On 03/04/2022 at 12:00, Storma and Wiz said:

I think Jacob could be making his debut this Thursday night. 

Better odds of me running out there I would have thought 

 

  On 30/01/2022 at 19:43, 58er said:

Really why talk about Amiss ? We were never able to get him early in the draft and have done a mighty job getting Van Rooyen. 

 

 

The guy we were really after was apparently Gibcus who's making a reasonable start with the Tigers.

  On 03/04/2022 at 13:55, dee-tox said:

The guy we were really after was apparently Gibcus who's making a reasonable start with the Tigers.

Gibcus was always touted as a top 10 pick not really sure how that works

@Storma and Wizjust joined to make that post about JVR debut this week

This suggests he knows or he is a troll.  If the latter he will have shot his cred on DL for quite a while.

I suspect the former so lets not dismiss it too quickly.

  On 03/04/2022 at 22:54, Lucifers Hero said:

@Storma and Wizjust joined to make that post about JVR debut this week

This suggests he knows or he is a troll.  If the latter he will have shot his cred on DL for quite a while.

I suspect the former so lets not dismiss it too quickly.

Or its young Jacob himself just putting it out there :)

I was disappointed he didn't play on the weekend was keen to see if he could carry on from the game against Sandy in which he did show some promise

Personally think he will make a good player given time - seems to understand the game well, is already physical, can mark and is looks like a pretty accurate kick

Fortunately we are no longer a team that needs to rush fist year players into the team and I hope he is allowed to settle and build confidence - he will be picked when he is ready - I would be very surprised if that's anytime in the first half of this season (absent covid issues or injury restricting others availability)

Edited April 3, 20223 yr by Sydee

  On 03/04/2022 at 12:00, Storma and Wiz said:

I think Jacob could be making his debut this Thursday night. 

same was said about Howes last week - someone taking the pi$$

In the VFL game against Sandy, JVR was cramping really badly towards the end of the game. Hopefully it was just cramp, and he didn't miss the game against the Bombers through injury.

I'd be shocked if he played this week.

  On 03/04/2022 at 23:10, Sydee said:

Or its young Jacob himself just putting it out there :)

I was disappointed he didn't play on the weekend was keen to see if he could carry on from the game against Sandy in which he did show some promise

Personally think he will make a good player given time - seems to understand the game well, is already physical, can mark and is looks like a pretty accurate kick

Fortunately we are no longer a team that needs to rush fist year players into the team and I hope he is allowed to settle and build confidence - he will be picked when he is ready - I would be very surprised if that's anytime in the first half of this season (absent covid issues or injury restricting others availability)

I'd be amazed if JVR came into the side to replace TMac (assuming BBB doesn't get up for the game). If BBB does get up I'd say it's likely he will come in at TMac's expense (After Friday night's game Sam Wiedeman surely can't be dropped. If nothing else, it would severely undermine his confidence). Maybe JVR is being held over as cover for Thursday as an emergency, although I would have thought he could have played a half assuming he isn't actually injured (I can't find anything one way or the other as to why he didn't play for Casey on Saturday).

  On 30/01/2022 at 22:54, DeeZone said:

I am rapt that we actually picked up JVR he is so important to our long term plans and the other bloke may be a bit more feminine than JVR not that is an issue.!!😳

Sorry just a play on words A Miss.😀✅

  On 03/04/2022 at 23:51, Sydney_Demon said:

I'd be amazed if JVR came into the side to replace TMac (assuming BBB doesn't get up for the game). If BBB does get up I'd say it's likely he will come in at TMac's expense (After Friday night's game Sam Wiedeman surely can't be dropped. If nothing else, it would severely undermine his confidence). Maybe JVR is being held over as cover for Thursday as an emergency, although I would have thought he could have played a half assuming he isn't actually injured (I can't find anything one way or the other as to why he didn't play for Casey on Saturday).

Agree, whether you think Weideman played a great game or just a serviceable game he did what was asked of him, dropping him after one game in and what he's been through to get here couldn't help his confidence. I think T-mac needs to take one for the team here. I know he's still working his tail off when he doesn't have the ball but Brown needs to come in. 

Edited April 4, 20223 yr by layzie

Dropping Weideman after one game, where he performed, sends a bad message to the list. Hunt went down, Bowey came in, rest is history. You can't say to the blokes on the fringe, be patient, stay keen, your moment will come. And when it does, we'll then discard you for our favourite player.

The depth we have in part comes from the (so-far) fact that when your moment comes, if you perform, you keep playing. And players who don't perform (eg Brown mid-last year) will create opportunities for others. We can't dilute the strength by playing favourites.

