POST GAME: Rd 06 vs Richmond

[defuture15 899]

Did we rely on the runners direction more than any other team? If so why didnt we instruct our players to manage themselves on the field?

[Seraph 1,824]

2 minutes ago, Moonshadow said:

Which one are you?

I'm the one not blaming people for being concerned about us seemingly going off a cliff.

We made a prelim last year.

At them moment we look like we'll be lucky to win 5+ games.

[Deesprate 1,324]

I flew down from the Goldy for this game. I think there was effort but the cattle in that team is so poor. The fact are we are looking at an extended period at the bottom. Please Mr President (Mr Invisible) move heaven and earth to get a Roos type to help Goodwin. This is more than the coach there need to be a complete overhaul. My highlight was sharing a lift with Neita and Hoppy after the game. Hoppy been in a good paddock!

[Dame Gaga 2,453]

53 minutes ago, Leoncelli_36 said:

If you want to spew up , watch Goodwins presser. He is positive and thinks we are moving in the right direction

Remember that TV show called Spin City? Gave everyone the blueprint for press conferences.

[Adam The God 30,259]

2 hours ago, Clintosaurus said:

Goody needs to get an explanation from the umpires boss on the massive inconsistencies between how we are umpired compared to the opposition every week. It is ridiculous.

Are we seriously blaming the umpires? There were inconsistencies both ways tonight.

[Demonsone 2,037]

Question is why has this team unravelled in less than 6 months??

You don't lose talent, Im questioning on what shape did they turn up to pre season??

Roos dosent make statements without knowledge of something going on

[Moonshadow 17,676]

5 minutes ago, Seraph said:

I'm the one not blaming people for being concerned about us seemingly going off a cliff.

We made a prelim last year.

At them moment we look like we'll be lucky to win 5+ games.

Are you the emotional one (one of many) looking for scapegoats? 

Edited April 24, 2019 by Moonshadow

[Hellaintabadplacetobe 4,294]

Being there for the ANZAC ceremony was a very moving experience, the first quarter whilst not pretty was some of the hottest footy in any match this year.

The following 3 quarters was just a putrid,  mistake-ridden game of  footy , the crowd was as flat as I've ever seen 70k plus in my life.  

We are a very ordinary team, most likely bottom 4.

 

[Dr. Gonzo 24,219]

1 hour ago, DemonOX said:

At least goody tried something different tonight and our defence was better. 

Our forward line is still dysfunctional and our mids still don’t run hard enough both ways. 

The tigers do move the ball forward really well and run and spread hard all 4 quarters. Maybe it’s something we can learn from. 

I think our mids busted a gut tonight. But the difference between us and the Tigers is they play smarter. They stick to their structures so theyre not constantly sprinting back and forth across the field. By midway through the 3rd our mids were stuffed from and the Tigers ran over us.

Every time the Tigers won possession of us they had someone set up across half back and someone else on the back corner of the square. Our guys had to sprint to make position every time then when we inevitably turned it over due to poor decision making/poor disposal they had to sprint back to cover their opponents. There's only so long you can keep doing that until it catches up especially with no reward.

I don't think you can say we didn't try tonight. But trying is the bare minimum. We need to learn to play smarter and get rewarded for our effort. We can't kick 1 goal for a half of footy and expect to win games

[dl4e 5,851]

I simply cannot explain the logistics of the MFC. They have become a nightmare to watch.

The fumbling tonite was alien.

[titan_uranus 25,020]

We asked Goodwin to make positional changes. He did. 

We asked him to loosen the aggressive nature of our forward press. He did. 

But we still stank. 

To me, tonight was proof that our fitness levels are deplorable. We were out on out feet in the third. They ran us off our legs. Our fitness issues must surely run deeper like Roos has suggested.

The effort was there, the attempts to spread and run two ways were there in the first half, but as we tired in the third quarter we fell apart.

Combining our lack of fitness with repeat turnovers leads to no confidence and it just spirals from there. 

I reckon Viney turned literally every one of his kicks over. He isn’t learning from previous mistakes and he’s trying to will himself into form by breaking tackles, but failing. 

