Just now, Patches O’houlihan said:

Pick 11 33 and 2019 first rounder for may and Kolo?

so effectively it’s 11, 16-18 and 33 

 

its possibly overs but if we bring in May and keep 5 I am okay with that 

If we lose Hogan & Tyson and get May, Preuss , Kolodjashnij and PICK 5, then Trade Week is a huge tick.

7 minutes ago, red and blue forever said:

OK, so no to the Tyson part of the deal.

 

How about

 

So now, how about...

Neale to brisbane for 5

hogan to Freo for 5, 11

Kent to saints for pick 39

Kelity, 11, + 39 - for May and KK

or

11, 36 and 39 for May and KK

 

?? should get it done...

Who said they want Keilty. But if he did and they did, it's a  yes from me.

Suns will get a high compo pick for May if they hold onto him next year.

I very much doubt they will take 11 and change.

1 minute ago, johndemonic said:

Tuned in to the trade radio to see what they were saying the picks just to kill some boredom, and they're debating gary rohan being top 8 in geelong or not. FMD

More like FGD

3 minutes ago, Redleg said:

They won't get the pick 3 comparable if they go up the ladder a few spots and it could be 7 or 8 at best.

Therefore 11 is not that far away and they are pretty desperate to put this to bed this trade period and not have the disruption next year.

I would not lose Sam Frost and that is way overs anyway.

11 is possibly unders so maybe we sweeten the deal with a later pick.

Port were willing to give overs to get pick 6 mate! Losing 11, Frost and our 2nd round pick or so is going to be far more pallatable than watching an elite pick 5 talent in other colors.

Edited October 11, 20186 yr by johndemonic

4 minutes ago, Perago Validus said:

Pick 39 from saints is for Hannebery, Kent will be for a pick 50+

Gold Coast will demand Pick 5, if May leaves next year as a FA they'll get a first round compo which would be pick 2 if they finish last.

Pick 5 is fair for May and KK.

And if they win the flag pick 19. So GCS are gambling that they will be worse next year? A bird in the hand.

6 minutes ago, The Chazz said:

Which is basically the same as what @mauriesy said, which you challenged, then started talking about cars.  Ok.

You don't like cars?

If Rohan is in your top 8, then you are in serious trouble.

 

2 minutes ago, Demonland said:

If we lose Hogan & Tyson and get May, Preuss , Kolodjashnij and PICK 5, then Trade Week is a huge tick.

I agree completely. We pay overs that trade but win overall. 

24 minutes ago, Jibroni said:

Would Gold Coast accept 11 and 30 something for May when they can get more next year?

I think Pick 5 may have to be used.

Quite possibly.  As much as Id like to take 5 to the draft,  I'm not against something like pick 5 for May, pick 19 and pick 29 or similar. 

Would leave us with Hogan for May and Picks 11, 19 and 29.

 

18 minutes ago, johndemonic said:

How about Sam Frost and a pick in the 30's with 11? I'm not sure i'd take that as a GC fan. They'd probably only take 5 as they can't be bothered asking for more to bring it to that pick 3 comparable trade that they'd get next year. Pick 11 couldn't possibly be on their agenda without A LOT of sweetness.

Frost is actually a very good idea. Bringing in May makes either Frost or Oscar surplus to our needs (a little like Tyson). GCS will need an immediate defender replacement. 

11 and Frost for May might be agood result for all parties (clubs and players).

18 minutes ago, The Chazz said:

What about Pick 11, and MFC 2019 First Round Pick, for May, KK and Pick 19?

When we win the flag next year that is just pick 11 for May and KK! If they aren't happy with 11 for May, they won't go for this. 

Edited October 11, 20186 yr by deanox

4 minutes ago, johndemonic said:

Tuned in to the trade radio to see what they were saying the picks just to kill some boredom, and they're debating gary rohan being top 8 in geelong or not. FMD

most astounding thing is that trade radio is classified as "Award Winning"

3 minutes ago, demon191919 said:

I really can't imagine GC accepting pick 11 for May - do people really see this happening? 

Considering they would almost certainly get a pick between 1-5 as compo next year.. Hope I'm wrong, though! 

Think we also need to consider the relationship between May and GC right now. Yes, they may get better compensation next year but they may also want to say goodbye this year as he hasn't treated them particularly well with no decision yet on whether he's staying or going. At least I'm hoping that might be the case.

GC won't cop pick 11 for Steven May, nor should they. 

 

Pick 5 is a good result for all parties. Get it done!

4 minutes ago, Demonland said:

If we lose Hogan & Tyson and get May, Preuss , Kolodjashnij and PICK 5, then Trade Week is a huge tick.

Kent out as well, but also manage to keep AVB!

15 minutes ago, hells bells said:

We were never going to get 5 & 6 for Hogan.  We might now get 5 & 11.  11 To be on traded for May.  

5 we can take to the draft or deal with Adelaide for 13 and 21 or similar. 

why would gold coast accept pick 11 for may when they get a top 3-5 pick for him next year through afl compensation. do your research! 

4 minutes ago, Redleg said:

Who said they want Keilty. But if he did and they did, it's a  yes from me.

Kelity is just an Idea, Key back for a key back

 

1 minute ago, reynolds46 said:

most astounding thing is that trade radio is classified as "Award Winning"

Darwin Awards...

2 hours ago, beelzebub said:

Must be for you as for all your chest beating and broughahas you seem oblivious to the point.

You don't know what cards the club holds...or what it has half a hand on via other tentative deals but it's all about those magic numbers

You presume what certain picks will garner in other trades then call prematurely on something not even done yet.

Trade period is like playing darts with a revolving board. It's a fluid environment where very little is fixed.

 

It was a hypothetical question. Feel free to answer it if you like

2 minutes ago, red and blue forever said:

Kelity is just an Idea, Key back for a key back

 

Keilty and Drunkn167 is overs 

 

Edited October 11, 20186 yr by johndemonic

1 minute ago, Dr.D said:

why would gold coast accept pick 11 for may when they get a top 3-5 pick for him next year through afl compensation. do your research! 

What if they win the flag next year? AFL compo pick no better than pick 19, do your research.

1 minute ago, reynolds46 said:

most astounding thing is that trade radio is classified as "Award Winning"

... best in category for AFL trade period journalism conducted by muppets that don't require hands up their nether regions to move and speak!

5 for may would blow goats, but 11, 36 (our first pick) and sweeteners in a bundle deal (that includes KK)  is what we need to get done

8 minutes ago, johndemonic said:

Tuned in to the trade radio to see what they were saying the picks just to kill some boredom, and they're debating gary rohan being top 8 in geelong or not. FMD

They're probably just killing some boredom too.

Can't be easy waffling for hour after hour to gin up excitement over a snail race

2 minutes ago, Davos said:

GC won't cop pick 11 for Steven May, nor should they. 

 

Pick 5 is a good result for all parties. Get it done!

Except we get him for nothing next year....

35 minutes ago, Richard Tionary said:

DONE DEAL | Fremantle has traded its Rd 1 (6), and its Future Round Three Selection to Port Adelaide for its Rd 1 (11), Rd 2 (23), Rd 2 (30), Rd 3 (49)

I believe now that MFC have had this all along and know what they wanted . Freo will trade Neil today as well.