The 2020 Trade Period

[Lucifers Hero 37,514]

4 minutes ago, layzie said:

Absolutely, this will be quite a bargaining tool and I'd expect a fair few to be using it. 

Yes and the more players a club has OOC (like us) the harder it will be to accommodate their expectations and the more vulnerable we are to losing some we would otherwise keep.

[dazzledavey36 49,736]

13 minutes ago, drdrake said:

Petty, Jordan and Sparrow all South Australians, I'm sure Adelaide we be on the hunt for any SA player at other clubs

Jordan is from my home town of Yarrawonga.  Grew up and played rep footy with my younger brother.

[drdrake 3,059]

4 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Jordan is from my home town of Yarrawonga.  Grew up and played rep footy with my younger brother.

Sorry, got him mixed up with Nietschke, I knew we took 2 kids from SA in that draft and Chandler as a rookie.

 

 

[spirit of norm smith 13,574]

I agree Crows will be after Sparrow and Petty. 

They can talk about Neal-Bullen. 

But we have a lot of inside mids so unfortunately Sparrow could be an option . 

Sparrow and Neal-Bullen for Crows 2nd round pick and 3rd round pick  (1st selection in 2nd round and 3rd round could be interesting) 

 

[Lord Nev 13,512]

12 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

I agree Crows will be after Sparrow and Petty. 

They can talk about Neal-Bullen. 

But we have a lot of inside mids so unfortunately Sparrow could be an option . 

Sparrow and Neal-Bullen for Crows 2nd round pick and 3rd round pick  (1st selection in 2nd round and 3rd round could be interesting) 

Sparrow isn't going anywhere.

[drdrake 3,059]

12 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

I agree Crows will be after Sparrow and Petty. 

They can talk about Neal-Bullen. 

But we have a lot of inside mids so unfortunately Sparrow could be an option . 

Sparrow and Neal-Bullen for Crows 2nd round pick and 3rd round pick  (1st selection in 2nd round and 3rd round could be interesting) 

 

 

Adelaide will laugh that offer off, I reckon they would have no interest in ANB.  Sparrow was only  pick 27 2 years ago and hasn't really show much.  We might be able to bundle up Petty and Sparrow our 4th round pick for Crows second round and 4th round pick.  The Crows will get Tyson Edwards son who by all accounts is a top 20 pick, so they will be looking at trading their second round picks out and get enough points in later picks to cover.

[BW511 2,346]

What do we get of value for players that haven’t got games, in a team that’s been absolutely putrid, for 1 1/2 seasons? 
 

[TRIGON 4,719]

1 hour ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Jordan is from my home town of Yarrawonga.  Grew up and played rep footy with my younger brother.

Dramatically increases the chances that he will linger longer.

(yes, I will see myself out now)

[dazzledavey36 49,736]

42 minutes ago, TRIGON said:

Dramatically increases the chances that he will linger longer.

(yes, I will see myself out now)

I'll open the door for you..........

[Half forward flank 1,022]

Success this year will be a big factor in whether a few are enticed away. Lets say Sparrow Jordan  Petty miss being part of funals sucess this year, injuries, they will likely be hellbent on staying for future success. When you say SA we are really just talking the Crows. Dont see players bursting down the door to go there for now.

[spirit of norm smith 13,574]

17 minutes ago, Half forward flank said:

Success this year will be a big factor in whether a few are enticed away. Lets say Sparrow Jordan  Petty miss being part of funals sucess this year, injuries, they will likely be hellbent on staying for future success. When you say SA we are really just talking the Crows. Dont see players bursting down the door to go there for now.

Agree. Crows are rabble and hardly an attractive option. Also go home factor is reduced because likely it could be another year 2021 on the road and in Hub type scenario once again. 

[BW511 2,346]

Anyone got any interest in Sam Petrevski-Seton from Carlton?

Forward-mid that could potentially add some outside run and carry to our mix. In contract for 2021 but he’s got some tricks

[Turner 1,483]

2 hours ago, BW511 said:

Anyone got any interest in Sam Petrevski-Seton from Carlton?

Forward-mid that could potentially add some outside run and carry to our mix. In contract for 2021 but he’s got some tricks

he's a running defender...

[BW511 2,346]

1 hour ago, Turner said:

he's a running defender...

That’s where he’s playing currently, from what I’ve heard, he was recruited as a forward-mid and played all his junior footy there in outside roles

[Binmans PA 26,662]

7 hours ago, BW511 said:

Anyone got any interest in Sam Petrevski-Seton from Carlton?

Forward-mid that could potentially add some outside run and carry to our mix. In contract for 2021 but he’s got some tricks

I'd take a look mate. Good suggestion. He did play forward-mid early on. He's got a bit of that zip and creativity that we lack around the ball and inside 50 (outside of Pickett).

[whatwhat say what 20,294]

There is no way Carlton would let him go

 

[DistrACTION Jackson 6,830]

Anyone have any whispers on players we are chasing?

If we aren't after guys like Atkins, Williams and Papley to add leg spped and skill I'd be disappointed.

[BW511 2,346]

45 minutes ago, Action Jackson said:

Anyone have any whispers on players we are chasing?

If we aren't after guys like Atkins, Williams and Papley to add leg spped and skill I'd be disappointed.

