Bobby Hill

[Ash35 425]

1 hour ago, PaulRB said:

You're a weird cat Ash, a Bombers fan posting on a Demons site...

Had to google about Davey's twins, then realised you weren't talking about Aaron's kids, but Alwins.. 

What happened, did they kick you off the Bomber forum for talking about the Demons too much?

🤪

And yes, Alwyn Daveys twin boys, not Aarons 

Hard to know exactly if they will be bid on as they have hardly played any footy over the past 2 seasons, but is prudent to plan ahead just in case.

I think Essendon is hoping hey will develop a bit more in 2022, although not too much as so they get bid on early. Word is Alwyn Jnr is a bit more advanced than Jayden, but that's just what I have read

[Redleg 38,506]

17 minutes ago, Ash35 said:

Long history between the 2, going back to the days McCartney was at the Bulldogs. He probably got the ball rolling when he apparently walked into the room, offered pick 38 for Stewart Crameri, and walked out. Crameri at the time has won our Goalkicking the previous 2 seasons and was in our top 12 players. We got him to give us pick 26 which we used to draft Zach Merrett, so they probably didn't amuse him.

Essendon probably did well out of the Stringer trade, but the Bulldogs were kicking him out the door, so we were hardly going to pay a kings ransom

We paid overs for Shiel with 2 1st Rounders, so I doubt he is angry at us for that

I know McCartney wasn't happy about us getting Caldwell last year for a couple of 2nd rounders, but over the journey, I reckon McCartney has "won" more often than Dodoro in trades between the 2.

Maybe he is just sick of losing players to us

This wouldn't have helped McCartney's attitude either.

The Giants will receive Pick 11 and a 2018 third round selection from the Bombers, while Essendon receive Smith, Pick 24 and GWS' 2018 second round pick.

Essendon's new draft selections will prove vital in securing the services of Jake Stringer and Adam Saad who have both nominated the Bombers as their preferred destination club.

[Ash35 425]

7 minutes ago, Redleg said:

This wouldn't have helped McCartney's attitude either.

The Giants will receive Pick 11 and a 2018 third round selection from the Bombers, while Essendon receive Smith, Pick 24 and GWS' 2018 second round pick.

Essendon's new draft selections will prove vital in securing the services of Jake Stringer and Adam Saad who have both nominated the Bombers as their preferred destination club.

McCartney was at the Bulldogs during that trade period.

That deal was done with the once head of Melbournes recruiting team Craig Cameron. IIRC he left for Gold Coast after that trade period, and McCartney moved onto to GWS to replace him.

We probably won that trade although Smith has been a disappointment barring his B&F winning first year with us and Saad has moved on. Stringer has been really good.

I think draft picks are bit overrated. They are only as good as the players you pick with them.

Pick 1 could get you Sam Walsh, or Paddy McCartin

Pick 32 could get you Trent Rivers, or Luke Valente

Melbourne have done it beautifully lately, trading in the likes of Lever, May, and Brown (Langdon FA), yet when they have had picks, drafted really well (Petracca, Oliver, Jackson, Pickett, Fritsch, Rivers, Jordan etc)

[Ash35 425]

Well there you go

Essendon offer our future 2nd straight up with nothing coming back, GWS say no

Strange, as Hill sounds like he will be out the door next at the end of next year and pretty unhappy in 2022

 

[Redleg 38,506]

47 minutes ago, Ash35 said:

Well there you go

Essendon offer our future 2nd straight up with nothing coming back, GWS say no

Strange, as Hill sounds like he will be out the door next at the end of next year and pretty unhappy in 2022

 

If I was the Giants I would be grabbing that. I don’t think Hill is that good. Very inconsistent and seen him jib a few contests. Not sure he has a great tank either. Maybe they are waiting for the last hour.

[deelusions from afar 1,620]

3 hours ago, Ash35 said:

Apparently we have offered a future 2nd but want a little something coming back. Even a late future 3rd or 4th pick will helps us, as we may well have both Davey twins to bid for next season under F/S

Sorry if this is going off topic, but does anyone know how many other father-son or NGA there might be in the mix at the pointy end of next year's draft.  Obviously very hard to know with lack of exposure.  But it there's a few around, it might make sense to trade our other picks after 17 for future 2nd/3rd/4th round picks as they might have some added currency next year?