Hibberd’s defensive job on Dusty was impressive but I think he also turned all of his kicks over. 

Our forward line is a shambles. We have no one leading at the ball carrier, which contributes to the turnovers. We have no one who can take a contested mark. We tried to bring forward pressure but ANB, Garlett and Hunt failed. Weideman is hopelessly out of form. Petracca was terrible. Tim Smith is a VFL player. 

We won’t get anywhere until we get 22 fit players, some forwards who lead at the ball and hold their marks, and we start lowering our eyes and hitting targets.

[Moonshadow 17,676]

1 minute ago, Dr. Gonzo said:

I think our mids busted a gut tonight. But the difference between us and the Tigers is they play smarter. They stick to their structures so theyre not constantly sprinting back and forth across the field. By midway through the 3rd our mids were stuffed from and the Tigers ran over us.

Every time the Tigers won possession of us they had someone set up across half back and someone else on the back corner of the square. Our guys had to sprint to make position every time then when we inevitably turned it over due to poor decision making/poor disposal they had to sprint back to cover their opponents. There's only so long you can keep doing that until it catches up especially with no reward.

I don't think you can say we didn't try tonight. But trying is the bare minimum. We need to learn to play smarter and get rewarded for our effort. We can't kick 1 goal for a half of footy and expect to win games

Very important difference

[titan_uranus 25,020]

I will say this - we’re a better chance of turning things around by focusing on defence first and trying to add attack, rather than the other way around. 

And I thought Hore was great again and is showing signs of a positive future.

[dazzledavey36 54,944]

2 minutes ago, titan_uranus said:

I will say this - we’re a better chance of turning things around by focusing on defence first and trying to add attack, rather than the other way around. 

And I thought Hore was great again and is showing signs of a positive future.

I saw play against Box Hill and he was very ordinary. Ever since he has come back into the side hes almost been our best defender along with Frost and Salem.

Cant wait to see how he develops. 

[Seraph 1,824]

8 minutes ago, Moonshadow said:

Are you the emotional one (one of many) looking for scapegoats? 

Not looking for scapegoats.

Just wanting to try and understand where it's all going wrong.

Love this team, really hurting to see them down like this to be honest.

[WERRIDEE 5,479]

We have nothing up forward. Weid is a bust too slow can't take a grab. Petracca is rubbish the rest stank too. May deserves a massive kick up the [censored] for what he has put us through. Great game by Tommy Mac he's a better defender than forward, Hore played well. Gawn is is a great ruckman the rest make too many mistakes. We are crying out for Hogan and Kent and they are at different clubs.

[Adam The God 30,259]

What I find scary and staggering is that we've gone from the 4th best side in the competition, to dead set last over the space of one off season. Is that some kind of record?

[ThreeOneSix 954]

Hore was really good. I thought Fritsch was one of our best. Too many players turned it over. Nearly all. Fritsch is one of very few who doesnt rush. Id put him in the midfield, as far as im concerned he is one of our top 3 best players. 

Our side is embarrassing. Goody should drop Oliver, Petracca and Gus and send them to play VFL, and learn that the big scary game of footy isnt all that scary. You can hold on to the ball and find the best option, you arent going to die with the ball in your hand so you dont have to rush everything.

Edited April 24, 2019 by ThreeOneSix

[Dame Gaga 2,453]

1 minute ago, A F said:

What I find scary and staggering is that we've gone from the 4th best side in the competition, to dead set last over the space of one off season. Is that some kind of record?

Melbourne are specialists at breaking records.

[dazzledavey36 54,944]

1 minute ago, ThreeOneSix said:

Hore was really good. I thought Fritsch was one of our best. Too many players turned it over. Nearly all. Fritsch is one of very few who doesnt rush. Id put him in the midfield, as far as im concerned he is one of our top 3 best players. 

Our side is embarrassing. Goody should drop Oliver, Petracca and Gus and grrt them to play VFL, and learn that the big scary game of footy isnt all that scary. You can hold on to the ball and find the best option, you arent going to die with the ball in your hand so you dont have to rush everything.

