ( i mean  really participate) 

[leave it to deever 17,511]

I really do believe we will win this. Not so confident about the Pf.

But it feels like the whole world is against us. Not just the Maynard  Incident. 

But we will coming out breathing fire and jump this mob. Their campaign is finished. They are in for a very rude awakening .

Edited September 14, 2023 by leave it to deever

[Tolstoys Nudge 1,616]

Just now, beelzebub said:

Did Grundy train today ? ( i mean  really participate) 

Yes… I had mail it was 💯 Turner so still confused to how he wasn’t there today but for me Grundy HAS to play either way  

[Lucifers Hero 39,556]

Voss is hedging his bets with Silvagni.  Says he is available but hasn't played a game for over a month.  It is rare for a player with his # of preseasons to come back via the VFL.  .

They have lost a tall fwd have an injured #1 ruckman and only Silvagni covers both positions.  Pittoney and DeK are not fwds and they need another tall to help Curnow otherwise Curnow will be in for a harrowing night!! 

If he isn't selected tonight I would expect a late change tomorrow.

Mind games...!

[Tolstoys Nudge 1,616]

Just now, Lucifers Hero said:

Voss is hedging his bets with Silvagni.  Says he is available but hasn't played a game for over a month.  It is rare for a player with his # of preseasons to come back via the VFL.  .

They have lost a tall fwd have an injured #1 ruckman and only Silvagni covers both positions.  Pittoney and DeK are not fwds and they need another tall to help Curnow otherwise Curnow will be in for a harrowing night!! 

If he isn't selected tonight I would expect a late change tomorrow.

Mind games...!

Not playing