[Turner 1,483]

40 minutes ago, deelusions from afar said:

Sorry if this is going off topic, but does anyone know how many other father-son or NGA there might be in the mix at the pointy end of next year's draft.  Obviously very hard to know with lack of exposure.  But it there's a few around, it might make sense to trade our other picks after 17 for future 2nd/3rd/4th round picks as they might have some added currency next year?

heard of Will ashcroft of the lions f/s as a potential top 5er so far

[Whispering_Jack 28,118]

5 minutes ago, Turner said:

heard of Will ashcroft of the lions f/s as a potential top 5er so far

Next year.

[DeeSpencer 23,657]

37 minutes ago, Redleg said:

If I was the Giants I would be grabbing that. I don’t think Hill is that good. Very inconsistent and seen him jib a few contests. Not sure he has a great tank either. Maybe they are waiting for the last hour.

Unless they can get a player to beef up their best 22 (hence targeting the Hawks forwards) I’d keep him. If he gets traded at the end of next year for little or nothing, even if he sits out the season (I doubt he does) they’ve haven’t given up much. Otherwise even though they keep finding ways to be stuck around the middle of the ladder the Giants remain in a premiership window. They have all the most important pieces, if Hill had a big summer he’d be a player they don’t have on their list.

[Turner 1,483]

1 minute ago, Whispering_Jack said:

Next year.

that's what he asked...

[manny100 1,112]

Have to laugh. Everyone blaming GWS for holding up the trade. No one on radio etc asking why don't the hard to deals with Dons improve their offer.

[Redleg 38,506]

1 hour ago, DeeSpencer said:

Unless they can get a player to beef up their best 22 (hence targeting the Hawks forwards) I’d keep him. If he gets traded at the end of next year for little or nothing, even if he sits out the season (I doubt he does) they’ve haven’t given up much. Otherwise even though they keep finding ways to be stuck around the middle of the ladder the Giants remain in a premiership window. They have all the most important pieces, if Hill had a big summer he’d be a player they don’t have on their list.

And if he is p-ssed off with the Giants I am sure he will try his hardest next season. 

[DeeSpencer 23,657]

10 minutes ago, Redleg said:

And if he is p-ssed off with the Giants I am sure he will try his hardest next season. 

Worked for Papley.
 

I’m not sure Hill would’ve grown up at the Bombers on a nice healthy deal.

GWS need to look at their welfare staff who haven’t created a good enough relationship that he could be honest with them. 

But if Hill wants a big contract he’ll have to earn it the old fashioned way. 

Edited October 13, 2021 by DeeSpencer

[Deestroy All 14,262]

Dumb by all parties. 
 

And I love it. 

[Demonstone 20,021]

He was never coming to Melbourne.

[Blistering 493]

When the write Adrian Dodoro’s biography, this will go down as yet another triumph.

[Ash35 425]

4 hours ago, Redleg said:

If I was the Giants I would be grabbing that. I don’t think Hill is that good. Very inconsistent and seen him jib a few contests. Not sure he has a great tank either. Maybe they are waiting for the last hour.

Agree, Very inconsistent up til now. Our future 2nd was just about overs depending on where we finish next season.

[Ash35 425]

2 hours ago, manny100 said:

Have to laugh. Everyone blaming GWS for holding up the trade. No one on radio etc asking why don't the hard to deals with Dons improve their offer.

You don't think a future 2nd round pick is a fair offer for Bobby Hill.

Averages 9 touches a game, kicked 14 goals in 17 games this year, and laid 6 tackles in his last 4 games this season.

I really don't think the Dons were the ones who were hard to deal with on this occasion

When other trades fall over, clubs are congratulated for "sticking to their guns and doing what's best for their club"

When Essendon trades fall over, "we are just hard to deal with"

[DeeSpencer 23,657]

48 minutes ago, Ash35 said:

You don't think a future 2nd round pick is a fair offer for Bobby Hill.

Averages 9 touches a game, kicked 14 goals in 17 games this year, and laid 6 tackles in his last 4 games this season.