I think there will be too much interest in those three for us to have a chance - no picks, not enough cash, so best look elsewhere 

[rjay 24,178]

19 hours ago, BW511 said:

Anyone got any interest in Sam Petrevski-Seton from Carlton?

Forward-mid that could potentially add some outside run and carry to our mix. In contract for 2021 but he’s got some tricks

I was a big wrap for him as a junior.

Certainly worth a look.

10 hours ago, whatwhatsaywhat said:

There is no way Carlton would let him go

 

Depends...they have needs and he's only fringe for them and being played out of position.

[DemonJack 14 85]

 

My Take on our Trade/Draft Period 

 

With North having our 1st rounder this year obviously don't have as many bargaining chips to trade for what we need. 

But we need to make changes to the list to keep improving (not to mention the coaching but that is another discussion). 

I think we still need some young talent on the list so would be wanting to use at least a second rounder and 3rd round pick in this draft. 

Unless it was for an unbelievable deal I would not give our 1st rounder for 2021, as it is meant to be a very very good draft and who knows where we finish next year ! 

I think for the right deal Brayshaw should be considered as trade bait he still holds a lot of value, We have the upper hand with him being contracted ( apparently Fremantle are keen) 

If so ask for their 1st Round , Adam Cerra, Darcy Tucker or even Sam Sturt who we were keen on in the draft a couple of years ago 

 

other players we should consider trading that hold some value 

 

Brayden Preuss ( however we still need to find some back up mature ruck from else where if he goes ) 

Tom Macdonald - Not worth much at the moment - but if a decent deal came along we would have to look at it 

 

Realistic players to Target given our needs. 

 

Adel - Rory Atkins 

Bris - Alex Witherden , Cedric Cox 

Carl - ? 

Coll - Tom Phillips, Tom Langdon  

Ess - Adam Saad 

Frem - Darcy Tucker, Adam Cerra, Sam Sturt,  

GWS  - Adam Kennedy, Xavier O'Halloran ,Jeremy  Finlayson,  Harry Perryman, Zac Williams , Zac Langdon 

Geel - Nakia Cockatoo, Quinton Narkle, 

GC - Alex Sexton 

Haw - Jack Gunston, Issac Smith 

Nth - Jarred Polec 

Port - Kane Farrel,  Karl Amon 

Rich -  Patrick Naish,  Oleg Markov 

Stk - Jack Lonie, Jack Sinclair  

Syd - Matthew Ling, Oliver Florent, Ben Ronke 

WCE - Andrew Gaff, Jackson Nelson, Tom Cole 

WB -  Bailey Dale,  Toby Mclean, Lewis Young, 

 

Top 3 realistic Targets for mine 

 

1. Adam Saad 

2. Alex Witherden  

3. Toby Mclean 

 

 

 

[Turner 1,483]

5 hours ago, DemonJack 14 said:

 

Realistic players to Target given our needs. 

Adel - Rory Atkins 

Bris - Alex Witherden , Cedric Cox 

Carl - ? 

Coll - Tom Phillips, Tom Langdon  

Ess - Adam Saad 

Frem - Darcy Tucker, Adam Cerra, Sam Sturt,  

GWS  - Adam Kennedy, Xavier O'Halloran ,Jeremy  Finlayson,  Harry Perryman, Zac Williams , Zac Langdon 

Geel - Nakia Cockatoo, Quinton Narkle, 

GC - Alex Sexton 

Haw - Jack Gunston, Issac Smith 

Nth - Jarred Polec 

Port - Kane Farrel,  Karl Amon 

Rich -  Patrick Naish,  Oleg Markov 

Stk - Jack Lonie, Jack Sinclair  

Syd - Matthew Ling, Oliver Florent, Ben Ronke 

WCE - Andrew Gaff, Jackson Nelson, Tom Cole 

WB -  Bailey Dale,  Toby Mclean, Lewis Young, 

 

Top 3 realistic Targets for mine 

 

1. Adam Saad 

2. Alex Witherden  

3. Toby Mclean 

 

 

 

id throw talia/laird in and also tarrant if north really want to bottom out. no interest in a pete wright? isaac cumming? schache? dyl roberton? finlayson?

Edited September 7, 2020 by Turner

[spirit of norm smith 13,574]

Top 4 realistic targets

Alex Witherden. Lions 
Isaac Cumming.  Giants 
Matthew Ling. Swans 
Jacob Kennerley.  Cats 

Pace and skill. No more hackers. 

Edited September 8, 2020 by spirit of norm smith
Xxxx

[Turner 1,483]

10 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Top 4 realistic targets

Alex Witherden. Lions 
Isaac Cumming.  Giants 
Matthew Ling. Swans 
Jacob Kennerley.  Cats 

Pace and skill. No more hackers. 

Witherden

Polec

Wright

Cumming for mine

[spirit of norm smith 13,574]

12 hours ago, Turner said:

Witherden

Polec

Wright

Cumming for mine

Assume Preuss goes (Giants or Swans) and Wright brought in as key forward/ruck backup. Sounds good. 

[WERRIDEE 5,255]

On 8/10/2020 at 7:39 PM, RalphiusMaximus said:

I'm pretty sure Melbourne is happy with the list at the moment.  We have depth across the board with the possible exception of the ruck.  Could probably do with drafting another project ruck to bring on for five years and there are a few people who will be cut loose, but overall we're looking solid. 

There is the problem right there we are no where near a premiership and the recruiters are happy with themselves. We need people who set standards not lower them.