Tough selection dilemma, but it's the kind of problem we could only have dreamed of in years past.

True MR we have seen players come in earlier than expected Jackson, Pickett, Rivers, JJ, Sparrow and Bowey and become household names, when JVR, Howes and Laurie get their chance someone will have to make way for them. It is a tough gig.!!

The way things are going there is only one bloke that's guaranteed a GF(God willing) spot.

  On 03/04/2022 at 13:55, dee-tox said:

The guy we were really after was apparently Gibcus who's making a reasonable start with the Tigers.

That's the first I have heard that.

Who is your source.? 

I am very happy with JVR and don't believe he is in line for selection vs Port on Thursday night.

What other tips  etc have "Storm and Wiz" given us of any reliability.

Sorry sounds about as credible as Mrs Havershams cats having a mid morning milk sip meeting. 

We don't need to do a "Jack Watts debut any time soon" so get your gear ready BBB and kicking boots on. 

T Mac medi sub ? 

 

  On 04/04/2022 at 01:06, DeeZone said:

True MR we have seen players come in earlier than expected Jackson, Pickett, Rivers, JJ, Sparrow and Bowey and become household names, when JVR, Howes and Laurie get their chance someone will have to make way for them. It is a tough gig.!!

Some have earned immediate spots others have had to work and on both cases it's all made proper sense.

JVR does not need a distraction to his development at this stage. Let him be at Casey unless Covid rears it's ugly head. 

  On 04/04/2022 at 01:08, willmoy said:

The way things are going there is only one bloke that's guaranteed a GF(God willing) spot.

Who is that ? 

  On 04/04/2022 at 00:57, Mazer Rackham said:

Dropping Weideman after one game, where he performed, sends a bad message to the list. Hunt went down, Bowey came in, rest is history. You can't say to the blokes on the fringe, be patient, stay keen, your moment will come. And when it does, we'll then discard you for our favourite player.

The depth we have in part comes from the (so-far) fact that when your moment comes, if you perform, you keep playing. And players who don't perform (eg Brown mid-last year) will create opportunities for others. We can't dilute the strength by playing favourites.

Tough selection dilemma, but it's the kind of problem we could only have dreamed of in years past.

Weed won't be dropped Tmac Will if Rick Lever is fit. 

  On 04/04/2022 at 03:26, 58er said:

Weed won't be dropped Tmac Will if Rick Lever is fit. 

and if Jake lever is fit even better

  On 04/04/2022 at 03:47, Jontee said:

and if Jake lever is fit even better

Rick is his Nick name Jontee. 
Up with the program. 

  On 03/04/2022 at 12:00, Storma and Wiz said:

I think Jacob could be making his debut this Thursday night. 

I assume you mean on Thursday nights Q+A? What's the topic? Growing up with a Dutch surname?

  On 04/04/2022 at 03:25, 58er said:

Who is that ? 

He plays, we win.

  On 04/04/2022 at 00:57, Mazer Rackham said:

Dropping Weideman after one game, where he performed, sends a bad message to the list. Hunt went down, Bowey came in, rest is history. You can't say to the blokes on the fringe, be patient, stay keen, your moment will come. And when it does, we'll then discard you for our favourite player.

The depth we have in part comes from the (so-far) fact that when your moment comes, if you perform, you keep playing. And players who don't perform (eg Brown mid-last year) will create opportunities for others. We can't dilute the strength by playing favourites.

Tough selection dilemma, but it's the kind of problem we could only have dreamed of in years past.

Unless of course you are talking about one of the top 5-10 in the team who are automatic ins after missing a game.

 

  On 04/04/2022 at 05:26, Redleg said:

Unless of course you are talking about one of the top 5-10 in the team who are automatic ins after missing a game.

 

A Lever, Petracca, etc, are automatic selections at this point and I think the list understand that.

  On 04/04/2022 at 05:37, Mazer Rackham said:

A Lever, Petracca, etc, are automatic selections at this point and I think the list understand that.

The beauty with our list atm, is we seem to have replacements available who can do a reasonable job filling in. Then because of good drafting, our talent pool is increasing. Other than maybe in the ruck, we have adequate depth in nearly all positions.

Jacob van Rooyen has all the raw tools to be a gun key forward. He's a physically dominant, athletic beast and seems to have the right attitude. I suspect he needs to work on his gas tank and that's to be expected. No need to rush him, he will play when he's ready.

Edited April 4, 20223 yr by shoguner