I really don't think the Dons were the ones who were hard to deal with on this occasion

When other trades fall over, clubs are congratulated for "sticking to their guns and doing what's best for their club"

When Essendon trades fall over, "we are just hard to deal with"

Don't you have your own forum?

[Whispering_Jack 28,118]

9 hours ago, DeeSpencer said:

Don't you have your own forum?

@Ash35 is a long time and respected Demonland poster. He’s also respectful of others and is welcome to post here at any time. And given that this is “The Bobby Hill Thread” he was fully on topic.

Thanks.

[grazman 6,743]

I watched Colin Young on Foxtel's trading day last night and my first thought was "used car salesman".  I'm not sure Bobby got the best advice here, but GWS were absolutely entitled not to trade him if it didn't work for them.  

Does he now have the where-with-all to knuckle down and play his best footy to go back to the well at the end of 2023 or does he throw his bum in the corner and end up on the scrap heap as a delisted free agent without any suitors?

[Lucifers Hero 37,524]

24 minutes ago, grazman said:

I watched Colin Young on Foxtel's trading day last night and my first thought was "used car salesman".  I'm not sure Bobby got the best advice here, but GWS were absolutely entitled not to trade him if it didn't work for them.  

Does he now have the where-with-all to knuckle down and play his best footy to go back to the well at the end of 2023 or does he throw his bum in the corner and end up on the scrap heap as a delisted free agent without any suitors?

Young is also Lobb's manager.  The other day it seemed like Bobby was used as a trading chip to free up cap space so Lobb could get from Freo to GWS.   GWS didn't like really entertain either deal.

Young also didn't help Bobby's cause saying how distraught he was, how hard it would be to go back to GWS and he won't be signing another contract with them.  Great way to devalue a possible trade next year.  

Meanwhile, Dodoro says:  “My last conversation was with him at 5pm, I said, ‘Look, we tried our best, we wish you all the very best,’ and he was fine, he was getting a tattoo actually, so he was happy.”

Time to change manager...

[Axis of Bob 10,497]

11 hours ago, Ash35 said:

You don't think a future 2nd round pick is a fair offer for Bobby Hill.

Averages 9 touches a game, kicked 14 goals in 17 games this year, and laid 6 tackles in his last 4 games this season.

I really don't think the Dons were the ones who were hard to deal with on this occasion

When other trades fall over, clubs are congratulated for "sticking to their guns and doing what's best for their club"

When Essendon trades fall over, "we are just hard to deal with"

I just don't think either party wanted it enough to make it happen. Hill is a nice player but the whole situations stinks of something weird.

I'm not much of conspiracies but the Colin Young theory makes a bite of sense.

[whatwhat say what 20,353]

the 'conversations' about finlayson going back to south australia started three months ago

the request from hill to be traded to one specific club in victoria started four days ago

it was always an ambit request that required gw$ getting 'cover' for a small forward

particularly important with greene on sabbatical for the first five weeks

[Ash35 425]

2 hours ago, Whispering_Jack said:

@Ash35 is a long time and respected Demonland poster. He’s also respectful of others and is welcome to post here at any time. And given that this is “The Bobby Hill Thread” he was fully on topic.

Thanks.

Thanks Jack

If I had a dollar for every time I've been told "go back to your own forum", I'd be a rich man. But as I have said earlier, I really do think most on here are reasonable and good football discussion can be had.

As for Bobby Hill, I'm a bit with @Axis of Bob, something doesn't really feel right. Sounds like his trade request caught GWS completely off guard, and the fact he contacted Essendon to seek out a trade as opposed to Essendon chasing him makes it seem like we weren't overly keen. Together with the Lobb trade, almost like it was manufactured by the manager and player but none of the clubs being involved. The opposite to the Luke Breust deal, where both Hawthorn and GWS had agreed, but the player had no idea about it and said "no".

I think our offer was fair (future 2nd), but with GWS seemingly just not interested in doing any type of deal, which is fine as he is contracted, the trade was never going to happen. But I was comfortable with our offer, and would have been disappointed if we stumped up more for a player such as Bobby Hill.