What game were you watching? Fritsch was bloody horrible. Hence why Goody had to take him out of our backline in the last qtr because he was plain shithouse.

[At the break of Gawn 4,460]

Couple of observations:

a) I respect Goody for making a few changes, but there's a fine line between sticking to your guns (and the plan you have laid out all summer) vs looking desperate. Some of the changes he made tonight smelt of desperation. Notably Brayshaw didn't attend one centre bounce. Not one. And he is our best centre bounce player. Tmac going back made our forward line as impotent as a 95yo man in a nursing home.

b) Goodwin keeps on banging on about "Connection". The reason we can't connect with our forward line all comes down to the very last possession going into the 50. We have guys like Oliver who slams it on the boot and bombs it in high, Brayshaw blindly kicking around corners, Viney who rarely makes a good decision with ball in hand. We need that last possession to go to someone with class who can dispose of it. The only people I can think of is Salem and Melksham otherwise the ball is going to keep on bouncing back out of there. Tom Lynch (Ade) is a great example of a connector, Watts was also pretty decent at it as well (he was ranked 1 for kicks that get retained inside the F50 in 2017). 

c) Richmond's pressure is elite. This makes their back 6 look amazing (although they are good in their own right) as every kick forward from the opposition is under pressure. Collingwood's game plan of keeping off is the only way to beat them. Unfortunately our skill level across the board is so below the Pies we could never execute that game plan

d) Richmond home games are horrible for anyone with a GA membership. Since how they have 98k members there's barely any GA seats left because they've farmed out any decent seats as reserved. 

Edited April 24, 2019 by At the break of Gawn

[At the break of Gawn 4,460]

10 minutes ago, titan_uranus said:

I will say this - we’re a better chance of turning things around by focusing on defence first and trying to add attack, rather than the other way around. 

And I thought Hore was great again and is showing signs of a positive future.

We worked on that transition from defensive side to an attacking side over 3 years though... 2014-2016

[Leoncelli_36 2,264]

I miss Cameron Pederson 

[Dr. Gonzo 24,219]

1 hour ago, dazzledavey36 said:

 

We've completely lost our mojo. We were the highest dcoring team under Rooke. Its not him. Something isn't right internally.

The only one who looked like who gave a [censored] and tried to create options was Tim Smith

Take out Hogan, Hannan, Vandenberg and TMac in the worst form of his career and who is going to take a mark in our forward line? We can't score because we can't mark/contest inside 50.

Edited April 24, 2019 by Dr. Gonzo

[ThreeOneSix 954]

3 minutes ago, At the break of Gawn said:

Couple of observations:

a) I respect Goody for making a few changes, but there's a fine line between sticking to your guns (and the plan you have laid out all summe) vs looking desperate. Some of the changes he made tonight smelt of desperation. Notably Brayshaw didn't attend one centre bounce. Not one. And he is our best centre bounce player. Tmac going back made our forward line as impotent as a 95yo man in a nursing home.

b) Goodwin keeps on banging on about "Connection". The reason we can't connect with our forward line all comes down to the very last possession going into the 50. We have guys like Oliver who slams it on the boot and bombs it in high, Brayshaw blindly kicking around corners, Viney who rarely makes a good decision with ball in hand. We need that last possession to go to someone with class who can dispose of it. The only people I can think of is Salem and Melksham otherwise the ball is going to keep on bouncing back in there. Tom Lynch (Ade) is a great example of a connector, Watts was also pretty decent at it as well (he was ranked 1 for kicks that get retained inside the F50 in 2017). 

c) Richmond's pressure is elite. This makes their back 6 look amazing (although they are good in their own right) as every kick forward from the opposition is under pressure. Collingwood's game plan of keeping off is the only way to beat them. Unfortunately our skill level across the board is so below the Pies we could never execute that game plan

d) Richmond home games are horrible for anyone with a GA membership. Since how they have 98k members there's barely any GA seats left because they've farmed out any decent seats as reserved. 

Melksham is a great kick but we had him in the midfield early and he turned it over too much. We need a cool head in the midfield. I can only think of Fritsch.